The 9 Best Cherries For Old Fashion (2023 reviews)

The latest filthy food cherry for old fashion is an absolute beast in terms of its features, and rightfully takes the top spot with ease. If you are looking for cocktail cherries, these are the absolute best for garnishing cocktails. These cherries are delicious, thick dark flavorful syrup. They last for ages so nothing goes to waste. They are super flavorful and not artificially colored, which is good. The juice is divine and needs no refrigeration. These are in thickened juice but that can be full of cherries. They are perfect for grown-up manhattan cocktails.

Why We Like This:

Great for cocktails and much richer flavor than regular maraschino cherries
The perfect garnish for a cocktail
Perfect blend of sweet and tart
Perfect ingredient for the perfect cocktail

Best For topping on cheesecake: Amarena Fabbri Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their daily purpose, but the amarena fabbri cherry for old fashion would be an anomoly. It is the pinnacle of cherry indulgence, adaptable to a variety of uses that food industry aficionados want to create memorable culinary delights. These are the best cherries ever for Manhattans and topping for cheese cakes. It’s delicious on plain vanilla ice cream or on top of unsweetened whip cream. The cherries themselves are identical, and they come with more syrup.

These are tiny sweet and delicious and come in a glass jar you can use for other things afterwards. They are great in bourbon, champagne or cosmopolitans. These are way better than maraschino cherries and the syrup is a great addition to desserts and cocktails. It can be used in many ways.

Why We Like This:

The perfect adornment for your old-fashioned
Good brand reputation

Best With stem: Evan Williams Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Evan Williams offers a variety of cherry for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. These Bourbon Cherries Make the Drink. They have a perfect amount of bourbon flavor with a nice vanilla flavor. The cherries and the syrup are delightfully thick and rich, sinking deep into the cocktail with a lasting masculine sweetness. The smell and taste are excellent. These are the types of cherries you get in true bars that take pride in their cocktails.

These stemmed cocktail cherries are the ideal gift for parties, housewarming, weddings, birthdays, or just as a surprise gift for cocktail connoisseurs. It's a tiny bit overpriced but the flavor is fantastic. This really makes an exciting cocktail.

Why We Like This:

Perfect finish to an old fashion
Beautiful presentation, not overly sweet, and does not overpower your drink
Makes the best old fashions ever

Best For baking: Sanniti Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

The sanniti cherry for old fashion is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. Maraschino cherries are delicious, turn a ho-hum vanilla ice cream into tasty delight. Whether you’re just looking for something sweet for breakfast or you’re decorating an entire cake, rex has the confections you desire. They are delicious and reasonably priced.

These are really good and perfect for old Fasioneds. It is ideal for baking a fruit cake, while sliced and whole candied fruit make excellent cake toppings and designs. They are in thick syrup and they are delicious. These are perfect for an old fashioned to make it taste like what's made in bars. They are perfect for an old fashioned to make it taste like what's made in bars.

Why We Like This:

Thick cherry sauce and delicious cherries
Great mixing the syrup for other cocktails or mocktails
Good investment for long term

Best With liquor: Traverse City Whiskey Co Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The traverse city whiskey co cherry for old fashion is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. Premium Cocktail Cherries make the difference between a mediocre drink and a sublime cocktail. It is sweet and savory, without the sticky and acrid taste that waxy imitations have. It comes with all the characteristics of seasonal tart cherries and have zero artificial colorings. The texture is nice and soft and the flavor doesn’t seem artificial, though some might find them a bit too sweet.

These are a bit firmer, with a taste that is comparable. The syrup makes a fantastic ice cream topping. It is best for cocktail drinks. It is best for old fashioned’s.

Why We Like This:

Slightly bigger and sweeter than the luxardo cherries
Great flavor and finish for a favorite cocktail
Good brand reputation

Best For Whiskey: Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the jack rudy cocktail co. cherry for old fashion has a convenient design. These cherries are SO delicious. It is good as a luxardo in cocktails. It is great for cocktails or eating right out of the jar. There are about 22 cherries per jar according to the label. It is the ideal companion to any number of drinks, most notably those made with whiskey. These are the best bourbon cherries.

Why We Like This:

Very rich taste and not overpowering
Amazing enhancement for the best old fashions
New and hot release

Best For One or two A day: Bourbon country Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

The bourbon country cherry for old fashion is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features for the price point. These bright red cherries are particularly useful for topping colorful creations like shirley temples, ice cream sundaes, and fruit salads. They go wonderful in cocktails but are perfect topping a dish of ice cream too. They really move the drink to the next level.

These cherries are delicious. They're large, sweet and not too "bourbon-y. They are nice maraschino cherries with a small hint of bourbon. It can be used in non-alcoholic beverages (fruit juices, carbonated drinks etc), but there will be a smaller bourbon taste noticeablity than enjoying the cherries alone or in alcoholic beverages. It is great in cocktails or pineapple upside down cake.

Why We Like This:

Celebrated by making an old fashion and it is delicious
Very nice glass container which can be reused many times over
A perfect gift for a housewarming and holidays

Best For lovely presentation: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co. cherry for old fashion is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily purpose. These whiskey cherries taste so good in old fashioneds. They bring back all the good memories of summers in Traverse City, beaches, starry nights, and drinks with friends. The cherries themselves have a deep, rich flavor without the sugary gag of maraschinos. They do not taste like maraschino cherries or sugary cherry pie filling. The syrup is a nice topper for brownies or vanilla ice cream. They come in a branded box that protects the glass jar and makes for a lovely presentation.

It is so deep, it's almost black. The flavor is very sweet.

Why We Like This:

Rich thick syrup even goes great on ice cream
Super easy way to level-up your home cocktail game
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Eli mason Cherry For Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their daily usage, but the eli mason cherry for old fashion would be an anomoly. It won’t take you longer than a minute to prepare a glass of delectable, boozy, flavorful old fashioned with eli mason old fashioned cocktail drink mix. These are made with premium, all-natural ingredients so you can be sure that your cocktail never has anything artificial in it, ever. It is perfect for cocktails and over ice cream. It is 10oz and contains approximately 20 cherries.

Why We Like This: