The 10 Best Whiskey Cocktail Cherries (2023 reviews)

We consider a whiskey cocktail cherry to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best With stem: Buy: Woodford Reserve Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Buy: Filthy food Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For tequila sunrise: Buy: Collins Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For Cherry pie: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For various drinks: Buy: Barrel Roll bar essentials Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For sauce: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For baking: Buy: Dirty Sue Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For desserts: Buy: Sable & Rosenfeld Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For Old Fashion: Buy: Pigeon River Whiskey Cocktail Cherry READ REVIEW

Best overall: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The cherry is a must have accessory for your daily usage. These are simply the perfect touch to create a delicious cocktail, and have become a must addition to home-made bourbon drinks. They are dark, sweet with a rich flavor and even more enticing, dense texture. The jar is fully packed with never ending delicious cherries. They have a deep rich flavor that is not waxy or artificial. They have a darker color than bing cherries and come in a luscious thick sauce which is perfect for adding to your favorite cocktail.

These are stunning in any drink or to eat as a treat. It has great flavor and texture, and are the perfect compliment to an old fashioned. It is ideal for cocktails, particularly a manhattan.

• Perfect addition to a high-end cocktail
• Great for a good bourbon or cocktail
• Good investment for long term

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The woodford reserve whiskey cocktail cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. The leftover juice is great on vanilla ice cream. They retain the taste and texture of fresh cherries with a hint of bourbon. There is a light flavor of the bourbon in it. The cherries are firm and full of flavor. The stem is what gives it a certain visual appeal for a cocktail.

These are flavorful to add to your cocktails or ice cream for dessert option.

• Great flavor while garnishing your guests cocktail
• Makes a delicious manhattan and does not contain harmful chemicals
• Good brand reputation

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Filthy food Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cherry that manages to win our hearts. It's the filthy food whiskey cocktail cherry and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient cherry you can buy. There is a lot of syrup with these cherries. They help in making the best Old Fashions. These cherries could be very good on top of a cheesecake, but the syrup they are in is thinner and the cherries themselves are not as sweet as your usual pie cherries. They last for ages so nothing goes to waste.

These cherries are a wonderful addition to cocktails. They are super flavorful and not artificially colored, which is good. The cherries have great consistency and soak up the rye in a Manhattan perfectly. They are in a heavy syrup and have fantastic flavor.

• Perfect ingredient for the perfect cocktail
• Must for your old fashions or manhattans
• Great flavor and beautiful for garnishing
• Gluten free, non gmo and vegan

Best For tequila sunrise: Collins Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Collins offers a variety of cherry for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. If you like manhattans or old fashioned cocktails, try these rich bourbon-infused cherries from collins. Formulated with professional bartenders, Collins mixers and garnishes are made with real ingredients for real cocktails. It is made from sweet, delicious fruit and preserved in syrups made with real sugar for cherries that add extra punch to manhattans, old fashioneds, and other classic cocktails.

These go above and beyond the usual bourbon cherry with an extra hit of cinnamon and spice. It is great for a tequila sunrise, since this cherry juice is richer than other maraschino cherry juice. It is perfect for manhattans or an old fashioned, collins bourbon cherries boasts a richer, more complex depth of flavor that stands up to strong cocktails better than the usual maraschino.

• Formulated with professional bartenders, collins garnishes are made with real juice and real sugar
• Hints of cinnamon and the toasty brown sugar complement whiskey cocktails and more
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For Cherry pie: Traverse City Whiskey Co Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co whiskey cocktail cherry is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily purpose. There is no better tasting cherries for your cocktails or desserts. The thick syrup adds a great sweetness and cherry pop to the drink too. The texture is nice and soft and the flavor doesn’t seem artificial, though some might find them a bit too sweet. They are also great over vanilla bean ice cream.

The jar is definitely more cherries than liquid. They are a passable substitute when you're using cheaper liquor anyway.

• Perfect addition to the old fashion cocktail,flavor is good
• Hiqh quality ingredients and great flavor
• Slightly bigger and sweeter than the luxardo cherries

Best For various drinks: Barrel Roll bar essentials Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The barrel roll bar essentials whiskey cocktail cherry is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily purpose. These dark reserve cherries are made with dark cherry juice, elderberry juice, and vanilla on top of its infusion with barrel-aged bourbon for that distinct taste you’ll love. Beyond cocktails and mocktails, these cherries are also a great garnish or ingredient for charcuterie boards, cheese plates, desserts, and cocktails. These are carefully and slowly cooked by hand in small batches to extract the most out of the fruit’s natural taste without ruining its texture.

These delicious fruits are a wonderful garnish or ingredient for charcuterie boards, cheese plates, desserts, and cocktails. It is ideal for various drinks like whiskey-made cocktails or the barrel roll old fashioned and manhattan mixes. It can also be used for a range of desserts. This large size means you have more than enough for those cherry cravings as well as your favorite recipes.

• One of the new comers and featured product
• Good investment for long term

Best For sauce: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co. whiskey cocktail cherry might be a relatively new release, but it's still nothing short of impressive this year. This really elevates your cocktail garnish, not candy sweet. They hold their shape in a cocktail and are satisfying to chew. They have a bolder and darker flavor. The syrup is very thick and dark and the cherries are also quite dark. They are packaged really well, definitely giftable. The taste is very similar to cherry pie filling. They are meaty and flavorful. They would be great in a variety of food and drinks and come in a quality container as well.

• Would also be great with soda or ice cream
• Rich, delicious cherries that are great for ice cream, beverages or just a treat
• Amazing!, delicious on ice cream and cocktails

Best For baking: Dirty Sue Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The dirty sue whiskey cocktail cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. The Dirty Sue Cherries are a step up when finishing off your Manhattan and Old Fashioned. These cherries are visually appealing and taste delicious. They go well with cake or icecream, as a classy dessert, or in a cocktail, or even as a tasty treat all by themselves.

This has everything you could possibly want in one whisky cherry and these cherries are large. They may look scary but the taste is absolutely delicious. They are large, taste amazing and crunch when you bite into them. It is perfect for old fashions and manhattans or use it to craft your own signature cocktail.

• An excellent robust cherry for your manhattan and old fashioned
• All-natural deep red color and gluten free
• Whisky is evident in flavor and effect

Best For desserts: Sable & Rosenfeld Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the sable & rosenfeld whiskey cocktail cherry has a convenient design. These Tipsy Cherries deliver on flavor and add a nice kick to drinks. It comes with stems albeit all are supposed to have them on. You will most certainly love these in your whiskey and other drinks around the house. It is perfect for garnishing cocktails or desserts.

There is NO alcohol in these cherries. The cherries themselves are definitely larger than typical maraschinos. It is a very minimal amount, probably just for a hint of flavoring and to be able to call them "tipsy.

• Perfect, big, juicy and flavorful fruit
• A great addition to manhattans, sours and old fashioneds
• Good investment for long term

Best For Old Fashion: Pigeon River Whiskey Cocktail Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The pigeon river whiskey cocktail cherry is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. It is perfect for a classic, old fashion cocktail. It is great to garnish whiskey sours, manhattans or desserts. It is great in mocktails like a roy rogers or shirley temple.

• Whiskey tinged dark burgundy colored cherries with most stems intact
• Dark red cherries for cocktails and desserts
• New and hot release