We consider a toilet tank rubber flapper to be a worthy investment in the long run. In the following post, we will help you to select the best toilet tank rubber flappers.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Korky Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Exact Replacement: Buy: Toto Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best With Quick Shipping: Buy: Kohler Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Hard Water: Buy: Essential Values Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Cost Saving: Buy: Uming Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Perfect Fit: Buy: Impresa Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For City Water Treatment: Buy: Blissvent Hygie Rinse Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For High Quality Replacement Toilet Parts: Buy: Hibbent Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Stainless Steel: Buy: Crosize Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Customer Service: Buy: Ifealclear Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Korky Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Korky toilet tank rubber flapper is the epitome of what a great flapper should be. The Korky Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper is very easy. It is made with fast shipping and has a water - saving design. Toilet tank flapper quickly fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste. Also, it works fine and has a simple design.

Finally, the korky toilet tank rubber flapper is made of flexible rubber for a tight seal and is easy to install, The 54 includes.

Almost all customers opine that the flapper is wonderful, simple, easy and smooth. Also, a few strongly agree that the flapper is the reason for that noise also. Further, they say that the flapper has is these fancy water - saving flapper.

• This is highly recommend, works well for good quality and it lasts longer.
• This works perfectly, it is very happy and has a universal design.
• This is easy to install and fixes the problem immediately.
• This can take days/weeks to get non-urgent repairs done.

Best For Exact Replacement: Toto Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other flappers in this category, the Toto Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper has a convenient design. The toto toilet tank rubber flapper fits perfectly and it is very nice. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, the flapper includes a chain along with instructions for set-up specific to the toto tank model.

The flapper is highly recommend, is built with clear instructions and it is great for simple fix. In addition, this is good for good quality and it is best for good fit. Most importantly, the toto toilet tank rubber flapper is made for very easy install and it can be used for the second time.

Most buyers agree that the flapper will last a long time. Further, they say that the flapper is easy to order, although all the stock numbers were changed. And, a few also found that the flappers will help you, They have great customer service.

• This is better made than the universal flappers sold in stores.
• This flapper requires adjustment during installation per the included configuration guide.
• The original flapper was removed. This new replacement flapper is a breeze to install.
• This is exactly the same thing and works great.

Best With Quick Shipping: Kohler Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Kohler Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper's superior materials makes sure that it ages well with use. The kohler toilet tank rubber flapper can be cut to the right fit, works fine and it is very easy. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, it fits great and it is sturdy.

Above all, the kohler toilet tank rubber flapper is designed by kohler engineers to maintain original product performance and promote product longevity.

Most customers find that the flapper is perfect after two tries, the reason being there are no instructions on the package. Further, they also found that the flapper was perfect and worked as advertised. In addition, a few say that note: if this replacement is made of the same material, the same outcome is likely. In conclusion, buyers found this to be one of the best flappers for daily purposes.

• This is here promptly in good condition.
• This is good for a reasonable price, fits perfectly and it has a turn on water supply.
• This is compatible with the following kohler models.
• This is installed into one of the kohler tanks for which it is designed.

Best For Hard Water: Essential Values Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Best part: essential value toilet tank rubber flapper costs comparatively low and it is available to ship in 24 hours. The Essential Values Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper is not compatible with the following two power gravity toilet models. The Manufacturer says: Our aftermarket toto toilet flapper replacement is made of high-quality rubber for a tight seal and the chain on it is made of stainless steel with a clip hook. Further, the flapper is great for expensive fixes and it is easy to attach.

The flapper is designed for quick install and it stops leaks. In addition, the flapper is as simple as it could get. Finally, the essential values toilet tankrubber flapper is highly recommended and it is made with fine workmanship.

Almost all buyers quickly discovered that the flapper is a good seller for parts. In addition, they strongly agree that the flapper is easy to install, fixed the intermittent tank leaking caused by the old and warped flapper. Therefore, customers were eager to recommend it to friends and would-be buyers.

• A Flapper for toilet tank is helpful to save water and water.
• It is easy to replace parts.
• This is very easy and it makes for a great replacement.
• Get yourself a quality aftermarket flapper for toto toilets with essential values.

Best For Cost Saving: Uming Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for a convenient and suitable flapper, Uming Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper should be your first option for buying. The uming toilet tank rubber flapper is used to remove the old leaky flapper. With the toilet flapper, you can easily fix the leaking toilet yourselves without calling the plumber & it costs a lot. This universal toilet flapper compatibled with kohler, gerber, toto 2 '' flush valves toilets & most American standard toilet tank.s.

The flapper works perfectly, very easily. It is installed in seconds and has a water - saving design. Also, it can be of good quality, comes with durable rubber, it is easy to install in seconds and has a universal design. Lastly, the uming toilettank rubberflapper is sturdy and it fits most.

"They are a little more expensive, but will hold up much longer and are worth the extra expense. " - says, one customer. Therefore, most customers agree that the flapper suits best, and no one questions it.

• If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.

Best For Perfect Fit: Impresa Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other flappers in this category, the Impresa Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper has a convenient design. The impresa toilet tank rubber flapper is suitable for silicone seal, It is easy to for installation instructions and has a simple design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The chain first by removing the clevis pin from the clevis pin from the trip lever rod, then pull the edges of the flapper free from the pegs to remove it.

Lastly, the impresa toilet tank rubber flapper is simpler than you'd expect, and does not require any tools for installation.

Almost all buyers opine that the flapper is easy to instal and it does the job. Further, a few say that the flapper fits well .. perfect plus fits percent works great.

• With this 3 pack value, you will be set for years to come.
• They have to replace the seals every year.
• This has stopped running toilets, works fine and it is made for good replacement.
• This is very easy and it is easy to use.

Best For City Water Treatment: Blissvent Hygie Rinse Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

For a low asking price, Blissvent Hygie Rinse Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper has managed to overwhelm their customers by packing as many features as they could. The blissvent hygie rinse toilet tank rubber flapper is easy to install with no tools, has reduced water waste, it saves money and has a water - saving design. Blue rubber is good for city water treatment, hard water, and well water, keeping your toilet running at an optimal rate. Further, it can be easy to replace old, no tools are required for installation，easy installation design.

The flapper is compatible with gerbers 99. In addition, it is lightweight, no frequent replacement,s built durable for a long life. Most importantly, the blissvent hygie rinse toilet tankrubber flapper is made of high quality rubber for a tight seal and includes a stainless steel chain with a clip hook.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the flapper was a perfect fit for gerber toilet. Also, a few say that the flapper is a supple rubber material and seals well.

• Adjust the chain length if needed.
• 【Feature】blissvent cosestool flapper is lightweight, no frequent replacement,s built durable for a long life.
• This can be fit for 3 inch flush valve.
• This has removed the tank lid and it fits perfectly.

Best For High Quality Replacement Toilet Parts: Hibbent Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Hibbent line of flappers comes in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. The Hibbent Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper comes with replacement toilet parts, is great for a great price and it works well for good quality. Fold those 2 pieces into 2 inch toilet tank paper. This universal toilet flapper compatibled with kohler, gerber, toto 2 '' flush valves toilets & most American standard toilet tank.s.

Lastly, the hibbent toilettank rubber flapper is very happy and it is highly recommend.

Almost all customers found that the flapper is easy to install ....need to wait for longevity. Moreover, a few say that the flapper comes with a stopper and clip like string as well. To sum up, buyers found this to be one of the best flappers for daily purposes.

• This is easy to install 2 pack 2-inch universal tank flapper.
• Loosen the clips of the old flapper 2.
• This is great for high quality replacement toilet parts and it is very good.
• Had to clip the new toilet flapper replacement down in its place 3.

Best For Stainless Steel: Crosize Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Crosize Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper is the most convenient flapper on the market today. The crosize toilet tank rubberflapper is compatible with kohler, kallista, gerber 2'' flush valves toilets & most toilet tanks. First, turn off the water valve to the toilet. These toilet drain plugs adopt an integrated design with high manufacturing precision.

The flapper is suitable for most 2-inch toilet stopper flapper,s including the following kohler models. Most importantly, the crosize toilet tank rubber flapper will not be deformed, long-life, and has good sealing.

Overall, many customers have used the crosize toilet tank rubber flapper for more than a few months without any problems, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• It is easy to use and has a simple design.
• Manufacturer says: We focus on providing efficient customer service.
• If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
• Manufacturer says: we provide a three-year free warranty service for the product.

Best For Customer Service: Ifealclear Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable flapper, Ifealclear Toilet Tank Rubber Flapper is your solution. The ifealclear toilet tank rubber flapper is easy to crack and has a long service life, high sealing. As the water level in the tank is at 1 inch depth, remove the old flapper, and install the new flapper. Also, it is made of high-quality rubber material, making it durable, thus it can be used for a longer time.

Above all, the ifealclear toilet tank rubber flapper is compatible with the American standard 738920.

• Conserve and save water while reducing your bills.
• This is designed with high performance rubber material which ensure durable and reliable.
• This is crafted with fine workmanship and has a universal design.
• Use this American standard flapper assembly to replace the old leaky one.