The 10 Best Sour Cherries In Syrup (2023 reviews)

We consider a sour cherry in syrup to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your needs from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Toschi Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best With liquor: Buy: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Ice cream: Buy: Oregon Chai Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For topping on cheesecake: Buy: Amarena Fabbri Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best With stem: Buy: Collins Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Bourbon: Buy: Hotel Starlino Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For baking: Buy: Sanniti Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Whiskey: Buy: Roland foods Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Black Forest cake: Buy: Specially selected Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Cherry pie: Buy: Gefen Sour Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best overall: Toschi Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Toschi line of cherry come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. These cherries are very tasty and great in drinks. They are absolutely superior to any cherry and add the quality gourmet touch to any beverage, especially an old fashioned or Manhattan. It shines as a glaze for pork or chicken and will even turn Brussel sprouts into a favorite side. It is perfect for cocktails, ice creams, pancakes, waffles or straight from the jar into your mouth. These candied sour black cherries are used at home and in restaurants and bars around the world.

These are the best cherries ever. This is absolutely a must when making cocktails, and these are delicious.

• Syrup is thick and good to use in many drinks
• Excellent value for a high quality product with great taste and texture
• Delicious, great as an easy dessert

Best With liquor: Luxardo original Maraschino Cherries Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Luxardo Original Maraschino Cherries line of cherry come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. Luxardo's maraschino cherries just make every cocktail drink exquisite. They are incredible and go great in any cocktail. There's only enough syrup to suspend them in, and it tastes like something you actually want to eat. The syrup is thick and dark. There is no bright red dye or chemical flavor in these. These cherries contain no artificial ingredients. These are definitely the real deal and provide the correct flavor and even texture for any cocktail calling for a maraschino cherry.

• Totally versatile for savory dishes that can handle a little sweetness
• Ideal for the craft cocktail maker in you
• Best maraschino cherries for mixed drinks

Best For Ice cream: Oregon Chai Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cherry that manages to win our hearts. It's the oregon chai sour cherry in syrup and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient cherry you can buy. These make the best pies. It's much better than the ones for pie cherries. Add your own favorite pie crust, sugar and other filling ingredients and these cherries will take you back to the best cherry pie you ever had. It calls for draining the juice to combine it with corn starch and sugar and cook till boiling.

The cherries are delicious, come packed in water so no heavy syrup. They are consistantly fresh and easy to cook with. They are great for cooking or eating.

• Taste pretty good mixed with other fruit like a fruit cocktail
• Perfect for making black forest cherry cake or just straight from the can
• Simple way to make a pie

Best For topping on cheesecake: Amarena Fabbri Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable cherry, amarena fabbri sour cherry in syrup should be your first option for buying. It is the pinnacle of cherry indulgence, adaptable to a variety of uses that food industry aficionados want to create memorable culinary delights. These are dark red cherries covered in a very thick and sweet syrup. They can stand up to the alcohol and the naturally slight boozy note to the flavor of course makes them integrate perfectly. They are meaningfully sweeter than the Luxardos, and they are not quite as dense.

This is nothing like those bright red, nasty sweet cocktail cherries, but rather a delicious balance of sweet and tart. The cherries are on the more tart side and the syrup is sweet but not sickeningly so. It can be used in many ways.

• Great flavor, beautiful container that can be reused for various things if you want
• A fun, unique gift for gift bags
• Yummy with chocolate ganache and ice creams
• Great taste and the syrup is not overly sweet

Best With stem: Collins Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Collins offers a variety of cherry for personal choice and yet maintaining quality in all the variants. Deep purple and juicy, these cherries are perfect for those looking for an authentic option. These gourmet sour cherries have a strong bing flavour that stands up to the stiffest drinks.

These amarena cherries in syrup are the ideal gift for parties, housewarming, weddings, birthdays, or just as a surprise gift for cocktail connoisseurs. It is perfect for those looking for an authentic option. It is perfect for adding the finishing touch, and the stemless amarena cherries are the best way to achieve authentic cocktails that you’d find at even the most prestigious bars.

• One of the new comers and featured product
• Good brand reputation

Best For Bourbon: Hotel Starlino Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

The hotel starlino sour cherry in syrup's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. There is no better cocktail cherry for your manhattan old fashioned. It is used to have canned cherries which tastes very sweet. It tastes sweet with a little bit of sour. It is great for garnishing bourbon or brandy drinks, or pour the marasca juice in your cocktail shaker as a drink mixer. There are no stems or pits in these cherries. These are in a thick & syrupy sauce that is sickly sweet to the point of hiding the fruit taste.

These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any diseases. It is great for adding a little luxury to your favorite desserts.

• Great on desserts and in drinks
• Thick, syrupy & way too sweet
• Great quality fruits in sweet syrup

Best For baking: Sanniti Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

The sanniti sour cherry in syrup is suitable and reliable and fits well with your daily purpose. Whether you’re just looking for something sweet for breakfast or you’re decorating an entire cake, rex has the confections you desire. These cocktail cherries are just as good and a MUCH better value than the more popular/famous brand. Unlike standard red maraschinos, these are deep red and packed in a sweep syrup that keeps them fresh. They do have a slightly different texture though.

These are big plump cherries to add to that it is perfect for an old fashion. It is ideal for baking a fruit cake, while sliced and whole candied fruit make excellent cake toppings and designs. The syrup in which the cherries are packed alone is worth the cost.

• Delivers what they promise
• Good investment for long term

Best For Whiskey: Roland foods Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention roland foods sour cherry in syrup for regular usage. These cherries taste almost the same as Amarena Toschi Italian Cherries in Syrup 18 Oz. It comes with a sweet and slighly sour flavor and a beautiful dark red color, amarena cherries are a wonderful addition to sweets. This is the happy medium between the neon-red, sugar bomb monstrosities and the luxurious, perfectly balanced Luxardo. The thick syrup is also a great additive flavor to your cocktails or dishes.

The Luxardo Cherries are smaller and delicate, but intensely flavorful. There is enough sugar in the syrup that they will keep a very long time that way. It is ideal for use in food service or in the home.

• Great for cocktails & other things
• Use them in drinks cookies, scones, with chicken, etc
• Delivers what they promise

Best For Black Forest cake: Specially selected Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the specially selected sour cherry in syrup has a convenient design. These cherries are perfect for making cherry pies. The texture is good and the flavor is great. It is filling for an awesome cherry pie. The syrup in the jar has a watery flow. It is packaged to ensure no breakage. They are the perfect cherries for the dish.

• Delivers what they promise
• Good investment for long term

Best For Cherry pie: Gefen Sour Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

The gefen sour cherry in syrup's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. These cherries are perfect for cakes, smoothies, any desert, or over vanilla ice-cream. It is great in desserts, jams, sauces, cakes, cherry pies, cocktails & in any recipes calling for sweet cherries. They are also extremely soft.

• Contains calcium, potassium, antioxidants, vitamin d, protein, fiber, iron
• Certified kosher for year round use including passover
• Top quality pitted dark sweet cherries in water
• High fructose corn syrup, gluten free