The 7 Best The Best Cheddar Cheese (2023 reviews)

We consider a the best cheddar cheese to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best overall: Buy: organic Valley The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best tasting Cheese: Buy: 365 by whole foods market The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best For cracker: Buy: pub Cheese The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best size Cheese: Buy: hickory farms The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best For mac: Buy: Wisconsin Cheeseman The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best For Charcuterie: Buy: Widmers Cheese Cellars The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best For sandwiches: Buy: Black Diamond The Best Cheddar Cheese READ REVIEW

Best overall: organic Valley The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Organic Valley has been making good-quality cheese for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and high-end materials. Organic pastures makes a raw cheese that’s good too, but it’s more mozzarella-like. This organic cheese has a delectable aged sharp cheddar taste and flower petal top. The flavor and texture is just right. This one is great for sandwiches, pairing with apples, and just eating as a snack on the go.

These cows graze on lush, organic pastures during the grazing season and dried grasses in the winter. It has a pleasant sharpness so pull the cork on your favorite malbec or bold red for a great pairing. This cheese is a solid option for those who enjoy and benefit from raw dairy.

• Slightly sharp, but not overpowering at all
• Phenomenal semi sharp taste for sandwiches and burgers
• Organic grass-fed cultured unpasteurized milk, sea salt, enzyme

Best tasting Cheese: 365 by whole foods market The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Next on the list, we've got yet another cheese that manages to win our hearts. It's the 365 by whole foods market the best cheddar cheese and it's widely considered as one of the best convenient cheese you can buy.

• Great flavor and bag keeps it fresh
• Sharp yummy semi spicy organic cheese squares
• Real sliced cheddar (so it will break into chunks) melts great

Best For cracker: pub Cheese The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

The pub cheese the best cheddar cheese is capable of outshining several other cheese featured in this list in overall features for the price point. This makes an excellent low carb, keto friendly dip. It's so spreadable right out of the fridge, very whipped and buttery, cheddary with a nice horse radish kick that goes pleasantly up the back of your nose. It pairs well with a variety of crackers.

• Served with berries with sugar free heavy whipped cream
• Deliciously tasty spread for crackers with a tangy bite
• Good brand reputation

Best size Cheese: hickory farms The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

The hickory farms the best cheddar cheese is capable of outshining several other cheese featured in this list in overall features for the price point. It pairs well with everything but is just as delicious on its own. It is aged with a hint of swiss to make this classic hickory farms blend. The smoky flavor is delightful.

• The perfect blend of cheddar and swiss
• New and hot release

Best For mac: Wisconsin Cheeseman The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

The wisconsin cheeseman the best cheddar cheese should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. It makes good cheese sandwich’s with lettuce, onions, mustard and mayonnaise. It's fresh and has that sharp flavor. It is great for mac & cheese or shredded on grits.

• Noble character and sharp flavor that can only come from careful aging
• Serve with full-bodied red wines, crisp whites and robust beers
• Great cheddar taste and not too sharp

Best For Charcuterie: Widmers Cheese Cellars The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

The Widmer ten year cheese tastes absolutely fantastic and there's no problem with it. It is used to white cheddar and is smooth and has a small amount of crystallization going on. The texture and unique flavor is why you pay more money for this unique cheese.

This is an intense, sharp yellow cheddar. It is better suited for gourmet mac-n-cheese or a great cheeseburger than for a charcuterie plate. It is a straddle between crumbliness and melting properties.

• Excellent flavor and presence reflecting it's careful aging
• Grilled cheese with sourdough bread is awesome
• Great umami flavor that comes only with good starting quality and serious age

Best For sandwiches: Black Diamond The Best Cheddar Cheese

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable cheese, black diamond the best cheddar cheese should be your first option for buying. It is good as boar's head canadian cheddar. It is made with an a-b taste test. It has a very distinctive flavor. It even lightly crumbles when sliced. It is made from pasteurized cow's milk. Its taste is a little more "sharp" than most extra sharp commercial cheddars. It is great for snacking or sandwiches.

• Very good with crackers, sour dough bread and wine
• Slightly drier and crumbly texture, with a matured cheddar flavor and pleasant sharpness
• Has a great flavor and lasts a long time