The 7 Best Italian canned Tomatoes (2023 reviews)

We consider a italian canned tomato to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Cento Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best Tomato: Buy: San Marzano Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best For creating A classic Italian Sauce: Buy: Bella Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best For pizza: Buy: Rega Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best With authentic Italian pizza: Buy: Ciao Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Colavita Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best flavor: Buy: Stanislaus Italian canned Tomato READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Cento Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

The Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes are peeled, sweet and plump and they are superb for making pasta sauce. These items offer high quality tomatoes in a thick puree, providing a delicious flavor and thick sauce. The acidity of tomatoes also causes more BPA to leach into the food.

These are canned whole tomatoes in tomato sauce. It has a very high water table which ensures the plants get the necessary water supply throughout their growth. These are soft and melt in your mouth. It allows for the handpicked crop to be delivered within hours after selection. The tomatoes are red, ripe and luscious.

• A nice subtle, sweet flavor, fresh tasting and not bitter
• Consistent quality that delivers a smooth, non-bitter, velvety finish to any dish
• Healthier, better tasting and quality tomatoes

Best Tomato: San Marzano Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

The san marzano italian canned tomato is capable of outshining several other tomato featured in this list in overall features for the price point. These are delicious that make perfect pizza and other sauces and aren’t loaded with a ton of salt allowing the preparer to season to their palette. They taste fantastic and fresh and un-fooled-around-with. When you move or your favorite product loses it’s quality it’s a great home position to return and start the process again.

These are the only tomatoes to use in spaghetti sauce, or any marinara. The flavor is a little tart, and there's more water in here compared to better brands. They are alledgedly grown from seeds of San Marzano tomatoes and thus are likely genetically identical. These tomatoes are sweeter and less acidic.

• Is even better, producing amazing pasta sauces, pizza sauce, and the like
• Stir occasionally while crushing the tomatoes against the side of the pot
• Perfect start to the perfect pizza
• Can of bogus, counterfeit deliciousness, 5 tbsp

Best For creating A classic Italian Sauce: Bella Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

Unlike the more familiar Romas, the San Marzano tomatoes grow in volcanic soil near Mount Vesuvius, in a small town with the same name. It is long and thin, with thick, sweet flesh and fewer seeds than other tomatoes, making them perfect for sauce. The flavor is delicious and you can taste the difference compared to anything else you have probably tried. If you want a great tomato sauce, this is the best choice.

These delicious tomatoes make delicious bruchetta. It is ideal for creating a classic italian sauce. It comes with such a short season for fresh tomatoes, canned tomatoes come in handy for sauces, soups or stews. The sauce is thicker and the taste is second to none.

• Ingredients 'selected organic italian tomatoes in organic tomato puree, organic basil
• Good investment for long term

Best For pizza: Rega Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

San Marzano tomatoes are thinner and more pointed than Roma tomatoes and the flesh is much thicker with fewer seeds, and the taste is stronger, sweeter and less acidic. They are high quality with great flavor. There is a paper label on these cans. These are whole tomatoes in a thick puree, so you will typically want to use them in a smaller form. It is perfect for pasta sauce and pizza.

These are really great and whole tomatoes are so much better for cooking. They are not too acidic either, just good, clean, bright tomato flavor. It is definitely a potent additive for making your own spaghetti sauce.

• Excellent tomatoes for homemade spaghetti sauce
• Fairly sweet, low seed count, and very tender and juicy
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best With authentic Italian pizza: Ciao Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate tomato. The ciao italian canned tomato is exactly that - it's a simple tomato that hits all the right notes. It is great with caputo pizzeria flour and authentic italian pizza.

• Perfect balance of acid and sweet
• Tasted great sweet and low acidity
• Very good flavor for chili, pizza, spaghetti, chicken cacciatore

Best premium: Colavita Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

The colavita italian canned tomato is specially designed for your daily purpose and has plenty of features that are of high quality. It has defined italian cuisine more than the tomato, and this is where the expertise of colavita lies. These Italian tomatoes are garden ripened to perfection. It is perfect as a base for soup, pasta sauce, and in pizza or chili.

• New and hot release
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best flavor: Stanislaus Italian canned Tomato

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate tomato. The stanislaus italian canned tomato is exactly that - it's a simple tomato that hits all the right notes. They are a standard in Italian restaurants. They make it so easy to make a delicious tomato sauce for either pasta or pizza. A bunch of sautéed garlic, salt, pepper and these tomatoes cooked for a couple hours and puréed and you have the absolute best ever pasta sauce. It is filled with naturally sweet, tender, ultra-premium plum tomatoes in a light “naturale” style juice. If you cook with them, they are sweet and mellow after.

It is superior to other canned tomatoes including those marked as "san marzano. There is no pressure to use them all in one meal. It provides a great fresh taste.

• The best, freshest tasting canned tomato product ever
• A perfect balance of sweet and tangy acidity that provides a great fresh taste
• Good investment for long term