The 9 Best Water Jug Caps (2023 reviews)

We are personally inclined towards gofriipai water jug cap, it is not so pricy, but it overachieves its purpose and outstanding in important aspects. Silicone Stretch Lids are a fantastic eco-friendly alternative to traditional plastic wrap or aluminum foil. These are nice to have, easy to clean, but the inner plug pops open with little force, so if you set the full jug down to hard, it will likely come open. It reduces air leak when the bottle is put upside down.

These lids don't leak at all when placed on either. It can be stored on their sides with no fear of leaks. The inner plug opens easily. These are perfect to fit on 5 gallon refillable water jugs. These lids are great if you’re refilling your own jugs.

Why We Like This:

More plastic caps that are hard to pry off and waste money
Food grade silicone, bpa free, sturdy & durable
Material is similar to those high heat resistant silicone

Best For Plastic Water Bottles: Striludo Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cap. The striludo water jug cap is exactly that - it's a simple cap that hits all the right notes. This 3 pack-5 gallon water jug covers are made of good quality silicone and they work great so far. It fits the primo 5 gallon water jugs easily and will hold if the water jug tips over in the car. One of them has the bigger "lip" on the top, designed for press on lids, and the other is threaded for the screw-on type. They keep the water in the jug until you set it on the water cooler.

It's easy to remove and works well. They fit like a charm and it's easy to put on and take off the water bottle. It is designed to have strong sealing performance, so it will not spill, leak or overflow. This is very convenient, especially for top loading water dispensers.

Why We Like This:

Easy to get on and off
Perfect fit for primo 5 gallon 55mm lids
Great reusable caps with penetration plug
Works great for 5 gallon jugs

Best For Water Storage: MYLOLF Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

Mylolf line of cap come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. These are the caps you want, if you don't want to deal with a jug that tipped over and leaked all over. Lines up perfectly, there is enough depth to insure a good seal as they do move a bit when you’re handling them or traveling in the car. This is perfect for 5 gallon jugs of water. It works well on top loading water dispensers.

The caps hug the bottle securely. They do not leak and keep the contents inside clean and fresh. It is easy to pull off before refilling. It fits well over the cap with no issues.

Why We Like This:

Saves water and mess with no leakage
Works with the primo water jugs
Need to worry about the plug falling into the water jug at all

Best For Bottles: Fiizzot Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable cap, fiizzot water jug cap should be your first option for buying. These silicone lids are wonderful and are so much better than trying to reuse the disposable lids. It is perfect for the bottles really good. The carrying handle is just a bonus. It is perfectly fits the 5 gallon water jar and keeps it water-tight.

The silicone lids are easy to wash/sterilize between uses. It is kept tilted so it does not leak. These are great caps for your 3 to 5 gallon water bottles. It is easy to use, leafproof and the value for money is great.

Why We Like This:

Come in very handy for carrying 40 lbs
Comes with handle and easy to carry
Bpa's, no pfas, no chemical leaching like some plastic lids do

Best For American Maid Bottles: Toymis Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cap. The toymis water jug cap is exactly that - it's a simple cap that hits all the right notes. These silicone water bottle caps are very useful, widely used in home, office, school, camping, sports activities, match, etc. Love these, they fit American Maid water bottles with the screw on top. It is perfect for american maid bottles. They are easy to put on and remove and make changing out the bottles in the cooler easy.

This water jug cap has worked very well. It comes with an inner buckle that can be removed, so it can be used in a water dispenser. It is easy to clean and reusable, saving you time and energy.

Why We Like This:

Works with primo pump and american made bottles
Great option for hard to find screw on tops
Good brand reputation

Best For ordinary Plastic lids: Dippo Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cap. The dippo water jug cap is exactly that - it's a simple cap that hits all the right notes. These spill magic bottle caps prevent water to leak or spill from the water bottle, tested even on upside down jugs. It can be used on these caps is thinner and almost flimsy compared to some others. The sound is your signal that the water jug is already sealed. The silicone is pretty flexible and you just squeeze the ribbed plug into the jugs.

These replacement caps are more flexible than the original, which is great, because they stretch a bit more and hold tight. It is perfect for those who reuse their water bottles.

Why We Like This:

An awesome way to keep your water jugs clean and sanitary for reuse
More fumbling with water jug tops and breaking nails
Works and seals 3 and 5 gallons jugs

Best For Use: Frenflu Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

The 5 gallon water jug lid is flexible and pretty tight, stronger sealing than general caps, making it ensuring that drinking water can stay clean and fresh for a long time clean and safe, creating a sterile environment for clear water storage. It fits any jug with a standard 55mm opening, including 5-gallon and 3-gallon jugs. It is perfectly on a 5 gallon bottle.

The jug cap adopts an anti-spill design with strong sealing, while preventing dust from entering, keeping the water clean and safe, creating a sterile environment for clear water storage. It can be well stored on the water jug cap, which is convenient for storage and use, and you can open the kettle at any time without worrying that the bottle cap has nowhere to be placed. It is suitable for use in water jugs at home, office, transporting and camping.

Why We Like This:

Save the environment and reduce plastic waste
Spill and are super soft and easy to put on
Leak proof and air tight design

Best premium: Thinkingpower Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

Thinkingpower water jug cap is the epitome of what a great cap should be. It is perfect for 5 gallon bottles.

Why We Like This:

Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best leak proof: CUNDA Water Jug Cap

Buy on Amazon

Cunda is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist cap for people on the go, and its line of cunda water jug cap definitely falls in line with that reputation. Be nature friendly with these reusable bottle caps which will also save you lots of money with time. Thanks to its stronk sealing, this jug cap keeps dust and other dirt out of your water, keeping it clean, fresh and sterile. It is made out of environment friendly silicone, ensuring you that drinking water can stay pure and fresh for a long time.

These caps work on the 4 gallon (3.96 gallon or 512FL OZ) bottles commonly sold at grocery stores. It comes with its standard 55mm opening so it is a perfect fit for 5 gallon jugs but also for 3 gallon jugs. It is suitable for water jugs at home and in your office.

Why We Like This: