The 9 Best Natural Maraschino Cherries (2023 reviews)

The luxardo original maraschino cherries natural maraschino cherry is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features. These are the very best Maraschino cherries for a cocktail. They are dark, sweet with a rich flavor and even more enticing, dense texture. The juice will crystallize, making them less appetizing in appearance. They would be perfect on ice cream, in many desserts, or just by itself as a treat.

The jar is not too large to store in the fridge, and the wide mouth allows easy access. The jar is fully packed with never ending delicious cherries. The syrup that the cherries sit in make a great flavor addition to cocktails, particularly a manhattan. They have a darker color than bing cherries and come in a luscious thick sauce which is perfect for adding to your favorite cocktail.

Why We Like This:

Perfect addition to a high-end cocktail
Makes the quintessential old fashioned perfect
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For Whiskey sours: Luxardo / Woodford Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable cherry, luxardo / woodford natural maraschino cherry is your end point. The Woodford Reserve cherries are very similar in taste, maybe not quite as sweet with a little more of a smokey taste. They are delicious in cocktails, desserts, etc. They are perfect in bourbon cocktails with luxardo or blood orange liqueur and a splash of bitters.

These are not your standard bright red, almond flavored, hfcs sweetened pseudo-cherries. They're worth the premium and last a very long time. It is best for finishing off manhattans and whiskey sours.

Why We Like This:

Great for cocktails and shakes or just your daily cherry on top snack
Excellent fir multiple uses in your bar and kitchen
Completely different from each other and yet equally delicious

Best For Manhattan Cocktail: Filthy food Best tasting Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cherry that manages to win our hearts. It's the filthy food best tasting cherry and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient cherry you can buy. If you make and drink Old Fashions these are the cherries you need. They help in making the best Old Fashions. They are super flavorful and not artificially colored, which is good. They last for ages so nothing goes to waste. They are perfect for grown-up manhattan cocktails.

These cherries could be very good on top of a cheesecake, but the syrup they are in is thinner and the cherries themselves are not as sweet as your usual pie cherries. The juice is divine and needs no refrigeration. They are in a heavy syrup and have fantastic flavor.

Why We Like This:

Perfect ingredient for the perfect cocktail
Must for your old fashions or manhattans
Great flavor and beautiful for garnishing
Gluten free, non gmo and vegan

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The woodford reserve natural maraschino cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. These are the only cherries to use for a great manhattan. They are cherries you want to pluck from your glass when you’re done and pop into your mouth. It is used for making "old fashioned" cocktail, and topping for ice cream sundae. They have the stems for easy finding and picking out of your drink.

The syrup is excellent over ice cream. It is a full cherry, with a complete stem, not dehydrated and rehydrated. The product makes a good cocktail garnish, better taste than typical maraschino cherries. They are on the pricy side but totally worth it for those special occasions.

Why We Like This:

Great flavor while garnishing your guests cocktail
Very tasty addition to an old fashioned or any other cocktail
Makes a delicious manhattan and does not contain harmful chemicals

Best For baking: happy Belly Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing less than best desirable cherry, then happy belly natural maraschino cherry is the one you should definitely consider. These are full of flavor and very delicious. It is a jar of regular maraschino cherries in a sweet light cherry-flavor watery syrup.

Why We Like This:

Can pineapple rings, drained, reserve juice
Evenly pour the pineapple juice, cherry syrup, and butter over the cake mix
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For kir Royal: Filthy food Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The filthy food natural maraschino cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. These cocktail cherries are absolutely wonderful. They elevate your cocktail, to a cocktale. It's very sweet with a tart finish. It is great for kir royal or eat straight up or to top a dessert. It can be used by some of the best restaurants and bars in the world.

These are the absolute premium cherries to compliment a beverage (Manhattan) or dessert. The syrup is pretty thick. It is great for any cocktail especially for an old fashioned.

Why We Like This:

Perfect to make an old fashioned or simply just to have a sweet snack
Good investment for long term

Best For cakes: Member'S Mark Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention member's mark natural maraschino cherry for regular usage. This is a truly scrumptious tiny delicacy that will brighten any ice cream sundae or Manhattan. Use this in a lot of christmas baking and candies, if you have need for a lot, this is the way to buy them. These cherries are first rate, plump juicy and very tasty. The cherry stems are great for dipping the cherries into melted chocolate or for mixed drinks. Love the cherries, they are big, fresh and always tasty.

These are decently sized, stem in tact on 95% of the cherries.

Why We Like This:

Not too sweet and not too bland
Nice and pump with a generous stem
Stores great,keeps nice in the fridge

Best With An Old Fashioned: Collins Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Collins has been making great cherry for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. These gourmet cherries give an original cherry flavor to your favorite tipple. Red and juicy, these cherries are perfect for topping-off your favorite cocktail or dessert. They taste pretty good too just like maraschino cherries are supposed to. They have about half the amount of cherries and lots of juice. The cherries are whole and round, not pressed together like others.

These cocktail cherries with stems are the ideal gift for parties, housewarming, weddings, birthdays, or just as a surprise gift for cocktail connoisseurs. It is made from sweet, delicious fruit and preserved in syrups made with real sugar for cherries that add extra punch to manhattans, old fashioneds, and other classic cocktails. The jars come half empty.

Why We Like This:

Good investment for long term
Delivers what they promise

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Tillen Farms Natural Maraschino Cherry

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the tillen farms natural maraschino cherry has a convenient design. If you're looking for a maraschino with traditional almond flavoring, heavy syrup, and confection sweetness, this isn't it. These cherries are delicious. They are dark in color with a good texture. They are beautiful, fresh, and have the right amount of sweetness, richness, and are more full bodied than your classic maraschino.

These are beautiful cherries with (mostly) stems on. It is perfect as an additive to a cocktail or the top of an ice cream sundae and are superior to maraschino cherries. The ingredients are great and no fake dye. These are in a semi-sweet liquid that kicks up the drink a notch.

Why We Like This: