The 12 Best Cherries For Old Fashioned Cocktail (2023 reviews)

If you often find yourself confused about good cherry, luxardo original maraschino cherries cherry for old fashioned cocktail should be your first option for buying. These are absolutely the most wonderful maraschino cherries. They make the best cocktails especially in Manhattan. Luxardo cherries are deep and luscious and real-cherry-tasting, have an extraordinary firm texture, and subtle rich fragrance. They can transfer them to six wide mouth pint mason jars. They are very dark red, and they have a firmness to them that you will not find in your store brand bright red maraschinos.

These exceptional candied cherries are an exclusive italian import with unbeatable flavor. They are gluten-free, non-gmo, vegan, and kosher. There is no substitute for these cherries.

Why We Like This:

Love them in cocktails or on a spoon
Good investment for long term

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

Best part: woodford reserve cherry for old fashioned cocktail costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. These are basically slightly nicer maraschino cherries. The product makes a good cocktail garnish, with better taste than typical maraschino cherries. They have the perfect amount of sweetness and the bourbon inside can be mixed into the drink. They are not excessively sweet which is nice. The cherries are firm and full of flavor. It is great for a professional looking old fashioned.

Why We Like This:

Great flavor while garnishing your guests cocktail
Good brand reputation

Best With liquor: Filthy food Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their daily purpose, but the filthy food cherry for old fashioned cocktail would be an anomoly. If you enjoy making specialty cocktails or just a great Manhattan these Filthy Cherries will make your day. These cocktail cherries are absolutely wonderful. They elevate your cocktail, to a cocktale. It's very sweet with a tart finish.

This glass jar contains 45 exquisite black cherries that are surely hard to forget. The syrup is pretty thick. These elevate your cocktail, to a cocktale. These are the best jarred cherries hands down. It is great for any cocktail especially for an old fashioned.

Why We Like This:

Fantastic garnish to a high end cocktail
Good investment for long term

Best For Bourbon: Evan Williams Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The evan williams cherry for old fashioned cocktail's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. These Black Cherries really make a Manhattan. They have good flavor and work perfect for cocktails. They add the perfect flavor in just 1 cherry and a teaspoon of juice. The cherries are dark and delicious and have their full stems which makes them a perfect match for a delightful cocktail. They are great for garnishes for cocktails and even a shirley temple.

These are great with a manhattan made with evan williams single barrel bourbon and evan williams bitters. It's a tiny bit overpriced but the flavor is fantastic.

Why We Like This:

Very fine cherries for old fashions
New and hot release

Best For baking: Sanniti Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The sanniti cherry for old fashioned cocktail should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These are fantastic and are much less than Luxardo Cherries. It is ideal for baking a fruit cake, while sliced and whole candied fruit make excellent cake toppings and designs. It is an ice cream sundae without the cherry on top. They are in thick syrup and they are delicious. They are delicious and reasonably priced.

These are really good and perfect for old Fasioneds. They are great for topping off sundaes/cakes or mixing with soda for a fun and festive drink. They are excellent for cocktails.

Why We Like This:

Great mixing the syrup for other cocktails or mocktails
Thick cherry sauce and delicious cherries
Good investment for long term

Best For mixed Cocktails: Royal Harvest Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The royal harvest cherry for old fashioned cocktail is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily usage. These are fabulous, large, juicy cherries. They beat those red dyed Maraschinos that dominate the cocktail cherry market, by a mile. It is great ingredient for mixed cocktails (or "mocktails"), whenever grenadine or cherry syrup is used in a recipe. They are perfect for this purpose, the juice is not too thick or sweet and these are the absolute best value for the money.

These cherries are as good as any out there, and way better than the artificial bright red cherries. The syrup is just the right consistency and good spooned onto ice cream. It is made with natural ingredients. These beat those red dyed Maraschinos that dominate the cocktail cherry market, by a mile.

Why We Like This:

Not too sweet and the extra juice works well in recipes
Wonderfully tasting cherries and better for you
Best cherries for making candy, desserts, gauche, etc

Best For Whiskey: Traverse City Whiskey Co Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co cherry for old fashioned cocktail's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. Premium Cocktail Cherries make the difference between a mediocre drink and a sublime cocktail. These cherries are delicious. It comes with all the characteristics of seasonal tart cherries and have zero artificial colorings. The flavor is a far more intense cherry, without the artificial. They are also great over vanilla bean ice cream. These cherries are a bit firmer, with a taste that is comparable. They are a great addition to cocktails.

Why We Like This:

Hiqh quality ingredients and great flavor
Adds great flavor to the drinks
Great for old fashioned’s or just adding one to a glass of bourbon

Best bar Cherry: Tillen Farms Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cherry that manages to win our hearts. It's the tillen farms cherry for old fashioned cocktail and it's widely considered as cherry that has the most suitable features. If you enjoy making quality craft cocktails that require a proper cherry, like an old fashioned, this is the cherry for your cocktail. It is perfect for really good cocktails. The sugar content is low, and the cherries present with a bright, real cherry taste. If you want to splurge on cocktail cherries, get these. They don't have chemicals and have a great flavor. These cherries are perfect for a Manhattan.

Why We Like This:

Very good flavor without all of the typical additives in maraschinos
Gives a nice color to frosting
Good investment for long term

Best For Old Fashions: Jack Rudy Cocktail Co. Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The jack rudy cocktail co. cherry for old fashioned cocktail is suitable and reliable and fits well with your regular usage. These cherries are SO delicious. It is good as a luxardo in cocktails. It is best for old fashions. There are about 22 cherries per jar according to the label. These are the best bourbon cherries. It is great for cocktails or eating right out of the jar. It is the ideal companion to any number of drinks, most notably those made with whiskey.

Why We Like This:

Very rich taste and not overpowering
Amazing enhancement for the best old fashions
New and hot release

Best For lovely presentation: Traverse City Whiskey Co. Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co. cherry for old fashioned cocktail should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These cherries are way more delicious than the standard maraschino cherries you can get in the grocery store. They taste great in cocktails of course, but are also wonderful on desserts such as cheesecake and ice cream. They are not as sweet as a typical maraschino cherry, and the consistency is more 'jelly' like, but same as the Luxardo cherries.

The cherries themselves have a deep, rich flavor without the sugary gag of maraschinos. They are dense and packed to the brim of the jar. It is made for a lovely presentation. These are made for a much more complex and intense cherry flavor.

Why We Like This:

Rich thick syrup even goes great on ice cream
Super easy way to level-up your home cocktail game
Good brand reputation

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Eli mason Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The eli mason cherry for old fashioned cocktail gives the top-tier cherry a run for their money by offering flagship specs at a much more affordable price. It won’t take you longer than a minute to prepare a glass of delectable, boozy, flavorful old fashioned with eli mason old fashioned cocktail drink mix. These are made with premium, all-natural ingredients so you can be sure that your cocktail never has anything artificial in it, ever having anything artificial in it, ever having ice cream. It is perfect for cocktails and over ice cream.

Why We Like This:

Good investment for long term
New and hot release

Best For Christmas baking: Ved Cherry For Old Fashioned Cocktail

Buy on Amazon

The ved cherry for old fashioned cocktail should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. A cocktail cherry on top of an ice cream sundae is great, but there are few things as satisfying as a Maraschino cherry at the bottom of an old fashioned cocktail or Manhattan cocktail glass. The Ved cocktail cherries are hand-picked of the finest marasca cherries in the rich mountains of Italy and offered in tightly sealed jars that will keep them fresh and delicious for longer.

Unlike the red cherries of the ice cream parlor, these gourmet cocktail cherries come in a burgundy-red hue that adds luxury to your drinks. It is great for christmas baking. It is looking for the vibrant green maraschino cherries you find on top of the whipped cream in restaurants. These are non-gmo, gluten-free, and vegan. It is suitable for any healthy diet.

Why We Like This:

Candied fresh, offered in safe jars
A great addition to any healthy diet
Looking for mouth-watering old fashioned cherries for your cocktails or baked delicacies