We consider a stainable wood floor filler to be a worthy investment in the long run. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best stainable wood floor filler for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Elmers Wood Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Shallow Fills: Buy: Dap Stainable Wood Floor Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Log: Buy: Minwax Stainable Wood Floor Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Small Holes: Buy: Sharpie Stainable Wood Floor Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Crafting And School: Buy: Elmers Stainable Wood Floor Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Exterior Use: Buy: Goodfilla Stainable Wood Floor Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Post Workout Recovery: Buy: Goodfilla Wood Filler READ REVIEW

Best For Outdoor Use: Buy: Gorilla Stainable Wood Floor Filler READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Elmers Wood Filler

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a filler. The Elmers Wood Filler is exactly that - it's a simple filler that hits all the right notes. The elmers wood filler is paintable, dries very fast and it has fill holes. After the wood filler dries to a natural color, easily stain or paint your wood to make it look new. Further, the filler is great for high quality material and it is used to fill holes.

Finally, the elmers wood filler is simple, is easy to paint and it is great for wood trim.

Almost all buyers opine that the filler is used to fill floor cracks, but it might not match the color of the floor. Also, they also found that the filler is easy to apply and blend when it is used, and it is easy to sand down once it has dried. Further, they strongly agree that the filler is easy to work with, dries fairly fast and sands well. Therefore, buyers were very happy to recommend it to friends and would-be buyers.

• This has dried though, it has become a nice non-glossy (matte) white.
• Elmer's: the glue with the orange cap.
• This is thicker than other similar brands. That makes it much easier to work with.
• This is used for filling in dings and scratches to create a uniform surface for painting.

Best For Shallow Fills: Dap Stainable Wood Floor Filler

Buy on Amazon

The Dap Stainable Wood Floor Filler's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The dap stainable wood floor filler is paintable and it dries very quickly. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, this is great for strong nails and it is highly recommend.

Most importantly, the dap stainable wood floor filler provides great value, saves time and it is great for wood trim.

Almost all buyers found that the filler is good for shallow fills. In addition, they strongly agree that the filler is in a high traffic area, you might want to think about epoxy putty. Also, a few strongly agree that the filler is by lifting the door by the door knob and pulling it shut so it can latch.

• This made some primed shiplap.
• This will work on any clean surface area.
• This is perfect for application and went on smoothly.
• This is easy to apply and to wipe off to level it out.

Best For Log: Minwax Stainable Wood Floor Filler

Buy on Amazon

The Minwax Stainable Wood Floor Filler is capable of outshining several other fillers featured in this list in overall features for the price point. The minwax stainable wood floor filler works well for pocket screws, works pretty well and it is maybe more. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, it is America's leading brand of wood finishing and wood care products.

The filler is pre-mixed and it becomes like wood. Moreover, I believe it 's paintable, for ease of use and it works great. Lastly, the minwax stainable wood floor filler is ideal for repairing cracks, small gouges, nail holes, knot holes and other defects in all types of unfinished indoor and outdoor wood surfaces.

Almost all customers agree that the filler is used to frame doorways has cracked, significantly. And, they strongly agree that the filler will be covered by a large wood patch and then painted over it. Moreover, a few strongly agree that if the putty dries in the tray, discard it as it will not re - soften. To sum up, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the filler suits the purpose.

• It is designed for use with oil-based and water-based wood stains.
• This is several days over a week or so.
• This takes paint very well on exterior wood.
• This filler does not have a smooth, hard finish.

Best For Small Holes: Sharpie Stainable Wood Floor Filler

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate filler. The Sharpie Stainable Wood Floor Filler is exactly that - it's a simple filler that hits all the right notes. The sharpie stainable woodfloor filler is easy to identify by usage, application and color. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it is inexpensive, works great and it has used stuff.

The filler dries very quickly and it works great when it dries quickly. Also, it works well on blemishes, is highly recommended and it has filled holes in the wood. Finally, the sharpie stainablewood floorfiller is as strong as the inside.

Almost all buyers agree that the filler is used to fill in some screw holes. And, a few say that the filler works well at filling wood and dries quickly. Moreover, a few strongly agree that the filler is stainable, so if you sand, stain & seal you will be fine. In short, many have used the filler for more than a few months without letup, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This has been used for many years.sandable and can be primed and painted with no issues.
• This cleans up with water and not chemicals.
• This maintains their great service forever.
• This works well in some situations.

Best For Crafting And School: Elmers Stainable Wood Floor Filler

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where Elmers Stainable Wood Floor Filler truly manages to shine. The elmers stainable wood floor filler has a variety of specialty and craft products including rubber cement, hot glue, spray adhesives, and liquid craft glue to meet all project needs. The manufacturer says: Explore our full range of art, craft, repair, school, and office products—great for children and adults. Moreover, it is easy to take on any project or repair at home or in the workshop.

The filler is ready to sand, stain or paint without shrinking or cracking. And, the filler can be used for door frames, sanded down hard and it is ideal for paper. Above all, the elmers stainable wood floor filler is ideal for repairing holes, dents, scratches, gouges and defects on any wood, wallboard, molding or painted surface.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the filler was perfectly, covered cracks and holes in the wood shelf. In addition, they say that the filler can be used on PVC with glue. Moreover, they also found that the filler is easy to sand and dries to a natural tan color. Overall, many customers have used the elmers stainable woodfloor filler for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This package contains one 4 oz bottle of wood filler.
• It looks great, is good for interior use and it dries fairly quickly.
• Elmer's: the glue with the orange cap.
• This is easy to smooth so sanding is minimal.

Best For Exterior Use: Goodfilla Stainable Wood Floor Filler

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Goodfilla Stainable Wood Floor Filler for regular use. The goodfilla stainablewood floorfiller is designed to accept stains similarly to wood. On finished oak, cherry, maple, white, neutral/tint base, rosewood, walnut, mahogany, ebony. The wood filler seems to dry lighter than the original color.

The filler is heavy is important and it has fill holes. And, the filler can be reconstituted with water if it dries in the container. Most importantly, the goodfilla stainable wood floor filler allows a longer open time and holds on to the water longer.

Almost all customers agree that the filler is easy to use and it hardens in a few hours. Moreover, they say that the filler is easy to use, has no odor, and has great results. And, they also found that this filler is meant to be covered with an appropriate finish coat.

• Follow the same directions as you would for a grain filler.
• This is much more and it is used for exterior projects.
• This will not sink, shrink, crack, or fall out.
• Can't tell it's a green product.

Best For Post Workout Recovery: Goodfilla Wood Filler

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing but a filler that is reliable, this Goodfilla Wood Filler is certainly a wise investment. The goodfilla wood filler is environmentally friendly and it is heavy. Goodfilla is so easy to sand, you'll be amazed by how much time you save. This innovative product appeals to woodworkers, makers, and artists since it seamlessly dovetails with all water - based products, plus lacquer.

The filler will not sink, shrink, crack, or fall out. Moreover, the filler will dry lighter and return to the original color once the finish is applied. Above all, the goodfilla wood filler is economical and it does for spray paint.

Almost all customers agree that the filler is suitable for exterior use. Moreover, a few also found that the filler is used to fill in gaps between planks on farm table. Further, they strongly agree that this filler dries hard and is easily sandable and would probably work well on floors as long as you get the correct tint / color. Overall, for most customers, Goodfilla product was just what they wanted.

• This cleans up easily, accepts oil over it without changing color.
• This is made with water or else you'd loosen or remove it from the surface.
• Get exactly what you want every time.
• This is perfect for in between coats of finish.

Best For Outdoor Use: Gorilla Stainable Wood Floor Filler

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase filler for their daily usage, but the Gorilla Stainable Wood Floor Filler would be an anomoly. The gorilla stainable wood floor filler works with high speed sanders•interior/ exterior*•water resistant*•moldable. You can’t use soap and water to clean hands and tools before material dries. The go - to product for strong, durable repairs to cracks, gouges and holes.

Finally, the gorilla stainable wood floor filler is easy to spreadhigh performance stainability and paintabilityshrink and crack resistantanchors nails and screws sandable.

"You can either snip the end with scissors for a larger application or puncture with something for a smaller application. " - says, one customer. To sum up, buyers found this to be one of the best fillers for daily purposes.

• The unique formula is easy to spread, allowing for a smooth, natural finish.
• Remove all excess residue with a damp cloth before the filler dries.
• Before filling, test stain on scrap wood with filler.
• It is easy to clean and dry the surface of dirt, dust and foreign material.