The 7 Best Aged Cheese (2023 reviews)

Date : May 09, 2023
Categories : Cheddar Cheese

We consider a aged cheese to be a worthy investment in the long run. We are here to help you choose the right one for your purposes from all the best available products in market today.

Our review process:

Our Top Picks:

Best overall:

Buy: organic Valley Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best With ice pack:

Buy: Wisconsin Cheese Mart since 1938 Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best For melt:

Buy: Made In Oregon Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best For snacking:

Buy: Wisconsin Cheese Mart since 1938 Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best For Cheese Board:

Buy: Wisconsin'S Best And Wisconsin Cheese Company Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best For Queso:

Buy: Wisconsins Best And Wisconsin Cheese Company Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best value For money:

Buy: Aplenty Aged Cheese

READ REVIEW

Best overall: organic Valley Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Organic Valley has been making good-quality cheese for years, thanks to a combination of clever design and high-end materials. Organic pastures makes a raw cheese that’s good too, but it’s more mozzarella-like. This organic cheese has a delectable aged sharp cheddar taste and flower petal top. These cows graze on lush, organic pastures during the grazing season and dried grasses in the winter. It has a pleasant sharpness so pull the cork on your favorite malbec or bold red for a great pairing.

It has a good consistency and tastes great. This cheese is a solid option for those who enjoy and benefit from raw dairy. The flavor and texture is just right. This one is great for sandwiches, pairing with apples, and just eating as a snack on the go.

Why We Like This:

Slightly sharp, but not overpowering at all
Phenomenal semi sharp taste for sandwiches and burgers
Organic grass-fed cultured unpasteurized milk, sea salt, enzyme

Best With ice pack: Wisconsin Cheese Mart since 1938 Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

It is a traditional wisconsin golden colored cheddar. The sharp flavor makes this cheese perfect for any beer or wine tasting, gives sandwiches a delicious zing, and can even be paired perfectly with gourmet sausage. It is extremely flavorful and an excellent sharp cheddar cheese. It is great with an ice pack to reuse.

Why We Like This:

Really good flavor profile, surprisingly creamy with good bite
Good brand reputation

Best For melt: Made In Oregon Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

It is good as big production cheddar gets. It is always made from rbst free cow's milk. This cheese is wonderfully sharp and you can serve it with crackers or melt it over veggies or for a real wow use it as one of your cheeses in making homemade mac and cheese. It makes for a good addition to a wine and cheese party (being this is so strong, you can serve a good strong red wine with it) or for a gift basket. The texture and flavor are very good, and the aging develops the flavor even more.

Why We Like This:

Good cheese, not exceptional, grates well and cooks well
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For snacking: Wisconsin Cheese Mart since 1938 Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

This is a truly sharp aged cheddar. The sharp flavor makes this cheese perfect for any beer or wine tasting, gives sandwiches a delicious zing, and can even be paired perfectly with gourmet sausage. It is good for snacking, and it melts well too. The quality of this cheese is very good.

Why We Like This:

New and hot release
Lot of satisfied buyers

Best For Cheese Board: Wisconsin'S Best And Wisconsin Cheese Company Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cheese. The wisconsin's best and wisconsin cheese company aged cheese is exactly that - it's a simple cheese that hits all the right notes. It is perfect for a topping on apple pie, toast, bagels, or apple pie.

Why We Like This:

Good brand reputation
One of the new comers and featured product

Best For Queso: Wisconsins Best And Wisconsin Cheese Company Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

Looking for something to Bring to your Next Event or Gathering. This Elite Aged Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese is for the REAL Cheese Connoisseur. It is great addition to your cheese and sausage charcuterie board, bloody mary bar, wine & cheese tray, beer & cheese party platter and sandwich tray. It is perfect to add to your wine & cheese gift basket or your beer & cheese lover basket, to add to your cheese charcuterie board, paired with fruits, crackers, crusty french bread, beer, wine or whiskey.THIS Cheese will be a HIT Cheese.

Why We Like This:

Slice and add with crackers, breads, fruit
Excellent to add to beer, wine & whiskey tastings and bars
Melt for cheese sauces, warm bread, pastas, fondue and sandwiches

Best value For money: Aplenty Aged Cheese

Buy on Amazon

We would, of course, be remiss if we didn't mention aplenty aged cheese for daily purpose. This classic New York cheddar is aged 12 months for a bold, powerful flavor. A just-right sprinkle of sea salt enhances the authentic flavor and crunch. It's very rich and pairs well with dry or sweet wine.

Why We Like This: