There are plenty of options available while buying replace tub drain gaskets in the market right now, and if you're confused regarding which one to go for, You have come to the right page.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Westbrass Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Oil Rubbed Bronze: Buy: Design House Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Perfect Fit: Buy: Danco Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best With Polished Brass: Buy: Ldr Industries Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Solid Metal: Buy: Wholesale Plumbing Supply Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For High Quality Material: Buy: Artiwell Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Tip Toe: Buy: Lasco Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Nice Look: Buy: Pf Waterworks Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Heavy Duty: Buy: Dorence Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Modern Design: Buy: Bluevue Replace Tub Drain Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Westbrass Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Here, we review a gasket that manages to win our hearts. It's the westbrass replaced tub drain gasket and it's widely considered as one of the best gaskets you can buy. The westbrass replaced tub drain gasket is built with metal construction and it works great. This westbrass designer tip-toe waste and overflow trim kit is the decorative solution and the perfect finishing touch for your tub. The product lines at the time included items such as faucets, valves, malleable fittings, etc.

Most importantly, the westbrass replaced tub drain gasket fits two-hole elbows. To add to that, it is made of the highest quality materials.

Almost all buyers found that the gasket is a great set in package. In addition, they strongly agree that the gasket works well and is so much cheaper than going to a bigbox store. Also, a few strongly agree that the gasket measures 1-7/8" - 11.5 threads per inch.

• Bath tub trim set with tip-toe drain plug and faceplate.
• Heavy duty metal construction. Do not use plumber's putty for installation, use silicone seal.
• This is built for heavy duty and it has a drain plug.
• This is easy to remove later if needed.

Best For Oil Rubbed Bronze: Design House Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The design house replaced the tub drain gasket so it should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. In addition, the design house replaced the tub drain gasket. provides quality, affordable home décor products to architects, developers, interior designers and homeowners to help create beautiful, functional living spaces. The Manufacturer says: We work directly with our factories to meet the highest standards, and our strict quality control process ensures a perfect finish for all your products. Moreover, it is built for heavy duty, It works great and has a simple design. Lastly, the design house replaced the tub drain gasket with an elegant oil-rubbed bronze color.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the gasket measures 1 7/8 inches outside diameter. Also, a few also found that the gasket is perfectly matches a peerless shower trim kit in oil rubbed bronze, also installed today. Also, they also found that the cost of the torque required for removal and installation can be really high. In short, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• It looks great and it is best for high quality.
• The lift and turn drain's petite design mounts seamlessly to your tub.
• This is a course thread 1 3/4 od unit.
• This feels well made, it allows for very good quality and has a nice style.

Best For Perfect Fit: Danco Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase a gasket for their daily usage, but the Danco Replace Tub Drain Gasket would be an anomoly. The danco replaced tub drain gasket fits most standard lavatory sinks with a 1-3/8 opening. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, it is easy to replace and it works great.

The gasket is great for easy fix and it is made for an easy fit. In addition, the gasket worked perfectly and it had a drain plug. Lastly, the danco replaced tub drain gasket is one of the largest plumbing repair, replacement and remodel suppliers in the home improvement industry.

Most buyers found that the gasket measures 15/16" inside, 2 1/8" outside. Further, they also found that the gasket is a little smaller in diameter but fits perfectly and seals the drain perfectly. Also, they say that the only gasket does not go down far enough to seal the drain.

• For sterling tip-toe style bathtub stoppers.
• This helps to keep drains flowing freely, eliminating clogs from foreign objects.
• This is easy to install with no tools required.
• This is perfect for whirlpool lifetime drain.

Best With Polished Brass: Ldr Industries Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where the industries replacetub rain gasket truly manage to shine. The ldr industry replaced the tub drain gasket. It looks good, is super easy, it allows for easy installation and has a great design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, it is inexpensive, does the job and it looks beautiful.

The gasket has a push button, is installed quickly. It is warm and has a standard design. Also, it looks amazing, works nice, it is attractive and has a convenient design. Above all, the ldr industry replaces tub drain gaskets made from stainless steel for prolonged use.

Almost all customers agree that the gasket is perfect the job, very good value for the money. In addition, a few also found that the gasket does a great job of keeping the water inside. Moreover, they strongly agree that the gasket makes people think it looks crappy. With no doubts, this gasket passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell. You will be too.
• It is very sturdy and it is good for fast delivery.
• This is an exact replacement for the original tub drain that no longer held water.
• This is a manual open and close device that should last much longer.

Best For Solid Metal: Wholesale Plumbing Supply Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for an appropriate and satisfactory gasket, wholesale plumbing supply replace the tub drain gasket is your end point. The wholesale plumbing supply replaced tub drain gasket looks awesome and it is great for decent quality. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, it is great for brand name, allows for a good seal and it is best for solid metal.

The gasket is designed for very high quality and it makes for nice quality. Finally, the wholesale plumbing supply replaced tubdrain gasket fits 1 3/8 inch or 1 1/2 inch waste elbows.

Most buyers quickly discover that the gasket can really freeze in place after they have been in there a few years. In addition, they also found that the gasket will give you a long - lasting solution. Also, a few say that the drain assembly is made to fit a 1 - 3/8 " pipe or a 1 - 1/2 " pipe with an included threaded adapter. In short, buyers found this to be one of the best gaskets for daily purposes.

• This is a very well made and solid piece of hardware.
• The drain assembly is a nice, heavy, well built piece.
• This looks good, and is way better than the gaping drain pipe.
• This worked perfectly, it is very attractive and has a nice style.

Best For High Quality Material: Artiwell Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another gasket that manages to win our hearts. It's the artiwell replaced tub drain gasket and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient gaskets you can buy. The artiwell replaced tub draingasket is great for a great price, has a drain plug and it went on easily. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, it comes with brass screws and it is best for high quality.

The gasket works perfectly. It has threaded adapter bushing, it looks good and has a simple design. Also, the gasket takes only 5 minutes to complete the installation. Lastly, the artiwell replaced tub drain gasket is designed for long-lasting durability.

Almost all customers found that the gasket is sealed between the drain pipe and the tub. And, a few say that the gasket is easy to install as long as everything is centered correctly.

• This fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes.
• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell, you will be too.
• This is perfect for high quality materials and it is built with great quality.

Best For Tip Toe: Lasco Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate gasket. The lasco replaced tub drain gasket is exactly that - it's a simple gasket that hits all the right notes. The lasco replaced tub drain gasket worked perfectly, has seal the deal and it works great. Use other Lasco plumbing products for all of your home improvement plumbing project needs. In addition, this is manufactured in China and it is a tiptoe seal wash gasket.

Above all, the lasco replaced tub drain gasket is perfect for home remodels, housing flips, apartments, condominiums, or million dollar homes.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the gasket was perfect for American standard tub. Also, a few strongly agree that the gasket is easy to install and fits perfectly. Moreover, a few say that the stopper then lifts out and the gasket can be removed and replace. With no doubts, this gasket passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• This has a drain plug and it works perfectly.
• This is great for a great price and it is perfect for a simple - use kit.
• The product is manufactured in China.
• The product is a tiptoe seal wash gasket.

Best For Nice Look: Pf Waterworks Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Pf Waterworks Replace Tub Drain Gasket for daily purpose. The pf waterworks replaced the tubdrain gasket. is good for nice item and it worked fine. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, it includes free haircatcher strainers which help prevent clogs.

The gasket works fine, works great and it works OK. Most importantly, the pf waterworks replace the tub drain gasket. is perfect for any bathroom improvement or remodeling projects.

One customer says - "Use plumbers putty and you should be fine. ". Most customers found that the gaskets are super responsive (replying within 15 minutes to all inquiries) and very accommodating.

• This includes toe touch bath tub stopper and bathtub drain shoes with matching finish.
• This is made for a nice look, is made with solid weight and it is attractive.
• Available in ch, bn, pb, ab, orb finishes.
• This is built with metal construction and it can resize for a nice fit.

Best For Heavy Duty: Dorence Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Dorence replaced the tub draingasket for regular use. And, the dorence replaced tub drain gasket has upgraded your bath, It installed easily and has great design. Above the floor * easy do-it-yourself installation. Moreover, the gasket works great, It makes for solid construction and has a modern style. Finally, the dorence replaced tub drain gasket comes in the most common oil rubbed bronze color.

Almost all customers found that the gasket is a very simple install with a good amount of plumber's putty. In addition, a few also found that the gasket is easy to remove the stopper to clean hair out of the drain. Therefore, customers were eager to recommend it to friends and would-be buyers.

• This is amazon's fault rather than the seller/brand.
• This is ideal for repairing problematic plumbing fixtures without the need to replace them.
• This is because there's white tape overlapping the original to "reseal" the box.
• This is also a very heavy, good quality piece.

Best Modern Design: Bluevue Replace Tub Drain Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The bluevue replaced tub drain gasket's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The bluevue replaced tub drain gasket is inexpensive, It is totally effective and has a great design. The Manufacturer says: The big gasket covers a larger area than our regular-sized gasket to hide rust damage around the rim of the overflow pipe. The big gasket works for center hole overflow pipes and overflows with one screw on each side.

The gasket works great, it is great for high quality and has a standard design. Most importantly, the bluevue replaced tub drain gasket is best for very high quality, It is made with zinc alloy and has a simple design.

Most buyers quickly discovered that the gasket comes with a silicone gasket which directs flow over the tub and wall joint. And, they say that the gasket design is very well-thought-out, with it effectively bypassing the problematic joint (standard gasket, which is prone to failure) between the overflow drain pipe and the wall of the tub/shower. Also, they strongly agree that the gasket comes with instructions but it is easy to figure out. In conclusion, for almost all buyers, it was what they were looking for.

• This can be used in every bathtub.
• This is easy to install, and has worked great.
• This is a perfect solution but a tricky installation.
• This is not what is installed on every single tub from the very beginning.