The 7 Best Spicy Mayonnaise (2023 reviews)

We consider a spicy mayonnaise to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Hellmanns Spicy Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best For potato salads: Buy: Duke'S Spicy Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best With Sesame Oil: Buy: Wafu Spicy Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best With relish: Buy: Sir Kensingtons Spicy Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best Paleo friendly Mayonnaise: Buy: Betterbody Foods Spicy Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Hellmanns Creamy Organic Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best Feature: ingredient Quality: Buy: Truff Spicy Mayonnaise READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Hellmanns Spicy Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The hellmanns spicy mayonnaise is specially designed for your daily purpose and has plenty of most useful features. Tangy and delicious this veg'an salad dressing is egg, dairy, cholesterol and gluten-free. It looks, smells and tastes like real mayo and has a nice creamy consistency. It tastes as good as the non-vegan variety and has a thick, creamy texture. It will be excellent on sandwiches and added to dips and spreads along with potato and macaroni salads, etc. The opening has a tightly secured inner seal to ensure the product arrives fresh and unopened.

The top spoon is the Best Foods Vegan Mayonnaise and the bottom spoon is the traditional Best Foods Mayonnaise.

• A delicious alternative to traditional mayonnaise
• Gmo sourced ingredients, and has no artificial flavors
• Flavorful, spicy dishes go over well with your guests

Best For potato salads: Duke'S Spicy Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention duke's spicy mayonnaise for regular usage. This is such a good, creamy mayo. It is made with vinegar which is so healthy for you. It applies easily to a sandwich, so you can get every bit of it out. It is creamy with just the right amount of zippiness and, a major plus, no sugar. It is perfect for potato salads.

The quality ingredients used and the slightly tangy flavor of Duke's mayo makes a HUGE difference. It's the perfect combination of zip and creaminess, with enough egg in it to taste it without it coming out like an egg salad right out of the jar.

• Great for sandwiches, pasta salads, cole slaw and much more
• Great sense memories of childhood at first taste
• Pasta/egg/potato/tuna salads, or just as a spread for bread for sandwiches

Best With Sesame Oil: Wafu Spicy Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The wafu spicy mayonnaise's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The seeds of the Wafu story were planted when Mari Toyoda, a trained Japanese chef, left home and immigrated to Canada. It's just mayo with a little bit of a spicy kick. This product works great in soups, eggs, pasta dishes, meats, and believe it or not, peanut butter sandwiches. It has a great flavor. It is great for sushi bowls. It's really strong and spicy mayo. It's great for sushi bowls.

• Made with real, high quality ingredients
• Great on sushi and in asian bowls
• Great spiciness that will enhance any food
• Gluten free and low in cholesterol and kosher

Best With relish: Sir Kensingtons Spicy Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The sir kensingtons spicy mayonnaise is capable of outshining several other mayonnaise featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Most commercial mayonnaise has a twangy flavor, to varying degrees, a thick whipped texture, and sweetness from sugar. This is a high quality mayonnaise made with quality ingredients. A foil inner seal ensures the product is fresh and untouched. It doesn't need to be refrigerated until it's been opened.

This is a quality mayonnaise made with quality ingredients. The flavor is bland and the consistency is looser than PK. The container makes application easy. While this mayonnaise can be considered vegetarian, it does contain free-range eggs, so it is not a vegan product.

• Squeeze bottles are easy to use
• Creamy and delicious, refrigerate after opening
• Highly recommend if you like flavorful vs oily like lots of mayo

Best Paleo friendly Mayonnaise: Betterbody Foods Spicy Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

Betterbody Foods offers a variety of mayonnaise for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. For a great paleo friendly mayonnaise that is health oriented WITHOUT REFINED SUGAR, this is an excellent condiment. It is made primarily of avocado oil with the twist of smoky zip from chipolte and lime. The chipotle lime adds an extra special touch. The mayo is creamy and a lovely orange color from the chipotle. It adds such great flavor with only the best ingredients. It is just sweet enough with the coconut sugar to make it taste good, but not overwhelm. This tastes very tangy with a bit of a heat kick. It makes a very tasty chicken salad.

• Delicious and made with the best ingredients
• Love the healthy oils and healthy ingredients
• Great tasting for all kinds of preparation
• Give your food some unique, tasty flair

Best premium: Hellmanns Creamy Organic Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other mayonnaise in this category, the hellmanns creamy organic mayonnaise has a design with broader appeal. Hellmann's Organic Spicy Chipotle Mayonnaise is made with USDA organic free-range eggs. It is made with organic spicy chipotle chili peppers, organic cage-free eggs, organic expeller-pressed oil, and no artificial flavors or preservatives. This gluten-free mayonnaise is made with USDA.

• A delicious option for meal preps
• Love the flavor and a new twist on recipe options
• Good investment for long term

Best Feature: ingredient Quality: Truff Spicy Mayonnaise

Buy on Amazon

The truff spicy mayonnaise's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. This goes so well with steak and fries. It adds a level of complexity to plain old chicken salad.

• A gourmet spicy mayo to elevate every meal
• Lot of satisfied buyers