The 8 Best Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherries (2023 reviews)

The luxardo original maraschino cherries old fashioned maraschino cherry should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. Luxardo's Maraschino cherries just make every cocktail drink exquisite. They have great dark cherry flavor and a delicious, rich syrup. It is great for making legit cocktails that call for a cherry. These are the color of a red neon sign and most non-human animals won't touch them. They are great in old fashions, manhattans, and quit nearly anything else.

These are dark, intensely flavored, and the juice is divine. They are great in drinks, and the syrup also can be used to add dimension to a drink and a bit of sweetness. It is firm but not chewy and the flavor is sweet and light without the cloying and artificial sweetness of the standard cocktail cherry.

Why We Like This:

Makes the best addition to a manhattan
Best maraschino cherries for mixed drinks
Ideal for the craft cocktail maker in you

Best For bar drinks: Toschi Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The toschi old fashioned maraschino cherry is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily usage. Upgrade your cherry game with these amarena black cherries for your next old fashioned, manhattan, or chocolate martini and you won’t regret it. These candied sour black cherries are used at home and in restaurants and bars around the world. It is the most widely used cocktail garnish.

If you love a quality single barrel bourbon mixed with an ultra-premium sweet vermouth, you'll love these cherries. The syrup is runnier, and the taste and texture of the cherries are not quite as wonderful. It is perfect for desserts or bar drinks.

Why We Like This:

Amazing on vanilla ice cream or canned fruit
A great ice cream topper or drink accompaniment
Best cherries for cooking and drinks

Best With liquor: Filthy food Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their regular usage, but the filthy food old fashioned maraschino cherry would be an anomoly. If you enjoy making specialty cocktails or just a great Manhattan these Filthy Cherries will make your day. These are the absolute premium cherries to compliment a beverage (Manhattan) or dessert. It can be used by some of the best restaurants and bars in the world.

These elevate your cocktail, to a cocktale. The syrup is pretty thick. It's very sweet with a tart finish. This takes your cocktail to the next level. It is great for kir royal or eat straight up or to top a dessert.

Why We Like This:

Perfect to make an old fashioned or simply just to have a sweet snack
Fantastic garnish to a high end cocktail
Add to make a great "old fashioned, " delicious flavors

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The woodford reserve old fashioned maraschino cherry gives the top-tier cherry a run for their money by offering flagship specs at a much more affordable price. These are basically slightly nicer maraschino cherries. They retain the taste and texture of fresh cherries with a hint of bourbon. They have the stems for easy finding and picking out of your drink. There is a light flavor of the bourbon in it. The jar contains about 25 cherries.

It is made from natural ingredients, these cherries bring a brightness along with hints of kentucky's finest bourbon to recipes. The leftover juice is great on vanilla ice cream. The cherries have a wonderful cherry flavor, but no bourbon flavor.

Why We Like This:

Very tasty addition to an old fashioned or any other cocktail
Great addition to desserts and highballs
Delivers what they promise

Best For Ice cream: Filthy food Best tasting Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The filthy food best tasting cherry is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily purpose. These cherries are delicious, thick dark flavorful syrup. Refrigerating the cherries just makes the sugar crystallize. They are super flavorful and not artificially colored, which is good. They are perfect for grown-up manhattan cocktails. They are always going to be fresh and can travel easy, like camping or tailgating.

These cherries are the best for garnishing cocktails. They are all packed in a can of juice with a rubber gasket sealable lid. The juice is divine and needs no refrigeration.

Why We Like This:

Gluten free, non gmo and vegan
Perfect blend of sweet and tart
Delicious, rich sweet and sour flavor
Great for cocktails and much richer flavor than regular maraschino cherries

Best For cakes: Member'S Mark Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The member's mark old fashioned maraschino cherry's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. These are regular size maraschino cherries with stems. They taste great and make a wonderful Manhattan. Use this in a lot of christmas baking and candies, if you have need for a lot, this is the way to buy them. They make a beautiful garnish and are delicious in all recipes.

The cherries are beautiful, with the stems on them. They are great in drinks all summer long and also good solo. It is perfect for the ice cream bar at a party.

Why We Like This:

Make home made chocolate covered cherries that everyone love
Good brand reputation

Best For An Old Fashion: Tillen Farms Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The tillen farms old fashioned maraschino cherry is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily purpose. These large black marinated cherries are the best flavored on the market. It gives your cocktail cherries a unique twist at a much better value than some of the other high end cherries. The Bada Bings offer a very authentic cherry taste and the dark syrup contributes the necessary sweetening called for by the need for a maraschino. Snack on these cherries straight from the jar, use them to add a touch of glamour to bourbon and whiskey cocktails or to top off ice cream sundaes and other desserts.

These cherries make the evening cocktail a true party in a glass. It can be used in cocktails, rather than maraschino cherries. The use of bubble-wrap is efficient and the box used is the perfect size. It is perfect for an old fashion.

Why We Like This:

Best bang for your buck in cocktail cherries
Best dark cherries you can get in a bottle
Good brand reputation

Best For baking: Tillen Farms Old Fashioned Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their daily usage, but the tillen farms old fashioned maraschino cherry would be an anomoly. These cherries are delicious. It is made from bing cherries. This makes a great Manhattan add a special touch. It is used for old fashions.

Why We Like This: