The 7 Best Pitted Cherries In Syrup (2023 reviews)

We consider a pitted cherry in syrup to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: Toschi Pitted Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Ice cream: Buy: Oregon Chai Oregon Fruit READ REVIEW

Best For Black Forest cake: Buy: Specially selected Pitted Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For cooking With Sweet Cherries: Buy: Oregon Chai Pitted Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For Cherry pie: Buy: Gefen Pitted Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best With pork chops: Buy: Oregon specialty Fruit Pitted Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best For pie: Buy: Gefen Pitted Cherry In Syrup READ REVIEW

Best overall: Toschi Pitted Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Here, we present cherry that manages to win our hearts. It's the toschi pitted cherry in syrup and it's widely considered as one of all-around great cherry you can buy. If you are looking for cherries to put in your "old fashion" drink then try these. It comes in a heavy duty, beautiful ceramic jar that can be used over and over. It is great in a manhatten (drink), on ice cream, and various desserts or garnish. These are pricey but the jar is large, heavy duty and it is filled with cherries and cherry syrup. They definitely have a sweet front and a tart finish.

These are exceptional and the syrup is good too. They are great for Manhattans and Old Fashioned cocktails. The syrup is not too thick and overpowering.

• Perfect for manhattan's or just with straight bourbon
• Really great compliment to deserts like ice cream or cake
• A great ice cream topper or drink accompaniment

Best For Ice cream: Oregon Chai Oregon Fruit

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The oregon chai oregon fruit is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. These cherries make a great tart cherry pie. It is great canned fruit to top cottage cheese or yogurt. It calls for draining the juice to combine it with corn starch and sugar and cook till boiling. The end result is a delicious pie that tastes better than anything you can buy in a store or bakery, and has much less sugar. The cherries are firm, delicious and fresh. They are the best cherry for pies. They are great for cooking or eating.

• Texture of the fruit is also well preserved
• Awesome product, corn syrup free, delicious
• Taste pretty good mixed with other fruit like a fruit cocktail
• Very nice quality with just a few bad berries in each can

Best For Black Forest cake: Specially selected Pitted Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other cherry in this category, the specially selected pitted cherry in syrup has a convenient design. It makes the best cherry pie ever. These are very close to the fresh fruit. The syrup in the jar has a watery flow. They are the perfect cherries for the dish. They are well packaged to ensure no breakage. The texture is good and the flavor is great. It is filling for an awesome cherry pie.

• Lot of satisfied buyers
• Good brand reputation

Best For cooking With Sweet Cherries: Oregon Chai Pitted Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

The oregon chai pitted cherry in syrup is capable of outshining several other cherry featured in this list in overall features for the price point. It is best choice for cooking with sweet cherries. The rich ripe flavor with the firmness of fresh fruit, these cherries are a wonderful treat to enjoy anytime.

• Use for pies, cakes, cobbler, ice-cream topping, fruit salad, sauces and chutney
• Tree-ripened pitted sweet black cherries in syrup
• Good tasting especially in the middle of winter for desert

Best For Cherry pie: Gefen Pitted Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

These cherries are perfect for cakes, smoothies, any desert, or over vanilla ice-cream. They are also extremely soft. It is great in desserts, jams, sauces, cakes, cherry pies, cocktails & in any recipes calling for sweet cherries. These are also extremely soft to add to that it is perfect for deep dish cherry pie.

• Top quality pitted dark sweet cherries in water
• Contains calcium, potassium, antioxidants, vitamin d, protein, fiber, iron
• High fructose corn syrup, gluten free
• Certified kosher for year round use including passover

Best With pork chops: Oregon specialty Fruit Pitted Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

Not everyone likes to purchase cherry for their daily purpose, but the oregon specialty fruit pitted cherry in syrup would be an anomoly. Because it comes with rich sweetness and a touch of vibrant tang, these fleshy, dark sweet cherries are wonderful for pies and cobblers.

• Great cherries for all your recipes
• Dairy free|gluten free|low salt|vegan|wheat free|yeast free
• Good brand reputation

Best For pie: Gefen Pitted Cherry In Syrup

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable cherry, gefen pitted cherry in syrup should be your first option for buying. Tart cherries have anti-inflammatory properties. The cherries are uniformly round and intact. It is great in desserts, jams, cakes, cherry pies, cocktails & any recipes calling for sour cherries. The water they are packed in is a treat in itself.

These tart cherries make the most delicious pie. The gelatin is good for joints, nails and hair, and for gut health. It is good as fresh or frozen, but a solid second option. It is perfect for black forest cake.

• Delicious cherries for a pie and a tart
• Easy access to canned sour cherries
• Lot of satisfied buyers