We consider a mtg oversized card sleeve to be a worthy investment in the long run. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best mtg oversized card sleeve for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Ultra Pro Penny Sleeve READ REVIEW

Best For Brand Name: Buy: Ultimate Guard Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve READ REVIEW

Best For Dragon Ball Super: Buy: Ultimate Guard Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve READ REVIEW

Best For Standard Size: Buy: Akashiya Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve READ REVIEW

Best For Your Mtg: Buy: Ultra Pro Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Ultra Pro Penny Sleeve

Buy on Amazon

Ultra Pro offers a variety of sleeves for personal choice and yet maintains quality in all the variants. The Ultra Pro Penny Sleeve fits perfectly and it works perfectly. Protect your trading cards from dirt and dust with ultra pro card sleeves. Also, the sleeve is really good and it can be bought for good value.

Most importantly, the ultra pro penny sleeve is durable and it is solid.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the sleeve would handle some thicker sized cards as well. Moreover, a few also found that the sleeve is perfect for the low cost. Also, a few say that the sleeve is a much better value. In conclusion, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• This is great for protecting baseball cards.
• This can hold smaller stuff but it’s more like little baggies.
• This is flimsy for playing and it works well for card storage.
• These fit basic sized playing cards.

Best For Brand Name: Ultimate Guard Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another sleeve that manages to win our hearts. It's the Ultimate Guard Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient sleeves you can buy. The ultimate guard mtg oversized card sleeve fits perfectly and it works great. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, the sleeves are too tight and it is best for double.

The sleeve is secure, is good for other oversized cards and it is used for perfect size. Lastly, the ultimate guard mtgoversized card sleeve fits perfectly and it is great for brand name.

Most buyers found that the sleeve is perfect for the MTG commander cards. In addition, a few say that the sleeve is great for transformers and large frame cards. With no doubts, this sleeve passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This comes in each pack, may vary.
• This is great for an oversized baseball card.
• This is perfect for planechase and archenemy cards.
• This is best for good fit, is inexpensive and it is perfect for magic.

Best For Dragon Ball Super: Ultimate Guard Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate sleeve. The Ultimate Guard Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve is exactly that - it's a simple sleeve that hits all the right notes. The ultimate guard mtg oversized card sleeve allows for a great fit, is designed for magic cards and it is durable. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, it is suitable for extra high clearness and it fits well.

The sleeve looks great and it is pretty durable. Lastly, the ultimate guard mtgoversized cardsleeve works great, is made of high-quality and it is acid free.

Almost all customers opine that the sleeve has opaque black backs and it is perfectly, highly recommend. Also, a few strongly agree that the sleeves can be shuffled pretty well when in the sleeves too. In short, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the sleeve suits the purpose.

• This is great for dragon ball Super and it is ideal.
• This comes in commander pre-made decks and scheme cards in archenemy.
• Sleeve size: 91 x 129 mm.
• This protects the cards and it is sturdy.

Best For Standard Size: Akashiya Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve

Buy on Amazon

The akashiya MTG oversizedcard sleeve's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The akashiya MTG oversized card sleeve fits perfectly, it is really nice and has a thicker design. High quality card sleeves from kmc, cardsleeve manufacturer in Japan, The sleeves to protect your valuable card collections. Moreover, it is durable, it works well and it comes in good condition.

The sleeve is resistant, it is very good and has a thick design. Most importantly, the akashiya MTG oversizedcard sleeve is suitable, is solid, it is perfect for nice touch and has a good design.

Almost all buyers found that the sleeve is good for double sleeving. In addition, they strongly agree that the sleeve fits, then character sleeves, then see oversized character sleeves. Also, a few strongly agree that the sleeves fit with yugioh cards if they are double sleeved.

• This will fit over dragon shield sleeves.
• It is strong, looks amazing, it is very big and has a perfect design.
• Lot of satisfied buyers.

Best For Your Mtg: Ultra Pro Mtg Oversized Card Sleeve

Buy on Amazon

Ultra Pro is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist sleeves for people on the go, and its line of Ultra Pro Mtg Oversized Card Sleeves definitely falls in line with that reputation. The ultra pro MTG oversized card sleeve feels good and it is difficult to shuffle. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, it feels great and it is very durable.

The sleeve is designed for a good fit and it allows for great fit. Moreover, this is good for top loaders and it makes for nice quality. Most importantly, the ultra pro mtg oversized card sleeve is durable, fits perfectly for magic cards and it protects the cards.

Most customers found that the sleeve fits the cards in there well and shuffles easily. Moreover, a few also found that the sleeve is perfect for your mtg archenemy scheme cards. In short, many buyers have used the sleeve for more than a few months without any issues, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This has nice sleeves, is ideal and it works great.
• This does the job and it makes for a great buy.
• Sized for oversized cards up to 3.5" x 5".
• This is very happy and it fits perfectly.