We consider a leaking tub drain rubber gasket to be a worthy investment in the long run. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best leaking tub drain rubber gasket for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: American Standard Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Solid Metal: Buy: Danco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best With Overflow: Buy: Westbrass Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Easy Install: Buy: Lasco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best With Fast Shipping: Buy: Pf Waterworks Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Freestanding Tub: Buy: Drop-In Drain Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Good Deal: Buy: Danco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For Heavy Duty: Buy: Bluevue Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best For High Quality Material: Buy: Artiwell Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Convenient Design: Buy: Artiwell No Putty Gasket READ REVIEW

Best Overall: American Standard Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for a good gasket, American standard leaking tub drain rubber gasket is your end point. The American standard leaking tub drain rubber gasket is simple, it is best for good fit and has a modern style. look. The Manufacturer says: Our innovative design allows up to 3" of additional water depth than conventional drains for a deeper, more relaxing soak. In addition, the gasket has features for very good fit, has a drain plug and it works with evolution.

Above all, the American standard leaking tub drain rubber gasket is a style that works better every.

Almost all customers found that the gasket is recommended to go along with the American standard deep soak tub. And, they also found that the gasket came with the tub, but oh well. Further, they strongly agree that the gasket barely fits and the screws provided barely grab with only a few threads. Overall, many have used the gasket for more than a few months without any problems, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• It drains well, it is very nice and has a standard design.
• Available in multiple finishes to match the décor.
• This came with great directions and it installed easily.
• This is an issue with the tub surface and the rubber.

Best For Solid Metal: Danco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Danco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The danco leaking tub drain rubber gasket is easy to clean, works perfectly, It allows for easy installation and has a turn style. There are various size o-rings for you to choose from to fit your existing tub drain. Further, the gasket drains well and it is designed with a great appearance.

The gasket makes for easy fix and it is easy to use. Above all, the danco leaking tub drain rubber gasket installed easily, is very nice and it looks good.

Almost all customers agree that the gasket is flat, water sits on the top of the drain. Further, they strongly agree that the gasket looks like a permanent fixture, shiny and new. Further, a few say that the largest gasket has a 1 3/16 " internal diameter and 1 7/8 " external diameter. Overall, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the gasket suits the purpose.

• This provides strength and durability plus provides a solution for missing or damaged tub drains.
• This makes the bathtub look new again.
• Replaces lift and turn, push button, and trip lever drains.
• This is a great way to hide a dirty plug hole.

Best With Overflow: Westbrass Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Westbrass Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. The westbrass leaking tub drain rubber gasket includes kitchen & bath showrooms, plumbing wholesalers and supply houses, oem and odm companies, as well as several national home centers. Please measure the drain shoe opening. The product lines at the time included items such as faucets, valves, malleable fittings, etc.

Above all, the westbrass leaking tub drain rubber gasket is great for a great price, works great, It is white and has a convenient design.

Almost all buyers agree that the gasket fits well and works well. Further, they say that the gasket is perfectly sealed perfectly for bathing. Further, a few strongly agree that the gasket works for both sizes of screw sets.

• This is made of the highest quality materials.
• It has 2 different sizes of rubber gaskets.
• Includes flat rubber sealing washer to seal against bath shoes.
• This match for a perfect replacement.

Best For Easy Install: Lasco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another gasket that manages to win our hearts. It's the Lasco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket and it's widely considered as one of the most convenient gaskets you can buy. The lasco leaking tubdrain rubbergasket has the largest retail plumbing line in the industry today with over 7000 packaged and 16, 000 bulk sku’s. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it is perfect for home remodels, housing flips, apartments, condominiums, or million dollar homes.

The gasket has sealed the deal and it is great for tip toe. Most importantly, the lasco leakingtub drainrubber gasket has stopped the drop, works great and it is designed for easy install.

Most customers opine that the gasket is perfect for American standard tub. And, they strongly agree that the gasket is easy to install and fits perfectly. And, they also found that the stopper then lifts out and the gasket can be removed and replace.

• This has a drain plug and it works perfectly.
• Use other Lasco plumbing products for all of your home improvement plumbing project needs.
• This is manufactured in China and it is a tiptoe seal wash gasket.
• The product is a tiptoe seal wash gasket.

Best With Fast Shipping: Pf Waterworks Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Pf Waterworks Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The pf waterworks leaking tub drain rubber gasket is made with fast shipping, It allows for easy installing and has a nice shape. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Also, this includes 3/8” or 5/16” fitting adaptors.

The gasket is very nice and it is durable. Lastly, the pf waterworks leaking tub drain rubber gasket is made of real metal, is easy to replace, it works great and has a turn style.

Almost all customers agree that the gasket is easy to install, it seals well, it's problem - free...except for one thing. Furthermore, a few also found that the gasket is installed in a tub that is frequently used. Overall, many buyers have used the PF waterwork leaking tub drain rubber gasket for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• Metal alloy construction with brass fitting.
• This is made with a durable finish, it is easy to use and has a great design.
• This is a perfect fit. 10 seconds install no tools.

Best For Freestanding Tub: Drop-In Drain Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Drop-In Drain has been making great gaskets for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. The Drop-In Drain Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket has a white pvc pipe and it is white. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, this is reasonable and it works perfectly.

The gasket is quick to install, allows for clean installation and it is easy to use. And, the gasket fits with 1-1/2" male, 1-1/2" female or 1-1/2" threaded bathtub drains. Most importantly, the drop-in drain leaking tub drain rubber gasket allows for installation as close to the wall as possible.

One customer says - "Yes you can lift the tub and remove it from the quick drain then reinstall it within seconds..same goes with changing a free - standing tub. ". Most buyers agree that the gasket is the only kit that gives different options.

• This allows for multiple air pressure tests as well as protecting the drain during construction.
• This works great and it comes with female adapters.
• Lot of satisfied buyers.

Best For Good Deal: Danco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

The Danco Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket is capable of outshining several other gaskets featured in this list in overall features in its price range. The Danco leakingtub drainrubber gasket is great for a great price and it works perfectly. The Manufacturer says: We provide stylish, design-oriented innovative home solutions that are user-friendly to support and encourage customers to tackle home improvement tasks on their own. Further, it is easy to replace and it is best for a good deal.

The gasket is inexpensive and it works great. Most importantly, the danco leaking tubdrain rubbergasket provides a positive seal in a drain.

In short, for almost all customers, the gasket was most suitable.

• This fits most standard lavatory sinks with a 1-3/8 opening.
• For sterling tip-toe style bathtub stoppers.
• This helps to keep drains flowing freely, eliminating clogs from foreign objects.
• This is easy to install with no tools required.

Best For Heavy Duty: Bluevue Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase a gasket for their regular usage, but the Bluevue Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket would be an anomoly. The bluevue leaking tub drain rubber gasket is perfect for high quality, It is totally effective and has a simple design. Say goodbye to overflow gasket and bathtub leaks with Bluevue’s revolutionary overflow gasket. The big gasket works for center hole overflow pipes and overflows with one screw on each side.

The gasket is perfect for heavy duty and has a standard design. Above all, the bluevue leaking tub drain rubber gasket is simple, It is designed for very high quality and has a modern design.

Almost all buyers opine that the gasket is not what is installed on every single tub from the very beginning. Moreover, they strongly agree that the gasket is a perfect solution but tricky installation. And, they also found that the gaskets that builders install to stop water from leaking from the overflow pipe in a bathtub are cheap, and degrade over time. Overall, buyers found this to be one of the best gaskets for daily purposes.

• This is a far superior idea made capable because of silicone injection molding.
• This comes with a silicone gasket which directs flow over the tub and wall joint.
• This is easy to install, and has worked great.
• Manufacturer says: this kit includes a big (larger-sized) leak-proof gasket and a bluevue cover.

Best For High Quality Material: Artiwell Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for a convenient and suitable gasket, Artiwell Leaking Tub Drain Rubber Gasket should be your first option for buying. Moreover, the artistic leaking tub drain rubber gasket is great for high quality material and it works great. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, it takes only 5 minutes to complete the installation. Finally, the artistic leaking tub drain rubber gasket is available in matt black and champagne bronze colors.

Most buyers found that the gasket is easy to push down, easy to let up, seals the water in, all good. Moreover, a few also found that the gasket is perfect and looks great with the Delta vero shower system in champagne bronze. In conclusion, buyers found this to be one of the best gaskets for daily purposes.

• The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell, you will be too.
• This is exactly as stated with the correct size.
• This is great for tip toe and it makes for solid construction.
• This comes with product dimensions and it works perfectly.

Best Convenient Design: Artiwell No Putty Gasket

Buy on Amazon

Best part: Artiwell no putty gasket costs comparatively little and it is available to ship in 24 hours. Moreover, the Artiwell No Putty Gasket is designed for long-lasting durability, improving coating technology to improve anti-flaked off performance, withstands longer - lasting soaking in water. The manufacturer says: We are proud of the products we sell, you will be too. Also, it fits 1-1/2" and 1-3/8" drain shoe sizes. Finally, the artiwell no putty gasket is available in 2 colors: matt black and champagne bronze.

"Universal kit will breathe new life into your dated bath tub. " - says, one customer. Overall, many customers have used the gasket for more than a few months without any complaints, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This has a threaded adapter bushing, it is easy to use and has a standard design.
• This has an overflow plate, it comes with a face plate and has a great design.
• It takes only 5 minutes to complete the installation.