The 7 Best Keto Mayonnaise (2023 reviews)

We consider a keto mayonnaise to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: 365 By Whole Foods market Keto Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best Runner up: Buy: Sir Kensingtons Keto Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best For sandwiches: Buy: Betterbody Foods Keto Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best For tuna: Buy: Walden farms Keto Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best premade Product: Buy: Betterbody Foods Avocado Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Walden farms Keto Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best For FRESHNESS: Buy: Chosen Foods Keto Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best Overall: 365 By Whole Foods market Keto Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The 365 by whole foods market keto mayonnaise is long-lasting, rigid and fits well with your regular usage like a dream. It is a chemical compound that is man made. It is made with organic expeller pressed canola oil. There's a slight background hint of quiet spices in the mix. It is made with canola oil and BF is made with soybean oil. It can be used as a preservative with a “tangy” taste. It comes in a glass jar compared to Bf's plastic jar. It is flavorful, not overpowering or weirdly bland.

• Modified food starch (msg), no dairy, no soy oil
• Good brand reputation

Best Runner up: Sir Kensingtons Keto Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

Sir Kensingtons line of mayonnaise come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. This is a high quality mayonnaise with no artificial ingredients. It is made with 100 percent avocado oil, a squeeze of lime juice, and a pinch of black pepper. It has a little tangy flavor but is still smooth and mellow. It is so much healthier than regular mayonnaise because of the avocado oil instead of the canola oil.

The product is creamy, smooth, and nothing in it but healthy Sunflower Oil, Egg Yolks, Organic Lemon Juice, Distilled Vinegar, Salt, Organic, Cane Sugar, Mustard Flour, Black Pepper, and Citric Acid. A foil inner seal ensures the product is fresh and untouched. The container makes application easy. This mayonnaise is thick but it squirts out easily.

• Main ingredients are sunflower oil, egg yolks, water, organic lemon juice and distilled vinegar
• Nice and creamy with a good body
• Light mayo that does not overpower food
• Squeeze bottles are easy to use

Best For sandwiches: Betterbody Foods Keto Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

Betterbody Foods line of mayonnaise come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. This avocado mayo has a slightly more tangy flavor than traditional mayo. It moistens the bread and has a mild taste. It is used to create a variety of mouth-watering dishes. This mayonnaise is delicious and doesn't have an off taste. It is a more yellow-green color as opposed to the creamy white color one normally expects in a mayo.

The flavor is excellent and very creamy. It does not have a strong avocado flavor and is a healthy substitute for regular mayo. It has pretty clean ingredients.

• Better body avocado mayonnaise is soy free and tastes great
• Worthy of regular, immediate & infinite re-ordering
• Best to limit the amount of foods prepared or restaurants

Best For tuna: Walden farms Keto Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The walden farms keto mayonnaise is capable of outshining several other mayonnaise featured in this list in overall features for the price point. This stuff tastes 95% like mayo. It offers a full line of specialty condiments and food enhancers with zero calories, zero net carbs, zero sugar, zero fat. It’s amazing on a piece of rosemary bread. It’s pretty good for egg salads.

The consistency is close to mayo, the taste is pretty good for what it is, Just add salt and pepper or whatever seasonings you want and it blends with other foods well. This doesn’t taste like real mayonnaise, but it’s not bad if you want to use it because you’re on a diet.

• Zero calories, sugar and fat free
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best premade Product: Betterbody Foods Avocado Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

Betterbody Foods is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist mayonnaise for people on the go, and its line of betterbody foods avocado mayonnaise definitely falls in line with that reputation. It is used to create a variety of mouth-watering dishes. You can use it to make dressing, aioli sauce, dip, or sandwich spread. It is non-gmo, gluten-free, soy and canola free. It is tasty and more of an alternative for regular mayo. It has just the right amount of kick so it adds (but doesn't overpower) the flavor of the other food. It can be a dip for many other veggies and even some fruits. It is just sweet enough with the coconut sugar to make it taste good, but not overwhelm. It does need to be refrigerated after opening.

• Give your food some unique, tasty flair
• Very thin, separates and has to be shook up
• Love the healthy oils and healthy ingredients
• Delicious and made with the best ingredients

Best premium: Walden farms Keto Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention walden farms keto mayonnaise for daily usage. It offers a full line of specialty condiments and food enhancers with zero calories, zero net carbs, zero sugar, zero fat. It is made with concentrated fruit extracts and natural flavors and is perfect for toast, bagels, muffins or as a mix-in with yogurt. On one hand, the chipotle flavor is very tasty and adds a nice kick to sandwiches and wraps. It pairs very well with a variety of foods, from grilled chicken to veggie burgers.

The chipotle flavor is very delicious and makes up for the differences in texture. It tastes better than plain old mayonnaise. It can be used as a binder in recipes and it works well. It is kind of thin, but you will like to use it for salads too.

• Adds a trivial amount of sugar
• Delicious and zero smartpoints if you're on weight watchers
• Good flavor for having no fat, calories, etc

Best For FRESHNESS: Chosen Foods Keto Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The chosen foods keto mayonnaise is specially designed for your regular usage and has all useful features. It's mayo heaven and tastes fabulous. It's made with cage-free eggs, as well as organic vinegar, mustard, and spices, it’s rich and slightly tangy—perfect for everyday use. It uses avocado oil instead of the standard oil commercial makers use (usually soybean, sometimes csnola), so the flavor is a bit different. It has good oils and no soy. It comes with a bit of classic organic mayo, vinegar and spices, so you've got a freshly made dressing for any dish.

THIS IS THE ONe you buy and use for all your mayo needs, no toxic Gluten, or EDTA. It tastes a little different than regular mayonnaise but it's actually quite good.

• Perfect mayo for keto, mediterranean and paleo diets
• Certified non-gmo, kosher, and gluten, dairy, soy and canola oil free
• Very good for egg, chicken salads