The 9 Best Cherries To Use In An Old Fashion (2023 reviews)

The luxardo original maraschino cherries cherry to use in an old fashion is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features. These are the very best Maraschino cherries for a cocktail. The syrup that the cherries sit in make a great flavor addition to cocktails. They are dark, sweet with a rich flavor and even more enticing, dense texture. The juice will crystallize, making them less appetizing in appearance. It is ideal for cocktails, particularly a manhattan.

The jar is not too large to store in the fridge, and the wide mouth allows easy access. The jar is fully packed with never ending delicious cherries.

Why We Like This:

Perfect addition to a high-end cocktail
Makes the quintessential old fashioned perfect
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For Bourbon: Filthy food Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Filthy Food has been making great cherry for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. These are the best jarred cherries hands down. The cherries make the best Manhattans and Old Fashioneds ever. The cherry juice is a real plus it would be easy just to put the cherries and some light juice and call it quits but they took it to the max. The syrup is pretty thick. These are the absolute premium cherries to compliment a beverage (Manhattan) or dessert. The Cherries are great and perfect for old fashioneds. It is great for kir royal or eat straight up or to top a dessert.

Why We Like This:

Add to make a great "old fashioned, " delicious flavors
Delivers what they promise

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for appropriate and satisfactory cherry, woodford reserve cherry to use in an old fashion should be your first option for buying. These are basically slightly nicer maraschino cherries. The product makes a good cocktail garnish, better taste than typical maraschino cherries. It is used for making "old fashioned" cocktail, and topping for ice cream sundae. The stem is what gives it a certain visual appeal for a cocktail.

It is made from natural ingredients, these cherries bring a brightness along with hints of kentucky's finest bourbon to recipes. The leftover juice is great on vanilla ice cream. They are perfect for cocktails. They are not excessively sweet which is nice.

Why We Like This:

Great addition to desserts and highballs
Great flavor while garnishing your guests cocktail
New and hot release

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Evan Williams Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

The evan williams cherry to use in an old fashion should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These Black Cherries really make a Manhattan. They add the perfect flavor in just 1 cherry and a teaspoon of juice. The cherries are dark and delicious and have their full stems which makes them a perfect match for a delightful cocktail. The smell and taste are excellent. The cherries are plump and perfectly soaked in a delicious brandied juice so they work perfectly blended with an orange for the perfect Old Fashioned.

The cherries and the syrup are delightfully thick and rich, sinking deep into the cocktail with a lasting masculine sweetness. It works well putting a few drops in a drink. These are great with a manhattan made with evan williams single barrel bourbon and evan williams bitters.

Why We Like This:

Beautiful presentation, not overly sweet, and does not overpower your drink
Not overly sweet like a maraschino but more complex and layered
Makes the perfect compliment to your drink
Very fine cherries for old fashions

Best For So many different recipes: Traverse City Whiskey Co Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co cherry to use in an old fashion should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. It makes it difficult to get cherries out of a jar. It is used to go snow boarding in the winters up in traverse city. The cherries would be great in cocktails, on ice cream, on top of a cake or cupcake, or just by themselves. They are really good and perfect for cocktails. A few drops of the syrup in the drink will elevate your cocktail and have people impressed with your creation.

These cherries have a great flavor and are great in Old Fashions. They are very rich and almost candied and in a syrup type liquid. It is good for a desert ice cream topping though.

Why We Like This:

Delicious treat to add to sprite or alcoholic drink
Tasty and necessary for a classic old fashioned or other cocktail drinks
Adds incredible flavor and presentation to craft old fashioned cocktails

Best For Old Fashions: Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The jack rudy cocktail co. cherry to use in an old fashion is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. These cherries are SO delicious. It is great for cocktails or eating right out of the jar. There are about 22 cherries per jar according to the label. It is the ideal companion to any number of drinks, most notably those made with whiskey. These are the best bourbon cherries.

Why We Like This:

Amazing enhancement for the best old fashions
Very rich taste and not overpowering
Good brand reputation

Best For Ice cream: Roland foods Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Roland Foods offers a variety of cherry for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. The Luxardo Marasca Cherries are actually a somewhat different cherry, but also delicious. Its syrup is much, much thicker. It comes with a sweet and slighly sour flavor and a beautiful dark red color, and amarena cherries are a wonderful addition to sweets. It is ideal for use in food service or in the home.

This is the happy medium between the neon-red, sugar bomb monstrosities and the luxurious, perfectly balanced Luxardo. The thick syrup is also a great additive flavoring to your cocktails or dishes. The cherries are very good quality. This is the most cost-effective way to purchase cherries.

Why We Like This:

Use them in drinks cookies, scones, with chicken, etc
Great for cocktails & other things
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For lovely presentation: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

Traverse City Whiskey Co. is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist cherry for people on the go, and its line of traverse city whiskey co. cherry to use in an old fashion definitely falls in line with that reputation. These whiskey cherries taste so good in old fashioneds. They come in a branded box that protects the glass jar and makes for a lovely presentation. It has a much more complex and intense cherry flavor. It comes with all the characteristics of seasonal tart cherries and have zero artificial colorings. The cherries themselves have a deep, rich flavor without the sugary gag of maraschinos.

These cherries are way more delicious than the standard maraschino cherries you can get in the grocery store. Great taste and flavor and more importantly the cherries have a really good texture/form. These would be a great addition to a gift basket or just alongside a nice bottle of bourbon.

Why We Like This:

Super easy way to level-up your home cocktail game
Rich thick syrup even goes great on ice cream
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Eli mason Cherry To Use In An Old Fashion

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention eli mason cherry to use in an old fashion for daily purpose. It won’t take you longer than a minute to prepare a glass of delectable, boozy, flavorful old fashioned with eli mason old fashioned cocktail drink mix. These are made with premium, all-natural ingredients so you can be sure that your cocktail never has anything artificial in it, ever. It is 10oz and contains approximately 20 cherries. It is perfect for cocktails and over ice cream.

Why We Like This: