The 8 Best old Nail Pullers (2023 reviews)

We are personally inclined towards stiletto old nail puller, it is not so pricy, but it overachieves its purpose and outstanding in important aspects. It is more of a luxury item than anything. It's not just the titanium that makes this worth the extra, extra cost over a typical steel cat's paw. It is designed very well to slip under a nail head and pull the nail out, with good mechanical advantage. The claws are extremely sharp and punch through anything stubborn. It can be hit by any hammer.

The curve of the head makes it difficult to pry under staples/nails with a very small protrusion. It is designed with two pulling surfaces and excellent angles for generating leverage. It is a pretty nice item if you need to pry into something or just to have something light for self defense in your pack.

Why We Like This:

Keeps pulling nails without getting dull
Lighter than any other and will stay sharper longer than steel
Good brand reputation

Best For Pulling out Nails: Bates choice Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

The bates choice nail puller is capable of outshining several other puller featured in this list in overall features for the price point. They're a very good quality end cutting pliers. They are small enough for right space and cut nails well attached to wood trim. The casting is clean without pock marks or bumps. If you have any amount of nail/staple pulling to do, this is a necessary tool.

These things are great, very sharp and can easily cut nails in hard to reach places. It is great for cutting wooden wicks. It is not too heavy to use. It is great for pulling out nails and staples as long as a little bit is sticking out of the surface.

Why We Like This:

Sturdy and sharp tool that can handle nails and staples
Easy on the hands and no pulling and jerking
New and hot release

Best For getting under Nail heads: Dead On Tools old Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another puller that manages to win our hearts. It's the dead on tools old nail puller and it's widely considered as puller that has the most suitable features. This thing pulls em out in bunches of nails, and removing each one can take up to a minute or two. It's a tool you can't live without and find more uses for all the time. The tool is burly and handy, in the sense that it feels right in the hand. It removes the nails and staples with ease. The entire deck has hundreds of nails, and removing each one can take up to a minute or two.

The best cat paw on the market the built in wrench is great plus it will cut any nail in half. This tool easily grips each nail and provides excellent leverage. It could be used for a lot of different tasks, including self defense.

Why We Like This:

Has a built in wrench for skill saw blade
Cool little tool does help remove nails from your woodwork
Works well, except for small finishing nails

Best For removing shingles: PACTOOL old Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

The pactool old nail puller should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The roof snake is a must have tool for roofing repairs, it makes replacing a single shingle a breeze without damaging outer shingles especially if your dealing with a roof that has some age on it. It works well on 3 tab roofing.

The Claw has the perfect angle for pulling tacks and the tack holder works perfectly for nailing under shingles. It works great and is perfect for nailing under the shingle and not damaging the shingle. This allows you to slip the nail underneath and hammer it in. It can reach farther more easily. This will make your job faster and easier.

Why We Like This:

Works great for replacing siding as well,especially the offset nailing lip
Great tool to remove and replace a few damaged shingles
Lightweight, strong roofing tool that works well
Well made, solid and compact and a good design

Best For remodeling or renovation projects: Crescent old Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

Crescent line of puller come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. This guy works extremely well to remove nails from wood that you want to reuse. This is an excellent tool and designed for the task of removing nails without damaging surrounding wood significantly. The extendable handle gives you plenty of leverage to pull out those stubborn nails, especially screw nails. This thing is heavy, but it pulls the nails pretty nice. This dude will never wear out and probably won't break unless you drop it from the roof onto concrete.

This product has proven itself through time-tested use and has passed with flying colors.

Why We Like This:

Great for deconstructing sets and homes
Works great and does minimal damage to surrounding wood
Works great, counter sinks into wood to grab the nail head

Best For reclaiming hardwood floor: Bates choice old Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

The bates choice old nail puller is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. These Bates Choice Nail Pulling Pliers do a great job, far more easily than a crow/pry bar or claw hammer. Because it only has one pivot point, it only grabs the nail with a small portion of the teeth making it easier to break smaller (18g) nails. It uses leverage and fulcrum point to easily pull nails, staples and screws from anything.

This tool is a real time. It’s just for pulling nails, the jaws are limited in opening width so that it can’t really be used for anything else. It is great for reclaiming hardwood floor. It is great as a secondary hammer.

Why We Like This:

A more precise, surgical approach versus a "quick & nasty hack job
Fantastic tool for a specific task
Beefy tool backed by superior support

Best For garden fence work: Honoson old Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate puller. The honoson old nail puller is exactly that - it's a simple puller that hits all the right notes. Two different shapes of tips allow them to work on various types of fasteners, help you quickly remove deeply embedded staples in your furniture, upholstery, wood, floor, industry, tire nails, nail shoes, carpentry nails, etc. This is a good set for pulling nails and clipping them off. The clipper is sharp and has clipped over 50 pin nails so far and is still sharp. The cutting pliers have a red and no-slip pvc handle, which is so comfortable for longtime use without feeling tired, and for saving a lot of your energy.

The other two pullers are small enough to get into the tight space but still sturdy enough to tap them into the gap. It comes with the nails removal pullers, you can effortlessly take off staples from wooden case, carpet, photo frame, cartons, and more.

Why We Like This:

Great reasonably priced nail remover tool set for all nails
Easier to open up hookups on fence poles
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best Nail Removal Tool: Hultafors old Nail Puller

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase puller for their daily usage, but the hultafors old nail puller would be an anomoly. It is a leading tool brand from sweden, offering reliable hand tools designed for discerning craftsmen around the world. It works well despite its small size, the atle can easily pull out a 5-inch nail, even when the head is off or buried deep in the wood. The pickets are tightly nailed with long nails which are difficult to pull out. They do minimal marerial damage, and they dont let go of the nail.

These have some old outbuildings and need to remove wood for projects. It has two leverage positions to get into those tight quarters. It has been pre-pulled out enough (about 1/8") by some other tool so that this device' relatively thick claw can take a grip. It can definitely pull pneumatic staples, maybe even better than nails some times.

Why We Like This: