The 10 Best Rubber Toilet Flappers (2022 reviews)

Not everyone likes to purchase flappers for their daily usage, but the Korky Rubber Toilet Flapper would be an anomoly. The korky rubber toilet flapper features rubber construction to add to that, it is universal and fits 2" plastic flush valves. Toilet tank flapper quickly fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste. Also, the flapper is great with a fast ship and it lasts longer.

Above all, the korky rubber toilet flapper works perfectly and it stopped the leak.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the flapper was the reason for that noise also. Also, they say that the flapper has these fancy water - saving flapper.

Customers also found that its wise to buy a toilet tank rubber flapper, along with this flapper.

Top Customer Quotes:

This allows for quick, easy installation, fits perfectly and it is highly recommended.
This provides great value, it can be trusted for good quality and has an excellent design.
This will already be worth its price.
This is very happy, it does the job and has a water - saving design.

Best With Quick Shipping: Kohler Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase flappers for their daily usage, but the Kohler Rubber Toilet Flapper would be an anomoly. The kohler rubber toilet flapper provides great value, would be perfect with quick shipping and it worked fine. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. In addition, it is made for quick delivery and it is designed for a great price.

The flapper works perfectly, it works great and it fits well. In addition, it is designed by kohler engineers to maintain original product performance and promote product longevity. Lastly, the kohler rubber toilet flapper is made with corrosion resistant material.

Most buyers found that the flapper is easy to install, and makes the whole system work as well as new. Moreover, a few also found that the flapper is a gift for a good neighbor. Also, a few strongly agree that note: if this replacement is made of the same material, the same outcome is likely.

Top Customer Quotes:

This fits perfectly, does the job and it is designed for easy fix.
This allows for a great fit and it keeps us on working.
This is certainly easier than going hunting at the local hardware store.
Protect the kohler products, Always look for the kohler genuine parts logo.

Best For Hard Water: Essential Values Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other flappers in this category, the Essential Values Rubber Toilet Flapper has a convenient design. The essential values rubber toilet flapper very easily. It is good for good quality and has a simple design. High-quality red rubbery-toto universal flapper is also resisting chlorine and gems issues. Moreover, this is highly recommended and it does the job.

The flapper is great for quick install and it is great for expensive fix. Most importantly, the essential values rubber toilet flapper can buy for a better price, would be perfect with great customer service and it is made with fine workmanship.

Almost all buyers found that the flapper works well with the tank. In addition, they strongly agree that the flapper comes with a link to a youtube video on how to install and replace this flapper. Also, a few strongly agree that the flapper will last more than 3 years, like the last one.

Top Customer Quotes:

A Flapper for toilet tank is helpful to save water and water.
Get yourself a quality aftermarket flapper for toto toilets with essential values.
This is a silicon flapper that seals the drain securely.
This is nice because the connection is all the way around and stretches to fit.

Best For Cost Saving: Uming Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Uming Rubber Toilet Flapper is capable of outshining several other flappers featured in this list in overall features for the price point. The uming rubber toilet flapper worked perfectly, It is easy to install in seconds and has a universal design. Measure the diameter of the flush valve drain opening at the bottom of your tank. The quality toilet flapper will also help to save water per flush without leaking anymore.

The flapper works well for good quality, It is made for cost - saving and has a water - saving design. In addition, it is very easy and it comes with durable rubber. Lastly, the uming rubber toilet flapper works perfectly, fits most and it is installed in seconds.

"They are very soft and seal well. " - says, one customer. With no doubts, this flapper passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

Few customers got menards toilet flapper, along with the flapper.

Why We Like This:

This is used to remove the old leaky flapper.
If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
Delivers what they promise.

Best For Easy Installation: Blissvent Hygie Rinse Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other flappers in this category, the Blissvent Hygie Rinse Rubber Toilet Flapper has a convenient design. The blissvent hygie rinse rubber toilet flapper can be easy to replace old, No tools are required for installation，easy installation design. The Manufacturer says: If anything goes wrong, we will provide satisfaction and friendly customer service. Moreover, this is compatible with gerber 99.

The flapper is great for brand name and it installed easily. In addition, the flapper worked perfectly and it had removed the tank lid. Lastly, the blissvent hygie rinse rubber toilet flapper is easy to install with no tools, It stops the leak and has a universal design.

Most buyers found that the flapper fits as well as the original. In addition, they also found that the flappers is only a matter of time before they also started leaking. Overall, many customers have used the blissvent hygie rinse rubbertoilet flapper for more than a few months without any problems, and it shows no sign of giving up.

Customers say that buying a rubber toilet flapper, with this flapper made their life much easier.

Top Customer Quotes:

This is a perfect fit for gerber toilet.
Adjust the chain length if needed.
This works perfectly, fits perfect, it is blue and has a water - saving design.
This is a supple rubber material and seals well.

Best For High Quality Replacement Toilet Parts: Hibbent Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The features department is where the Hibbent Rubber Toilet Flapper truly manages to shine. The hibbent rubber toiletflapper is highly recommended and it is great for a great price. Loosen the clips of the old flapper 2. The 2 " universal flapper fits flush valves in most toilets and the flexible long - lasting rubber creates a tight seal.

The flapper is very happy, worked perfectly and it was very good. And, the flapper comes with replacement toilet parts and it can be trusted for good quality. Most importantly, the hibbent rubber toilet flapper includes a stainless steel chain with a clip hook and float.

Almost all customers quickly discovered that the flapper is easy to install ....need to wait for longevity. Furthermore, a few also found that the flapper is easy to install : 2 pack 2-inch universal tank flapper. Also, they strongly agree that the flapper comes with a stopper and clip like string as well. So, customers were very happy to recommend it to friends and families.

Customers also discovered that its wise to buy a toilet tank rubber flapper, along with this flapper.

Why We Like This:

Had to clip the new toilet flapper replacement down in its place 3.
You will install it easily with confidence.
Fold those 2 pieces into a 2 inch toilet tank flapper.
fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste.

Best For Great Price: Lydia'S Deal Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate flapper. The Lydia's deal rubber toilet flapper is exactly that - it's a simple flapper that hits all the right notes. The Lydia's deal rubber toilet flapper is like the original and it is great for water savings. With the toilet flapper, you can easily fix the leaking toilet yourselves without costing a lot. The long - lasting flapper is made of high quality rubber that withstands hard water, & well water.

The flapper allows for a great fit and it is designed for a great price. Finally, the Lydia's deal rubber toilet flapper is made from long - lasting red rubber, creating a tight and long seal.

Most buyers quickly discovered that the flapper works well. no leaking. Additionally, it is perfect and no leaking. And, they also found that the pull chain sometimes gets kinked & the valve does n’t close properly. Overall, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the flapper suits the purpose.

Why We Like This:

This is designed with an oversized sealing surface to fit most 2" toilet models.
This works as intended and it is adjustable for maximum performance.
This is ideal for use in high - efficiency 1.28 to 3.5 gallons per flush toilet.
This toilet part replacement includes the universal adjustable flapper & stainless steel chain.

Best For Stainless Steel: Chinshwehaw Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Chinshwehaw Rubber Toilet Flapper gives the top-tier flappers a run for their money by offering flagship specs at a much more affordable price. The chinshwehaw rubbertoilet flapper has a tight seal and will not be deformed at will. The manufacturer says: If you don’t like our products, we will provide a full refund for up to one year, so join it now. Also, the flapper is made of high-quality rubber, which is durable and long-term use.

Most importantly, the chinshwehaw rubber toiletflapper is a stainless steel chain with a clasp.

Customers say that getting a toilet tank rubber flapper, along with flapper is useful.

Why We Like This:

This is suitable for urban water treatment, hard water and well water.
Lot of satisfied buyers.

Best With Good Sealing: Crosize Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other flappers in this category, the Crosize Rubber Toilet Flapper has a convenient design. The crosize rubber toilet flapper is not compatible with the following two power gravity toilet models. The Manufacturer says: Our toilet plug has a stainless steel chain, which can be easily adjusted to a suitable height. The quality toilet flapper will also help to save water per flush without leaking anymore.

The flapper will not be deformed, long-life, and has good sealing. Most importantly, the crosize rubber toilet flapper is very efficient, is easy to use, it allows adjustment and has a simple design.

Obviously, this product passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

Customers found that getting a toilet tank rubber flapper, with this flapper made their life much easier.

Why We Like This:

If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
Replacement for toto flapper model thu138s.
First, turn off the water valve to the toilet.
This fits the g-max, thu499s, thu331s, thu175s & 2021bp models.

Best For Good Replacement: Amayjuelong Rubber Toilet Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another flapper that manages to win our hearts. It's the Amayjuelong Rubber Toilet Flapper and it's widely considered as the flapper that has the most suitable features. The amayjuelong rubber toilet flapper is made of flexible silicone rubber material, making it durable, thus could be used for a longer time. Flapper replacement kit, quickly fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste. The flapper adjusts to match original toilet settings and eliminates water waste by decreasing the amount of water flushed.

The flapper is blue and it is compatible with henshaw. And, the flapper is super easy to install and works great. Most importantly, the amayjuelong rubber toilet flapper is made of soft material and it is sturdy and functional to make a great seal.

Customers also discovered that its wise to buy a toilet tank rubber flapper, along with this flapper.

Why We Like This:

This is compatible with Lowe's aquasource toilets.
This is a good replacement for the needed 3 inch stopper flapper for various types of toilets.
Good brand reputation.