There are several advantages of having a rubber flapper valve. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best rubber flapper valve for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Fluidmaster Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Easy Install: Buy: Korky Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Exact Replacement: Buy: Toto Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best With Quick Shipping: Buy: Kohler Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Hard Water: Buy: Essential Values Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Cost Saving: Buy: Uming Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Great Price: Buy: Lydia'S Deal Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Money: Buy: Ifealclear Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For Stainless Steel: Buy: Crosize Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best For City Water Treatment: Buy: Jayen Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Compatible With Sterling Toilet Models: Buy: Amayjuelong Rubber Flapper Valve READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Fluidmaster Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where the Fluidmaster Rubber Flapper Valve truly manages to show. The fluidmaster rubber flapper valve is highly recommend, is adjustable for maximum performance, It has fill valves and has a simple design. The rigid frame aligns the flapper properly on every flush. In addition, the valve has solved the flushing issue and it is easy to use.

The valve is good for good quality, Go ahead and it will stop wasting water. In addition, it is the #1 toilet repair brand in the world. Most importantly, the fluidmaster rubber flapper valve can be cut for the right fit, making for a great buy, It is designed for good fit and has a very good design.

Most buyers agree that the valve fits well and easily into the tank tube, centers well, and flushes completely. Further, a few say that the valve is a two inch type. And, a few also found that the flapper is easy to install and seemed to fit right.

• Fixes most common cause of running toilet.
• This is perfect after adjusting the chain length.
• The rigid frame aligns the flapper properly on every flush.
• This allows for flush adjustment and also fits a 2-inch flush valve seat.

Best For Easy Install: Korky Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

Korky offers a variety of flappers for personal choice and yet maintains quality in all the variants. The Korky Rubber Flapper Valve is made for easy install, It is designed for quick easy installation and has an easy installation design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Further, it stopped the leak, it works better and has a universal design.

The flapper is made with fast shipping, it is non-adjustable and has a water - saving design. Finally, the korky rubber flapper valve features rubber construction to add to that, it is universal and fits 2" plastic flush valves.

Almost all customers agree that the flapper is already worth its price. Further, they also found that the flapper can take days/weeks to get non-urgent repairs done. Overall, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the flapper suits the purpose.

• This is these fancy water - saving flapper.
• This lasts longer and it is designed for easy installation.
• The Toilet tank flapper quickly fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste.
• This is made with fast ship, is highly recommended and it does the job.

Best For Exact Replacement: Toto Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Toto Rubber Flapper Valve's high-end materials make sure that it ages well with use. The toto rubber flapper valve provides for easy installing and it is convenient. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, the valve works as advertised, It is used for the second time and has a simple design.

The valve seals perfectly, it is white and has a true design. Finally, the toto rubber flapper valve includes a chain along with instructions for set-up specific to the toto tank model.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the valve would last a long time. Moreover, they strongly agree that the flapper will help you, They have great customer service. And, they say that the flapper that said it would fit most other products fit ours. To sum up, many customers have used the toto rubber flapper valve for more than a few months without any problems, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• This is easy to configure for the appropriate model and install.
• This is easy to order, although all the stock numbers have changed.
• Polypropylene body with rubber sealing surface.
• The Flapper includes a chain along with instructions for set-up specific to the toto tank model.

Best With Quick Shipping: Kohler Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

Best part: Kohler Rubber Flapper Valve costs comparatively little and it is available to ship in 24 hours. The kohler rubber flapper valve works very well, keeps on working and it stopped the leaking. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. And, the valve fits perfectly and it is strong.

Finally, the kohler rubber flapper valve is very easy, fits properly and it lasts forever.

Most customers found that the flapper was a gift for a good neighbor. Also, a few strongly agree that the valve fits with the plugging hole and works completely well. And, a few also found that note: if this replacement is made of the same material, the same outcome is likely. Overall, buyers found this to be one of the best valves for daily purposes.

• This is here promptly in good condition.
• This fits great and it has turned on the water supply.
• This allows for a great fit, provides great value and it is easy to use.
• This is easy to install and has been working flawlessly now for over a month.

Best For Hard Water: Essential Values Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

Essential Values line of flappers comes in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. The Essential Values Rubber Flapper Valve is as simple as it could get. The Manufacturer says: Our aftermarket toto toilet flapper replacement is made of high-quality rubber for a tight seal and the chain on it is made of stainless steel with a clip hook. Further, the valve is not compatible with the following two power gravity toilet models.

The valve is good for fast delivery, is highly recommend, it is good for a better price and has an easy installation design. Above all, the essential values rubber flapper valve does the job, is great for expensive fixes and it is easy to attach.

Most customers opine that the valve will last more than 3 years like the last one. Moreover, they also found that the flapper is easy to install in less than 10 minutes. Moreover, they also found that the valve is a silicon flapper that seals the drain securely. Overall, most buyers agree that the valve suits them best, and no one questions it.

• Get yourself a quality aftermarket flapper for toto toilets with essential values.
• It is easy to replace parts.
• This works well with toto tank.
• This is nice because the connection is all the way around and stretches to fit.

Best For Cost Saving: Uming Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Uming Rubber Flapper Valve's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The uming rubberflapper valve is reliable, comes with durable rubber and it is easy to install in seconds. With the toilet flapper, you can easily fix the leaking toilet yourselves without calling the plumber & it costs a lot. This universal toilet flapper compatibled with kohler, gerber, toto 2 '' flush valves toilets & most American standard toilet tank.s.

The valve comes with no tools and it is great for cost saving. Further, this is very easy, it is good for good quality and has a water - saving design. Finally, the uming rubber flappervalve fits most, It is installed in seconds and has universal design.

"Make sure the diameter of the valve is 2 inch.s " - says, one customer. To sum up, buyers found this to be one of the best flappers for daily purposes.

• This is used to remove the old leaky flapper.
• If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
• Good brand reputation.

Best For Great Price: Lydia'S Deal Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

If you want nothing but a flapper that is reliable, this Lydia's deal rubber flapper valve is certainly a wise investment. The Lydia'S Deal Rubber Flapper Valve allows for great fit and it is adjustable for maximum performance. With the toilet flapper, you can easily fix the leaking toilet yourselves without costing a lot. The long - lasting flapper is made of high quality rubber that withstands hard water, & well water.

The flapper is made from long - lasting red rubber, creating a tight and long seal. Moreover, the valve is designed with an oversized sealing surface to fit most 2" toilet models. Above all, the Lydia's deal rubber flapper valve can be installed with no tools and it is like the original.

Almost all customers agree that the valve works well. no leaking. Additionally, it is perfect and no leaking. And, they also found that the pull chain sometimes gets kinked & the valve does n’t close properly. Overall, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• This toilet part replacement includes the universal adjustable flapper & stainless steel chain.
• This is ideal for use in high - efficiency 1.28 to 3.5 gallons per flush toilet.
• New and hot releases.

Best For Money: Ifealclear Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Ifealclear Rubber Flapper Valve's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The ifealclear rubber flapper valve is installed easily and it is coated with black material. Conserve and save water while reducing your bills. This universal toilet flapper not only facilitates less water usage, but works all every time.

Above all, the ifealclear rubber flapper valve can be installed with no tools and it is made for an easy fit.

Almost all customers opine that the valve is easy to install, works well and does what it’s supposed to. Also, they strongly agree that the flapper looks and feels like a quality item. In conclusion, for almost all buyers, it was just what they wanted.

• This is easy to install and has better quality than the generic flappers.
• This fits perfectly and it is with fine workmanship.
• 3.solved the problem of your toilet running quickly and helped your water bill too.
• Stainless steel chain w/ clip hook included, Just adjust the chain length if needed.

Best For Stainless Steel: Crosize Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Crosize Rubber Flapper Valve for daily purpose. The crosize rubberflapper valve is very efficient, it is easy to use and has a simple design. The Manufacturer says: We provide a three-year free warranty service for the product. The quality toilet flapper will also help to save water per flush without leaking anymore.

The valve is suitable for most 2-inch toilet stopper flapper,s including the following kohler models. Most importantly, the crosize rubber flappervalve is compatible with kohler, kallista, gerber 2'' flush valves toilets & most toilet tanks.

In conclusion, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• These toilet drain plugs adopt an integrated design with high manufacturing precision.
• This will not be deformed, long-life, and has good sealing.
• First, turn off the water valve to the toilet.
• Manufacturer says: We focus on providing efficient customer service.

Best For City Water Treatment: Jayen Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Jayen Rubber Flapper Valve for regular usage. The jayen rubber flapper valve is easy to install without additional tools to optimize flushing performance. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The chain is made of stainless steel, durable to use and has a long service life.

Lastly, the jayen rubber flapper valve is made of harmless, sturdy and soft rubber material.

• This is perfect for city water treatment, hard and well water.
• Close the water valve leading to the toilet.
• New and hot releases.

Compatible With Sterling Toilet Models: Amayjuelong Rubber Flapper Valve

Buy on Amazon

The Amayjuelong Rubber Flapper Valve's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. The amayjuelong rubber flapper valve fits 2-inch plastic flush valves. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The flapper adjusts to match original toilet settings and eliminates water waste by decreasing the amount of water flushed.

Lastly, the amayjuelong rubber flapper valve is super easy to install and works great.

• This is compatible with sterling toilet models, it fits most and has a universal design.
• This is made of flexible rubber for a leak-free seal.
• Lot of satisfied buyers.