The 7 Best Italian Tomatoes (2023 reviews)

We consider a italian tomato to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Cento Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best Runner up: Buy: Bianco dinapoli Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best Whole Tomato: Buy: Strianese Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best For creating A classic Italian Sauce: Buy: Bella Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best For spaghetti: Buy: Rega Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best premium: Buy: Mutti Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best Feature: Blending power: Buy: La Valle Italian Tomato READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Cento Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

Cento Italian-style plum tomatoes will make your spaghetti sauce taste great. They have crushed, puréed, and Italian style. Nevertheless, the tomatoes are delicious, sweet and plump, and soft enough to break down with a spoon while cooking. These tomatoes are best suited for warmer climates, making the sarnese nocerino area of italy the ideal location to grow them. It is great for your body and mind.

Love these tomatoes and the size of the can is perfect when you don't need a large can. It is perfect for italian recipes, full flavor, not too acidic and very italian. It is good for any italian dish requiring tomatoes.

• Great brand for any italian dish
• Delicious & versatile, but dented, unlabeled cans included
• New and hot release

Best Runner up: Bianco dinapoli Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

Bianco Dinapoli tomatoes are organically grown and harvested on cliff fong's family farm in yolo county, california. They are easy to work with, as they come whole and can be crushed or pureed to achieve the desired consistency. These plum-shaped tomatoes are washed, steam-peeled and hand selected at the olam tomato processor cannery in williams, california.

These tomatoes are perfectly ripe and full of flavor, making them the ideal base for homemade tomato sauce. The whole tomatoes are good for any kind of sauce or soup, while the crushed tomatoes are great for heavily-seasoned or spicy dishes.

• Rich tomato flavor without being too acidic
• Tomatoes are flavorful and sweet and makes a good sauce
• Good brand reputation

Best Whole Tomato: Strianese Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

These are the best tasting tomatoes for pizza with a sweet low amount of seeds. The soil in that area produces tomatoes perfect for producing great sauces such as a basic Marinara. If you are willing to open a can, it gives a genuine taste for those who are looking for a flavorful and more versatile alternative to mass produced pasta sauces. These are healthier and make italain dishes better than restaurants.

As with San Marzano tomatoes, the tomatoes are sweeter, less acidic and softer. The flavor of these tomato are outstanding. The cans are double full of tomato instead of just juice too. This has real (and real big) tomato pieces.

• Makes delicious sauce, non-acidic, great taste
• Great product especially adding a can to the pot when you’re making spaghetti sauce
• Good investment for long term

Best For creating A classic Italian Sauce: Bella Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

Unlike the more familiar Romas, the San Marzano tomatoes grow in volcanic soil near Mount Vesuvius, in a small town with the same name. It is ideal for creating a classic italian sauce. It is long and thin, with thick, sweet flesh and fewer seeds than other tomatoes, making them perfect for sauce. The flavor is delicious and you can taste the difference compared to anything else you have probably tried.

If you want a great tomato sauce, this is the best choice. It comes with such a short season for fresh tomatoes, canned tomatoes come in handy for sauces, soups or stews. The sauce is thicker and the taste is second to none.

• Ingredients 'selected organic italian tomatoes in organic tomato puree, organic basil
• Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For spaghetti: Rega Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

Cherry tomatoes are essential for all types of home-cooked Italian sauces, but also lend themselves beautifully for preparing decorations and skewers. Rega Cherry Tomatoes are naturally sun-ripened, delicate, sweet, meaty and full of flavor. Insisted on by best chefs, use them for a simple sauce with olive oil and garlic, this sauce is ideal for spaghetti, cooked only for 78 minutes. The cherry tomato also contains potassium, phosphor and calcium, improving blood circulation and pressure. These are some of the best canned tomatoes you will find.

• Make quick but delicious pasta dinners at home with simple ingredients
• Make a classic tomato sauce, add these for sweetness
• Delivers what they promise

Best premium: Mutti Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention mutti italian tomato for daily usage. These canned whole peeled tomatoes are the highest quality with no gmos, additives, or preservatives, which helps them break down quickly when cooked. It is made with natural goodness, you can see and taste a difference in these delicious, canned tomatoes. They are low in acidity and high in flavor with a natural sweetness that is ready for the pizza directly out of the can with a few pulses of the immersion blender.

These are carefully packed into non-bpa cans to preserve their fresh taste. It is perfect for pasta sauce and any other recipes that require whole-peeled tomatoes. It is based on partnership built on respect and dedication. These are harvested when perfectly ripe, then quickly preserved to retain their fresh taste and packed in their own juice. It is perfect for cooking for one or two.

• The richest, sweetest, most tomatoey flavor and great texture
• Delivers what they promise

Best Feature: Blending power: La Valle Italian Tomato

Buy on Amazon

These are simply the "cream of the crop" when it comes to the best tomatoes in a can. These are picked from the vines, they are rinsed and placed into cans, without any additives or preservatives. The tomatoes have a typically sweet and sour taste, and a lively red color. The peel, at full maturity, is easily removable.

The tomatoes are grown much like grapes and are picked three or four times per year between July and September. These tomatoes are extremely delicate and are handled with extreme care.

• Love the natural good tomato favor and taste
• Good investment for long term