The 11 Best Cherries For Whiskey Sour (2023 reviews)

There are several advantages of having a cherry for whiskey sour. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best cherry for whiskey sour for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Best Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Buy: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best With Cherries: Buy: Filthy food Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best With stem: Buy: Woodford Reserve Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best For pie: Buy: Tillen Farms Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best For So many different recipes: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co Maraschino Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For Cherry pie: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best For baking: Buy: Marco Polo Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best For lovely presentation: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best For sauce: Buy: Traverse City Whiskey Co. competition brands Cherry READ REVIEW

Best For Black Forest cake: Buy: Gefen Cherry For Whiskey Sour READ REVIEW

Best overall: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Best Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the luxardo original maraschino cherries best cherry has a design with broader appeal. From the dark, deliciously sweet syrup to the slight "snap" you experience when biting into one, Luxardo cherries are a wonderfully unique experience. They are excellent quality cherries, originally sour and naturally dark red suspended in a sweet thick syrup. The juice will crystallize, making them less appetizing in appearance.

The Luxardo cherries have the wonderful flavor that puts the cookies over the top. It has excellent flavor, is firm, has a very deep, dark red color and are packed in a very thick, sticky cherry liquor. It can be used in homemade ice cream and even in greek yogurt for breakfast. These are simply the perfect touch to create a delicious cocktail, and have become a must addition to home-made bourbon drinks.

• Very dense, flavorful cherries that put the perfect finish on a manhattan
• Great for a good bourbon or cocktail
• Perfect addition to a high-end cocktail

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their regular usage, but the luxardo original maraschino cherries cherry for whiskey sour would be an anomoly. The aroma is the essence of cherries and their presence in a cocktail is magical. They muddle in cocktails extremely well and infuse the entire drink with an exquisite hint of cherry. The level of sweetness with that hint of tart is perfect. The syrup is thick and dark. These cherries contain no artificial ingredients. They are delicious and are a treat unto themselves.

There is no bright red dye or chemical flavor in these cherries. They are definitely the real deal and provide the correct flavor and even texture for any cocktail calling for a maraschino cherry. It is firm but not chewy and the flavor is sweet and light without the cloying and artificial sweetness of the standard cocktail cherry.

• Best maraschino cherries for mixed drinks
• A deep, rich semi sweet cherry that beautifully sets off the manhattan cocktail
• Makes the best addition to a manhattan
• Worth the money if you like delicious desserts

Best With Cherries: Filthy food Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the filthy food cherry for whiskey sour has a convenient design. If you make and drink Old Fashions these are the cherries you need. It is the best tasting cherry for an old fashion. These are great cherries and the value for quantity received is excellent.

These are always going to be fresh and can travel easy, like camping or tailgating. It’s flavor is just sweeter, not different than fresh. There is a lot of syrup with these cherries. If you are looking for cocktail cherries, these are the absolute best. These are in thickened juice but that can be full of cherries.

• Perfect blend of sweet and tart
• Great for cocktails and much richer flavor than regular maraschino cherries
• Delicious, rich sweet and sour flavor
• Perfect ingredient for the perfect cocktail

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

Woodford Reserve offers a variety of cherry for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. The Bourbon flavor is very mild. It is made from natural ingredients, these cherries bring a brightness along with hints of kentucky's finest bourbon to recipes. The jar contains about 25 cherries. The leftover juice is great on vanilla ice cream.

They have the perfect amount of sweetness and the bourbon inside can be mixed into the drink. The product makes a good cocktail garnish, better taste than typical maraschino cherries. It is great for entertaining, 1 jar lasts approx 2 nights of drinks for a group of.

• Very tasty addition to an old fashioned or any other cocktail
• Save the juice and reduce for dessert topping
• Perfect cherries for all you "old fashioned" drinkers

Best For pie: Tillen Farms Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The tillen farms cherry for whiskey sour is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. They are big fat plump amazing cherries and they make the most fantastic Manhattan's. They are packed full of cherries and are not too overly sweetened like sugary candy. They are packed in a thin syrup that is not too sickly-sweet and effectively adds just a drop or so to your mix. The Jar is packed full of cherries and are not too overly sweetened like sugary candy.

It is best cherry for drinks, taste like a cherry and not over sweet ice cream cherries. Use these for cocktails and you won't ruin the flavor. It is great as an economic old fashion ingredient. The syrup is sweet and therefore, if the cherries are sour to begin with, they are no longer sour. It is not up to luxor cherry quality, but toss a couple in a shot of whiskey with a bit of orange sparkling water and enjoy.

• Flavor is well balanced quite delicious
• Even a splash of juice is excellent
• Great flavor & syrup not too gooey

Best For So many different recipes: Traverse City Whiskey Co Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about appropriate and satisfactory cherry, traverse city whiskey co maraschino cherry should be your first option for buying. These are terrific dessert cherries. They are used to go snow boarding in the winters up in traverse city. It makes for an amazing summertime/warm weather drink and these cherries go wonderfully in it. It is great for desert as well. These cherries have the perfect flavor and texture for cocktails. It is great for smoked old fashioned cocktails. These are in a seriously sweet juice, so sweet, it takes over your cocktail. These really do make a big difference in a cocktail.

• Nice and suftly crunchy, super sugary and sweet, and thick
• Adds incredible flavor and presentation to craft old fashioned cocktails
• Perfect for manhattans and old fashions

Best For Cherry pie: Traverse City Whiskey Co Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing but the best desirable cherry, then traverse city whiskey co cherry for whiskey sour is the one you should definitely consider, as it manages to bring a lot to the table. Premium Cocktail Cherries make the difference between a mediocre drink and a sublime cocktail. These cherries are delicious. They work well as a garnish in cocktails and in desserts. The flavor is a far more intense cherry, without the artificial. They are also great over vanilla bean ice cream.

It comes with all the characteristics of seasonal tart cherries and have zero artificial colorings. They are great for cocktail drinks. They are also great for bourbon on the rocks.

• Perfect addition to the old fashion cocktail,flavor is good
• Hiqh quality ingredients and great flavor
• Great flavor and finish for a favorite cocktail

Best For baking: Marco Polo Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

The marco polo cherry for whiskey sour is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features for the price point. These tart cherries are extremely tasty. The product itself says no preservatives, but it has citric acid added which is a preservative. This is the one you need for cherry pies. They are delicious and perfectly preserved.

• Good replacement for trader joe's morello cherries
• Great flavor, needs to be less cooked
• Excellent in crepes with mascarpone or whipped cream
• Pie cherries without all the extra sugary gel

Best For lovely presentation: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co. cherry for whiskey sour's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. These cherries are way more delicious than the standard maraschino cherries you can get in the grocery store. They bring back all the good memories of summers in Traverse City, beaches, starry nights, and drinks with friends. It has a much more complex and intense cherry flavor. The flavor is very sweet.

It is made with marasca cherries and these are made with balaton cherries. The cherries themselves have a deep, rich flavor without the sugary gag of maraschinos. The great taste and flavor and more importantly the cherries have a really good texture/form. These would be a great addition to a gift basket or just alongside a nice bottle of bourbon.

• Rich thick syrup even goes great on ice cream
• Super easy way to level-up your home cocktail game
• New and hot release

Best For sauce: Traverse City Whiskey Co. competition brands Cherry

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about appropriate and satisfactory cherry, traverse city whiskey co. competition brands cherry should be your first option for buying. If you want a perfect Manhattan, these are the cherries you need. They are sweet, soft, and full of natural cherry flavor. They come in a rich syrup and are very sweet and delicious. The syrup is also very sweet, so it’s also great for a sauce on ice cream. These are meaty and flavorful.

These cherries are an event, not a simple treat. They are meaty and flavorful. They are a bit spendy but they also aren't your typical cherry and the jars are a decent size.

• Make an exponentially better garnish for cheesecakes than canned cherry pie filling ever would
• Great over ice cream and in manhattans and other drinks
• Come in a quality container as well
• Would also be great with soda or ice cream

Best For Black Forest cake: Gefen Cherry For Whiskey Sour

Buy on Amazon

The gefen cherry for whiskey sour should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. Tart cherries have anti-inflammatory properties. It is great in desserts, jams, cakes, cherry pies, cocktails & any recipes calling for sour cherries. The cherries are uniformly round and intact, but a solid second option. The water they are packed in is a treat in itself.

These tart cherries make the most delicious pie. It is good for joints, nails and hair, and for gut health. The gelatin is good for joints, nails and hair, and for gut health. It is good as fresh or frozen, but a solid second option.

• Easy access to canned sour cherries
• Delicious cherries for a pie and a tart
• Good brand reputation