The 6 Best authentic Italian Tomatoes (2023 reviews)

Cento brand tomato products are 100% vine ripened tomatoes, picked fresh and packed immediately to preserve their authentic italian taste. The rich volcanic soil from mount vesuvius supplies the tomato plant with all the nutrients it needs. It is easy to make smaller dinners with 1 or2 cans and it’s a worthy splurge.

This is typical for all tomatoes that are canned with basil. It has a flavor all its own, really, really good taste. It is no sweetner needed as there is no tartness like most other tomato sauces. It allows for the handpicked crop to be delivered within hours after selection. These are best for making creamed tomato soup.

Why We Like This:

Excellent, sweet tomatoes that melt away wonderfully over the heat
Best canned tomatoes for sauces and curries
Best tomatoes for making a vegan sauce

Best Runner up: Strianese authentic Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

The volcanic soil where these tomatoes are grown must be magic. Just the tomatoes, with a little olive oil, garlic, salt and pepper are all you need for the best tasting tomato sauce you've ever had. As with San Marzano tomatoes, the tomatoes are sweeter, less acidic and softer. These are the best tasting tomatoes for pizza with a sweet low amount of seeds. The cans are double full of tomato instead of just juice too.

The flavor of these tomatoes are outstanding. They are whole peeled, sweet & tender. It is great for fresh style pizza at home.

Why We Like This:

Makes delicious sauce, non-acidic, great taste
Great product especially adding a can to the pot when you’re making spaghetti sauce
One of the new comers and featured product

Best premium: Mutti authentic Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

The mutti authentic italian tomato is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your daily purpose like a dream. These canned whole peeled tomatoes are the highest quality with no gmos, additives, or preservatives, which helps them break down quickly when cooked. It is made with natural goodness, you can see and taste a difference in these delicious, canned tomatoes. They are low in acidity and high in flavor with a natural sweetness that is ready for the pizza directly out of the can with a few pulses of the immersion blender.

These are harvested when perfectly ripe, then quickly preserved to retain their fresh taste and packed in their own juice. It allows the soil to recover its nutrients while cutting down on the need for natural and chemical fertilizers. It maintains a dense texture and slightly acidic flavor from the volcanic soil. It is perfect for pasta sauce and any other recipes that require whole-peeled tomatoes. It is based on partnership built on respect and dedication.

Why We Like This:

The richest, sweetest, most tomatoey flavor and great texture
Good investment for long term

Best For freshness: San Marzano authentic Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

If you like to fry your tomatoes when making certain italian sauces or heavy-bodied stews, real san marzano tomatoes are so soft and sweet that they collapse and disappear in the pan. There should be no pieces, no sauce in the can, nothing but whole, firm-fleshed tomatoes, with a little of their juice. It is 100% authentic in taste and texture. It can be added to any recipes to create a tasty dish. The flavor is fantastic and the quality is outstanding.

Why We Like This:

Sweet, low acid, great it all recipes with them
Makes very good gravy or sauce for pasta
Dairy free, gluten free, keto friendly, paleo friendly, low fat, vegan, vegetarian

Best value For money: La Bella San Marzano authentic Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

The la bella san marzano authentic italian tomato is right on the money and fits well with your daily usage. These tomatoes make fantastic pizza sauce. It is ideal for recipes with short cooking time, adding delicate & fresh flavor.

Why We Like This:

One of the new comers and featured product
New and hot release

Best Feature: Blending power: La Valle authentic Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

These are simply the "cream of the crop" when it comes to the best tomatoes in a can. The tomatoes are grown much like grapes and are picked three or four times per year between July and September. These are picked from the vines, they are rinsed and placed into cans, without any additives or preservatives. The peel, at full maturity, is easily removable.

The tomatoes have a typically sweet and sour taste, and a lively red color. These tomatoes are extremely delicate and are handled with extreme care.

Why We Like This:

Love the natural good tomato favor and taste
Good brand reputation

The 6 Best authentic Italian Tomatoes (2023 reviews)

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Cento authentic Italian Tomato

Best Runner up: Strianese authentic Italian Tomato

Best premium: Mutti authentic Italian Tomato

Best For freshness: San Marzano authentic Italian Tomato

Best value For money: La Bella San Marzano authentic Italian Tomato

Best Feature: Blending power: La Valle authentic Italian Tomato

6 Best Italian canned Tomatoes