The 7 Best saltwater Taffy sweets (2023 reviews)

Best runner up:

Buy: Sweet Candy company Good Candy

Best For decorations:

Buy: Sweet Candy company Party favor Box

Best For Candy buffet:

Best peppermint Salt water:

Buy: Sweet Candy company Salt water

Best Accuracy:

Best value For money:

Best Overall: saltwater Taffy Sweet

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a water. This product is exactly that - it's a simple product that hits all the right notes. If you love spicy, cinnamon and taffy you should get this. They are pretty in a candy dish for Valentine's Day, Easter, July 4th, Christmas, and anytime you want a sweet treat by SWEETS. It is nice and fresh with a great flavor. The cinnamon gives the taffy a mild spicy flavor. It is not so hot as to make you cry but it wakes up your mouth as it dissolves.

The taffy is nice to have around for DIABETICS, stage. It is fresh and chewy, not sweet, just perfect saltwater taffy.

Why We Like This:

Has a nice cinnamon kick to it
Dry crumbs and pieces of taffy in the wrapper
Strong cinnamon flavor, great for cinnamon lovers
Great cinnamon taffy, not too spicey

Best runner up: Sweet Candy company Good Candy

If you want nothing short of the best possible water for your daily usage, this product is certainly a worthy investment. This Cotton Candy Taffy is delicious. It has no real flavor other than sweet. The variety of flavors all taste very good. The color is perfect, the taste replicates cotton candy perfectly, & they are fresh. The taffy is very fresh, soft and chewy good. It comes in 3 nice 1-lb boxes and is melt-in-your-mouth soft.

Customers also found that its wise to buy a saltwater taffy gift box, along with this water.

Why We Like This:

Fresh, soft, and not too chewy with very good flavors
New and hot release

Best For decorations: Sweet Candy company Party favor Box

The sweet candy company party favor box has killer features for the price point. It’s definitely not salt water taffy, but it tastes like regular taffy candy. It is individually wrapped and it is one of the nation’s leading designer, importer, and wholesale distributor of amusement toys, novelties, giftware, and incentive merchandise. These are easily chewable and bursting with flavor. The taffy is nice and soft and has a great color. These come in fast and are packaged neatly. It is perfect for decorations and party favors. These are so good that you’ll want to hide them from yourself.

Why We Like This:

Soft and chewy, great flavor and clearly they’ve been freshly made
Really a good tasting taffy without sticking to you teeth
Delivers what they promise

Best For Candy buffet: saltwater Taffy Sweet

The saltwater taffy sweet is capable of outshining several other products featured in this list in overall features for the price point. Sweet's Key Lime Taffy is a tart and tangy key lime flavor in a soft, wonderful piece of taffy. It has three pounds of Key Lime taffy and it is such a vibrant, pure, delicious lime (although it really is more the classic lime flavor than "key" lime), three pounds and it will almost be too much lime.

This brand has a very strong lime flavor that will make your lips pucker and mouth water. The flavor is great, and the green doesn't taste artificial. If you like Key Lime pie, this is the Taffy for you.

Why We Like This:

Lot of satisfied buyers
Good brand reputation

Best peppermint Salt water: Sweet Candy company Salt water

Next on the list, we've got yet another product that manages to win our hearts. It's the sweet candy company salt water and it's widely considered as product that has the most suitable features.

Few customers got saltwater taffy sweet, along with the water.

Why We Like This:

Great balance of sweetness and peppermint with classic taffy chewiness
Very smooth nice peppermint taste and not too salty
Good brand reputation

Best Accuracy: saltwater Taffy Sweet

Sweet Candy Company has been making great water for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and appropriate materials. There is a Lemon Lime Flavor and Key Lime Flavor but no Lemonade flavor.

Customers say that buying a saltwater taffy gift box, with this water made their life much easier.

Why We Like This:

Corn syrup, sugar, coconut oil, egg whites, salt, natural and artificial flavor
Definitely more chewy and harder on the teeth
Very flavorful, and a nice assortment
Not hard, not sticky, and very flavorful

Best value For money: saltwater Taffy Sweet