There are several advantages of having a pie iron. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best pie iron for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Camp Chef Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Stainless Steel: Buy: Pinsuko Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Heavy Duty: Buy: Uno Casa Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Making: Buy: Lodge Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For High Quality: Buy: Guidesman Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best With Recipe: Buy: Colibrox Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Two: Buy: Bestnest Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Open Fire: Buy: Sphxt Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Long Handled Aluminum Sandwich Toasters: Buy: Palmer Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best For Item Size: Buy: Sleeri Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best Feature: Giftable: Buy: Rome Pie Iron READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Camp Chef Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

The Camp Chef Pie Iron is the best long-standing iron on the market today. The camp chef pie iron is used for aluminum foil, comes with a great deal, It is highly recommended and has a good design. Cast iron creates even heat distribution, giving you a golden brown crust every time. Also, this is made to meet the highest standards of quality for fit and finish.

The iron made a pie and has a functional design. Most importantly, the camp chef pie iron is let cool, It is great for even on the bottom and has a great design.

Most buyers opine that the iron is great for sauteeing, cooking eggs and home fries, etc. Also, they strongly agree that the iron fits the mini medium big green egg perfectly. In addition, they also found that this beautiful pan is a true 10 inches side to side without the handles. In short, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the iron suits the purpose.

• The manufacturer says: we’ve raised the steaks in the outdoor cooking industry.
• This is great for a small batch of rolls.
• This can happen for a couple of reasons.
• This measures 12 1/2 inches and comes out ready to use.

Best For Stainless Steel: Pinsuko Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate iron. The Pinsuko Pie Iron is exactly that - it's a simple iron that hits all the right notes. The pinsuko pie iron can see the cast iron round design crimps the bread and seals in the goodness. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The original pie iron manufacturer and has been helping make campfire memories since 1964.

The iron is made of solid cast iron construction. Above all, the pinsuko pie iron tastes better, has high quality, it is effective and has a handle design.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the iron makes toasty bread pockets sealed around creamy stuffing. And, a few also found that the iron is made of stainless steel. And, they also found that the irons themselves are cast iron and are of good quality.

• Toasts pies and sandwiches with ease.
• This is perfect for regular store-bought slices of bread.
• The iron performed very well .. no sticking and nice, even browning.
• They are easy to use and seriously yummy treats to be made with them.

Best For Heavy Duty: Uno Casa Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable iron, Uno Casa Pie Iron is your solution. The uno casa pie iron works perfectly, It is great for camping and has a nice design. A hook keeps the head securely closed while cooking to seal in flavors and protect your food. The cast iron pie iron is non - stick, highly heat & pressure resistant, and rust - free if kept dry.

The iron is convenient, it is robust and has a handle design. Finally, the uno casa pie iron is used to make hashbrowns, grilled cheese & meats, tortillas, bread rolls, and more.

Most buyers quickly discover that the iron is heavy but works great. Furthermore, a few also found that the iron is pretty heavy, especially when putting on the handle extensions. Moreover, a few say that the iron is easy to clean, and the food cooks wonderfully. In short, buyers found this to be one of the best irons for daily purposes.

• This will last a long time.
• This is good for hotdogs, burritos, a single serving of hashbrowns etc.
• This is a pre-seasoned mountain pie maker.
• No need to season your pie iron after each use.

Best For Making: Lodge Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

The Lodge Pie Iron's superior materials make sure that it ages well with use. The lodge pie iron provides excellent heat distribution and retention for consistent, even baking. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The traditionally sized lodge 9 inch seasoned cast iron pie pan is made for homemade and store - bought crusts alike.

The iron can stop your search for the perfect cast iron pie pan is over. Most importantly, the lodge pie iron features a dual handle design for easy lifting.

Most buyers find that the iron will provide a lifetime of awesome pies. In addition, they strongly agree that the iron is great for baking a few biscuits too. Moreover, a few say that this pie pan has all the advantages of cast iron as well as its disadvantages. In conclusion, for almost all customers, it was what they were looking for.

• The manufacturer says: we make memories that last for generations.
• Seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil.
• This is thicker, is made for immediate use and it is preseasoned for convenience.
• It has been making heirloom-quality cookware and accessories since 1896.

Best For High Quality: Guidesman Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where Guidesman Pie Iron truly manages to shine. The Guidesman pieiron is great with quick shipping and it makes for a perfect gift. Long-lasting cast iron head with easy open hinge. Further, it was high quality and it worked great.

Lastly, the guidesman pie iron has been used all summer and it is useful.

Almost all buyers opine that the iron is good care of and season the cast iron. Further, they say that the iron will last for many years. In conclusion, many customers have used the iron for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This is great for cooking food over a campfire.
• These make great gifts too, either in a camping-themed gift basket, or by themselves.
• This allows for great quality and it is clear.
• This is perfect for camping, good weight with a heavy - duty feel.

Best With Recipe: Colibrox Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other irons in this category, the Colibrox pie iron has a convenient design. Further, this cleans up well and it makes for easy cleaning. Have a seasoned cast iron finish on the interior of the pie iron. Lastly, the Colibrox Pie Iron measures 4-1/2" x 4-1/4" and the total length is 28-7/8.

In short, many customers have used the Colibrox pie iron for more than a few months without any issues, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• Long-lasting cast iron head with easy open hinge.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.

Best For Two: Bestnest Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

The Bestnest Pie Iron's superior materials make sure that it ages well with use. 7"l x 475"w x 175"d pie iron, 21"l handles construction. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. When it comes to finding an optimal iron, the bestnest pie iron is definitely your first choice.

• Each cast iron head has an extra large chamber, for creating larger sandwiches.
• Stainless steel rods and wooden handles keep you safely away from fire.
• Cast iron construction remains hot and cooks quickly and evenly.

Best For Open Fire: Sphxt Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

Sphxt makes beautiful and great iron with classic and smartly chosen materials. The Sphxt Pie Iron is fully attached, ensuring it does not come apart while cooking, making it much easier to handle. Maintain your cast iron pie iron by cleaning it regularly with hot soapy water using a non-metallic pad or brush and dry thoroughly. The wooden and metal handles unscrewed from the cast iron head, making it very easy to clean.

The iron has been purposefully made with long handles for protection while cooking. And, it has detachable handles for ease of transport and for cleaning the pie head. Above all, the sphxt pieiron has a detachable wooden handle that is 20 cm in length and 1.8 cm in diameter.

• This allows for even cooking, additionally makes great toasted sandwiches, desserts and meats.
• The cast iron head can be placed over a flame or nestled between coals.
• The kids will love the rainbow coloured straws.
• Already pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, so you’re good to go.

Best For Long Handled Aluminum Sandwich Toasters: Palmer Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other irons in this category, the Palmer Pie Iron has a convenient design. Further, this is designed to accomodate a standard slice of bread. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Most importantly, the palmer pie iron made using square aluminum sandwich toasters seals all the ingredients in 2 slices of bread.

• Designed to accomodate standard size slices of bread.
• 26" overall length - the handle is 18" long.
• Close iron to seal in the ingredients and toast for approximately 3 minutes.
• Seal all the ingredients into 2 slices of bread.

Best For Item Size: Sleeri Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another iron that manages to win our hearts. It's the Sleeri Pie Iron and it's widely considered as the iron that has the most suitable features. The sleeri pie iron is perfect for keeping pie irons in a single place. This is a great way to keep your pie makers clean. And, it is easy to store and has a great design.

It is great to have everything in one place. Further, the iron is just the bag to store the pie irons in, storage holders for pie irons. Above all, the sleeri pie iron has a handle that's comfortable to hold, easy to carry.

• Material: oxford cloth. Item size: approx. 33.86''x7.09''/86x18cm.
• A great way to protect the cast iron, and store your pie irons.
• Use a cast iron pie cooker, sandwich maker storage bag.

Best Feature: Giftable: Rome Pie Iron

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other irons in this category, the Rome pie iron has a convenient design. You can cook two sandwiches at a time or a calzone, fish and pastries. And, the iron can be used as a small skillet. The iron is easy to maintain and it will match with your regular use.

In short, most buyers agree that the iron is functionally comfortable and no one questions it.

• 8.5 in. X 4.25 in. Cooking head.
• This double - sized pie iron allows you to maximize cooking versatility.
• Delivers what they promise.