We consider a drain flapper valve to be a worthy investment in the long run. In the following post, we will help you to select the best drain flapper valves.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Fluidmaster Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Exact Replacement: Buy: Toto Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Easy Install: Buy: Kohler Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best With Fast Ship: Buy: Korky Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Cost Saving: Buy: Uming Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Hard Water: Buy: Essential Values Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Good Quality: Buy: Ifealclear Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Perfect Fit: Buy: Plumb Craft Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Brand Name: Buy: Oatey Drain Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Fluidmaster Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Fluidmaster drain flapper valve is the epitome of what a great flapper should be. The Fluidmaster Drain Flapper Valve has solved the flushing issue and it stopped the leak. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, it is very nice, It is very simple and has a universal design.

Finally, the fluidmaster drain flapper valve is dedicated to making the installation of its products easy and simple with a complete line of toilet repair parts including.

Almost all customers opine that the flapper is a two - inch type. Also, a few strongly agree that the flapper can adjust flush volume. Further, they say that the flapper allows for flush adjustment.

• This works well and reduces water use in older toilets.
• Replace or fix your toilet flapper with a fluidmaster toilet flapper.
• Micro ban prevents growth of harmful microbes.
• This is the #1 toilet repair brand in the world.

Best For Exact Replacement: Toto Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing but a valve that is reliable, this Toto Drain Flapper Valve is certainly a wise investment. The toto drain flapper valve can do for customer service, It is made for easy fit and has an easy installation design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, the valve works as advertised and it is a simple fix.

Lastly, the toto drain flapper valve is built with clear instructions, It has saved money and has a true design.

Almost all customers opine that the valve is from Toto, which is a Japanese company. And, they say that the valve will last a long time. In addition, a few also found that the valve will work on your toto toilet model sw723crj.

• The photos in this listing accurately show the original flapper colors and matching numbers.
• This is exactly the same thing and works great.
• The flapper prevents leakage by being very flat and very soft.
• This flapper requires adjustment during installation per the included configuration guide.

Best For Easy Install: Kohler Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Kohler Drain Flapper Valve for daily purpose. The kohler drain flapper valve comes with a float used in various 1.6 gpf two piece toilets. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, it works as advertised, it is easy to attach and has a true design.

The valve works great, it is easy to instyall and has a very good design. Most importantly, the kohler drain flapper valve is compatible with the following kohler models.

Most customers found that the valve can be used on koller toilet, good fit. And, a few also found that the flapper has a slightly different design than basic flappers. And, they strongly agree that the flapper is soft and slips easily onto the prongs, the foam float is easily moved up or down the chain, and the hook, easily closed once set, works more smoothly than the older spring clip. Therefore, buyers were eager to recommend it to friends and would-be buyers.

• These make for great replacement, pay attention and it stops the leak.
• This is an exact replacement part. It is quick and easy.
• This has provided a nice seal so far.
• It is a no-brainer to use genuine parts.

Best With Fast Ship: Korky Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Korky Drain Flapper Valve should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The korky drainflapper valve works fine, does the job, It has called a plumber and has a water saving design. Toilet tank flapper quickly fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste. In addition, the flapper can do for customer service and it works better.

The flapper provides great value, It stops the leak and has a practical design. In addition, it features rubber construction to add to that it is universal and fits 2" plastic flush valves. Above all, the korky drain flappervalve lasts longer, it is practical and has an easy installation design.

Most buyers opine that the flapper is the reason for that noise also. And, a few strongly agree that the valve can take days/weeks to get non-urgent repairs done. In addition, they say that the flapper has these fancy water - saving flapper. Obviously, this flapper passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This will already be worth its price.
• This is very happy, it is highly recommended and has an excellent design.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.

Best For Cost Saving: Uming Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

Uming offers a variety of valves for personal choice and yet maintains quality in all the variants. The Uming Drain Flapper Valve fits perfectly, it is made for cost saving and has a universal design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The quality toilet flapper will also help to save water per flush without leaking anymore.

Most importantly, the uming drain flapper valve can be installed with no tools, is coated with durable rubber and it is easy to install in seconds.

"They are a little more expensive, but will hold up much longer and are worth the extra expense. " - says, one customer. Obviously, this product passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
• This is used to remove the old leaky flapper.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.

Best For Hard Water: Essential Values Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

Essential Values line of valves comes in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. The Essential Values Drain Flapper Valve is as simple as it could get. The Manufacturer says: Our aftermarket toto toilet flapper replacement is made of high-quality rubber for a tight seal and the chain on it is made of stainless steel with a clip hook. Further, the valve is not compatible with the following two power gravity toilet models.

The valve makes for great replacement, comes with great customer service, it is easy to attach and has a universal design. Above all, the essential values drain flapper valve is good for a better price and it is highly recommend.

Most customers opine that the valve will last more than 3 years like the last one. Moreover, they also found that the flapper is easy to install in less than 10 minutes. Moreover, they also found that the valve is a silicon flapper that seals the drain securely. Overall, most buyers agree that the valve suits them best, and no one questions it.

• Get yourself a quality aftermarket flapper for toto toilets with essential values.
• It is easy to replace parts.
• This works well with toto tank.
• This is nice because the connection is all the way around and stretches to fit.

Best For Good Quality: Ifealclear Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Ifealclear Drain Flapper Valve's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The ifealclear drainflapper valve features an oversized sealing surface to fit a large 3 inch flush valve opening and all rubber seal. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, it works better and it is built with fine workmanship. Lastly, the ifealclear drain flappervalve is made of chlorine - resistant rubber for a long life.

Most buyers found that the flapper is a perfect fit for Toto cst 864, good seal, easy installation. Further, a few say that the flapper is easy to install and works great. And, a few say that the two rubber feet of the flapper are inserted on a short plastic rod and are easily removed and the chain as well, which is hooked to the toilet handle extension.

• Connect chain to the trip lever.
• Stainless steel hook and chain are included for installation.
• This is perfect for 3” flaps.
• Replace the old flapper with the new one.

Best For Perfect Fit: Plumb Craft Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The plumb craft drains flapper valve's superior materials, making sure that it ages well with use. The Plumb Craft Drain Flapper Valve works in most tank style toilets, including 1.6 gallon low - flush toilets. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, it is made with polypropylene plastic.

The flapper includes a brass ball chain and a hook. Moreover, the valve has stopped the leak, it is sturdy and has a water saving design. Above all, the plumb craft drain flapper valve is highly resistant to harsh and chlorinated water.

Almost all customers agree that the valve is easy to install and looks like it will last forever. Moreover, a few also found that the valve fits most toilets with 2" flush valves, even 1.6-gallon low flush toilets. Moreover, they strongly agree that this flapper is an adjustable water saving dial. To sum up, buyers found this to be one of the best valves for daily purposes.

• This is highly recommend, it is many more and has a universal design.
• Fits most toilets, including: American standard, kohler, glacier bay, Mansfield and many more.
• A toilet flapper is a replacement flapper that will stop your leaky toilet from running.
• 2-way mounting for brass and plastic 2" flush valves.

Best For Brand Name: Oatey Drain Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Oatey Drain Flapper Valve's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The oatey drain flapper valve can be trusted for the highest quality and it is reliable. Across a wide range of applications and projects, oatey has the drains and strainers you need to get the job done. And, the valves include preformed base drains, solvent weld shower drains, caulking and threading shower drains, shower drains for built-up showers, general purpose drains and more. Lastly, the oatey drain flapper valve is designed for use on tile shower bases where a traditional mortar bed with pvc/cpe liner requires a drain with weep holes.

• Whether solvent weld or mechanical, oatey drains can accommodate your connection type.
• Delivers what they promise.