There are several advantages of having a toilet water flapper. Let’s take you step by step, type by type, and find the best toilet water flapper for you.

Our review process: Show/Hide

Our Top Picks:

Best Overall: Buy: Fluidmaster Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Easy Install: Buy: Korky Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For High Performance: Buy: Ifealclear Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Hard Water: Buy: Hibbent Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Cost Saving: Buy: Uming Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Great Price: Buy: Lydia'S Deal Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Good Value: Buy: Mudder Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Long Lasting Use: Buy: Plumb Craft Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For Customer Service: Buy: Crosize Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best For City Water Treatment: Buy: Jayen Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Compatible With Sterling Toilet Models: Buy: Amayjuelong Toilet Water Flapper READ REVIEW

Best Overall: Fluidmaster Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Fluidmaster Toilet Water Flapper is capable of outshining several other flappers featured in this list in overall features. The fluidmaster toilet water flapper makes for a great replacement and has a universal design. The rigid frame aligns the flapper properly on every flush. In addition, the flapper is made for easy repair, It is designed for exact replacement and has a very good design.

The flapper worked perfectly, has fill valves and it is made for a perfect fit. Moreover, it is good for fast delivery, it is adjustable for maximum performance and has a water - saving design. Above all, the fluidmaster toilet water flapper is adjustable for optimum performance and water savings, is corrosion-resistant, and has a solid frame for ultimate reliability.

Almost all customers found that the flapper works well and reduces water use in older toilet.s. And, they say that the flapper is a two - inch type. Moreover, a few say that the flapper is easy to install and seemed to fit right. Overall, for almost all customers, Fluidmaster product was what they were looking for.

• Fixes most common cause of running toilet.
• The flapper, a dial to adjust the amount of water in the flush.
• This works well and is a very good price on Amazon.
• This is perfect after adjusting the chain length.

Best For Easy Install: Korky Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for a convenient and suitable flapper, Korky Toilet Water Flapper should be your first option for buying. The korky toilet water flapper features rubber construction to add to that, it is universal and fits 2" plastic flush valves. Toilet tank flapper quickly fixes running and leaking toilets and eliminates costly water waste. Moreover, the flapper is highly recommend, it provides great value and has a water - saving design.

The flapper would be perfect for fast ship, it allows for quick, easy installation and has a practical design. Further, it is made of flexible rubber for a tight seal and is easy to install, The 54 includes. Most importantly, the korky toilet water flapper is designed for easy installing and it works flawlessly.

Most buyers found that the flapper is wonderful, simple, easy and smooth. And, a few say that the flapper can take days/weeks to get non-urgent repairs done. In short, at the price, they believe that they got a steal of a deal with it.

• This will already be worth its price.
• This is very happy, lasts longer, it works better and has an excellent design.
• This is the reason for that noise also.
• This does the job and it is practical.

Best For High Performance: Ifealclear Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, amazon sellers, and family and friends what most people want in a convenient and appropriate flapper. The Ifealclear Toilet Water Flapper is exactly that - it's a simple flapper that hits all the right notes. The ifealclear toilet water flapper is easy to crack and has a long service life. 4If you're looking for a fit for the part gerber 99. And, the flapper is compatible with gerbers 99.

The flapper is designed for high performance, It has fast recovery in seconds and has an easy installation design. And, this has removed the tank lid and it is made for easy installation. Finally, the ifealclear toilet water flapper is great for brand name, can be installed with no tools and it is strong.

One customer says - "Simple to install, but ensure the model matches the toilet in your home. ". Most buyers agree that the flapper works for a 3inch opening.

• This includes a stainless steel chain w/ clip hook.
• This is made for good replacement and it makes for great replacement.
• This is with fine workmanship, is pretty reliable and it fits perfectly.
• This is for the larger 3" opening.

Best For Hard Water: Hibbent Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Best part: Hibbent Toilet Water Flapper costs comparatively little and it is available to ship in 24 hours. The hibbent toilet water flapper is compatible with toto g-max thu499s, thu175s & 2021bp. You can easily fix the toilet without calling a plumber, and solve leaking, hissing, running toilet,s double flush, and worn toilet flapper. This toilet flapper stopper is made of quality rubber material that has a good sealing effect, which can well prevent leakage.

The flapper is built with durable and soft rubber, sturdy stainless chain that has no twist, corrosion-resistant, and provides the best seal to save water. Most importantly, the hibbent toilet water flapper is easy to understand, it works great and it does the job.

Almost all customers agree that the flappers come in different sizes ranging from 2" to 4. Moreover, they also found that the flapper is great for a toto toilet.

• This includes a 3" flapper and a stainless steel chain with a clip hook.
• 3 inch toilet flapper can quickly solve leaking toilets and reduce costly water waste.
• This is coated with durable rubber and it fits well.
• This is not compatible with the following two models.

Best For Cost Saving: Uming Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Uming is known for creating pragmatic and minimalist flappers for people on the go, and its line of Uming Toilet Water Flappers definitely falls in line with that reputation. The uming toilet water flapper comes with durable rubber and it fits perfectly. Measure the diameter of the flush valve drain opening at the bottom of your tank. The new toilet flapper was corrosion - resistant, no twist & provided the best seal.

The flapper worked perfectly and it is great for high quality. In addition, it comes with no tools, many more, It is great for cost saving and has a universal design. Lastly, the uming toilet waterflapper is easy to install in seconds, It has installed in seconds and has a water - saving design.

"Make sure the diameter of the valve is 2 inch.s " - says, one customer. Obviously, this flapper passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
• This is used to remove the old leaky flapper.
• New and hot releases.

Best For Great Price: Lydia'S Deal Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself confused about convenient and suitable flapper, Lydia's deal toiletwater flapper should be your first option for buying. The Lydia'S Deal Toilet Water Flapper fits most 3-inch flush valve toilets and is ideal for use in high - efficiency 1.28 to 3.5 gallons per flush toilets. It's durable to use and not easy to rust or break, You can apply it for a long time. This toilet part replacement includes the universal adjustable flapper & stainless steel chain with a clip hook.

Above all, the Lydia's deal toilet water flapper allows for great fit, It is adjustable for maximum performance and has a universal design.

Most customers quickly discovered that the flapper works well with no leaking and also it is perfectly and no leaking. Further, they say that the pull chain sometimes gets kinked & the valve does n’t close properly. To sum up, the tone of buyers is very positive and we believe that the flapper suits the purpose.

• This is made from long - lasting red rubber, creating a tight and long seal.
• One of the newcomers and featured product.

Best For Good Value: Mudder Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Mudder Toilet Water Flapper's material feels more premium than its price would suggest. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. Moreover, the flapper is made for good value and it is compatible with cst44s. In short, with a 3.7 rating and more than 832 buyers, the Mudder toilet water flapper stands as the best choice.

"Toilet flapper works great now. " - says, one customer. In short, many buyers have used the mudder toilet water flapper for more than a few months without letup, and it shows no sign of giving up.

• Good investment for the long term.
• New and hot releases.

Best For Long Lasting Use: Plumb Craft Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Plumb Craft Toilet Water Flapper for daily purpose. The plumb craft toilet water flapper is easy to for installation instructions, It is made for simple installation and has a universal design. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The 3 - inch universal fit water saving toilet flapper adjusts to fit most 3 - inch flush valves.

Lastly, the plumb craft toilet waterflapper is good for water consumption, can look for detailed instructions, it has fill valves and has an easy installation design.

Most buyers agree that the flapper is a perfect replacement for leaky degraded flapper. Also, a few say that this problem is to pulling the top of the tank, unscrewing the valve assembly, using a knife or pick to remove the contaminant and then reassemble the valve. In conclusion, buyers found this to be one of the best flappers for daily purposes.

• Universal design fits most large 3" toilet flush valves.
• Detailed instructions make installation quick and easy.
• Engineered materials resist chlorinated and harsh water for a longer life.
• Save water and stop toilets from running with adjustable design.

Best For Customer Service: Crosize Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

Compared with other flappers in this category, the Crosize Toilet Water Flapper has a convenient design. The crosize toiletwater flapper is not compatible with the following two power gravity toilet models. First, turn off the water valve to the toilet. The quality toilet flapper will also help to save water per flush without leaking anymore.

The flapper is made of flexible rubber for a tight seal and is easy to install, 2021 includes (1) large 3" flapper and (1) stainless steel chain. Further, it will not be deformed, long-life, and has good sealing. Finally, the crosize toilet water flapper is very efficient, is easy to use and it allows adjustment.

Obviously, this flapper passed the test and had very satisfied buyers eager to share their experience.

• If so, congratulations on finding the perfect toilet flapper.
• Replacement for toto flapper model thu138s.
• Manufacturer says: we provide a three-year free warranty service for the product.
• Manufacturer says: We focus on providing efficient customer service.

Best For City Water Treatment: Jayen Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention Jayen Toilet Water Flapper for daily purpose. The jayen toilet water flapper is easy to install without additional tools to optimize flushing performance. Designed with an oversized sealing surface to fit most 2" toilet models, which can help you repair your toilet leak, and save you time in finding the right chain. The chain is made of stainless steel, durable to use and has a long service life.

Lastly, the jayen toilet water flapper is made of harmless, sturdy and soft rubber material.

• Close the water valve leading to the toilet.
• This is perfect for city water treatment, hard and well water.
• Lot of satisfied buyers.

Compatible With Sterling Toilet Models: Amayjuelong Toilet Water Flapper

Buy on Amazon

The Amayjuelong Toilet Water Flapper is satisfactory and appropriate and fits well with your daily use. The amayjuelong toilet water flapper is compatible with the American standard and most toilet brands with 2-inch toilet tank valve opening. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. The flapper adjusts to match original toilet settings and eliminates water waste by decreasing the amount of water flushed.

The flapper is super easy to install and works great. Most importantly, the amayjuelong toilet water flapper has 2-inch plastic flush valves.

• This is made of flexible rubber for a leak-free seal.
• This is compatible with sterling toilet models, there are many more and has a universal design.
• Delivers what they promise.