The 10 Best Cherries For Manhattan Cocktail (2023 reviews)

We consider a cherry for manhattan cocktail to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best With liquor: Buy: Toschi Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best With stem: Buy: Woodford Reserve Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best For Ice cream: Buy: Amarena Fabbri Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best For kir Royal: Buy: Filthy food Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best For baking: Buy: Sanniti Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Buy: six Lugs Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best For various drinks: Buy: Barrel Roll bar essentials Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best For sauce: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best Flavor: Buy: Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail READ REVIEW

Best overall: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The luxardo original maraschino cherries cherry for manhattan cocktail is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features. If you want to make the perfect manhattan, luxardo cherries are a must. These exceptional candied cherries are an exclusive italian import with unbeatable flavor. They hold well in the fridge, but put them in a cold part of the fridge. The flavor is deep and rich and NOTHING like any candy-apple-red maraschino cherry you've ever had.

The Luxardo cherries are deep and luscious and real-cherry-tasting, have an extraordinary firm texture, and subtle rich fragrance. There is a good deal of dark red syrup, which is delicious as well. If you're going to use a lot of them-even over months-this is way more economical than the small jars.

• Best cherries for making an old fashion
• Good brand reputation

Best With liquor: Toschi Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable cherry, toschi cherry for manhattan cocktail is your end point. Maraschino cherries are boring and gross in comparison to these perfectly textured and slightly sour cherries. They pack a super cherry flavor that pairs well with many different foods and beverages. It shines as a glaze for pork or chicken and will even turn Brussel sprouts into a favorite side.

These are the best cherries for the perfect Manhattan drink. The cherries themselves are so good it's hard to use only three in a manhattan or old fashioned. It is great in yogurt or tarts. The cherries have a complex flavor that pairs well with many different foods and beverages.

• Delicious, great as an easy dessert
• Great value good flavor, dark and rich for cocktails
• Excellent value for a high quality product with great taste and texture
• Delicious dark cherries in a wonderful syrup

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for appropriate and satisfactory cherry, woodford reserve cherry for manhattan cocktail should be your first option for buying. These are perfect for an old-fashioned cocktail. They add a distinct, dark cherry flavor to your drink. They have the stems for easy finding and picking out of your drink. The leftover juice is great on vanilla ice cream. They have the perfect amount of sweetness and the bourbon inside can be mixed into the drink.

It is great for entertaining, 1 jar lasts approx 2 nights of drinks for a group of. They are not excessively sweet which is nice. It adds to the perfect blend of flavors.

• Very tasty addition to an old fashioned or any other cocktail
• Save the juice and reduce for dessert topping
• New and hot release

Best For Ice cream: Amarena Fabbri Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

Amarena Fabbri has been making great cherry for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. It is the pinnacle of cherry indulgence, adaptable to a variety of uses that food industry aficionados want to create memorable culinary delights. They are meaningfully sweeter than the Luxardos, and they are not quite as dense. They can stand up to the alcohol and the naturally slight boozy note to the flavor of course makes them integrate perfectly.

These are dark red cherries covered in a very thick and sweet syrup. The cherries themselves are identical, and they come with more syrup. It can be used in drinks and is good enough to make chocolates. They are way better than maraschino cherries and the syrup is a great addition to desserts and cocktails. It’s delicious on plain vanilla ice cream or on top of unsweetened whip cream. The syrup is thick and yummy.

• The perfect adornment for your old-fashioned
• Great taste and the syrup is not overly sweet
• Great flavor, beautiful container that can be reused for various things if you want
• Perfect in manhattans or fruit cake too

Best For kir Royal: Filthy food Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The filthy food cherry for manhattan cocktail is suitable and reliable and fits well with your regular usage. These cocktail cherries are absolutely wonderful. They make the best Manhattans and Old Fashioneds ever. The cherry juice is a real plus it would be easy just to put the cherries and some light juice and call it quits but they took it to the max. The syrup is pretty thick. It's great for kir royal or eat straight up or to top a dessert. These are the best jarred cherries hands down. It's perfect for your bar at home.

• Great addition to the liquor cabinet
• Perfect to make an old fashioned or simply just to have a sweet snack
• Fantastic garnish to a high end cocktail

Best For baking: Sanniti Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The sanniti cherry for manhattan cocktail is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. Maraschino cherries are delicious, turn a ho-hum vanilla ice cream into tasty delight. They are excellent for cocktails. Whether you’re just looking for something sweet for breakfast or you’re decorating an entire cake, rex has the confections you desire. It is an ice cream sundae without the cherry on top.

These are perfect for an old fashioned cocktail. It is ideal for baking a fruit cake, while sliced and whole candied fruit make excellent cake toppings and designs. They are delicious and reasonably priced.

• Thick cherry sauce and delicious cherries
• Great mixing the syrup for other cocktails or mocktails
• One of the new comers and featured product

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: six Lugs Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing less than best desirable cherry, then six lugs cherry for manhattan cocktail is the one you should definitely consider, as it manages to bring a lot to the table. Six Lugs Cocktail Cherries take number one as far as texture, ideal sweetness-to-tart ratio, syrup flavor & consistency and aromatics go. Specially crafted in small batches, these old-fashioned cocktail cherries are candied and steeped in a rich syrup using only natural ingredients. It is fantastic over vanilla ice cream.

These old fashioned cocktail cherries are harvested at their peak, hand sorted, then crafted in small batches for 8 days to create the highest quality cocktail cherry. It is perfect for a manhattan or old fashioned. These go amazing in all types of beverages. It is superior to most other cocktail cherries.

• Luxardo texture with a vanilla leaning flavor
• Excellent substitute for luxardo cherries for a manhattan
• Great cherries for a whiskey cocktail
• Perfect level of sweetness with intense cherry flavor

Best For various drinks: Barrel Roll bar essentials Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

Barrel Roll Bar Essentials has been making great cherry for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. No decent kitchen or bar is complete without these premium cherries. These dark reserve cherries are made with dark cherry juice, elderberry juice, and vanilla on top of its infusion with barrel-aged bourbon for that distinct taste you’ll love. Beyond cocktails and mocktails, these cherries are also a great garnish or addition to cheese plates and charcuterie boards.

These delicious fruits are a wonderful garnish or ingredient for charcuterie boards, cheese plates, desserts, and cocktails. It is ideal for various drinks like whiskey-made cocktails or the barrel roll old fashioned and manhattan mixes. This large size means you have more than enough for those cherry cravings as well as your favorite recipes. These are carefully and slowly cooked by hand in small batches to extract the most out of the fruit’s natural taste without ruining its texture. It can also be used for a range of desserts.

• Good investment for long term
• Delivers what they promise

Best For sauce: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cherry that manages to win our hearts. It's the traverse city whiskey co. cherry for manhattan cocktail and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient cherry you can buy. If you want a perfect Manhattan, these are the cherries you need. They are big syrupy cherries. It comes with all the characteristics of seasonal tart cherries and have zero artificial colorings. It is perfectly with the tangy lemon taste and smooth whiskey burn. This really elevates your cocktail garnish, not candy sweet.

These are meaty and flavorful cherries. The taste is very similar to cherry pie filling. These would be great in a variety of food and drinks and come in a quality container as well.

• Rich, delicious cherries that are great for ice cream, beverages or just a treat
• Very good with vanilla ice cream and cocktails
• Great over ice cream and in manhattans and other drinks
• Make an exponentially better garnish for cheesecakes than canned cherry pie filling ever would

Best Flavor: Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Cherry For Manhattan Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The jack rudy cocktail co. cherry for manhattan cocktail's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. These are the best bourbon cherries. It is great for cocktails or eating right out of the jar. There are about 22 cherries per jar according to the label. It is best for old fashions. It is the ideal companion to any number of drinks, most notably those made with whiskey.

• Amazing enhancement for the best old fashions
• Very rich taste and not overpowering
• Good investment for long term