The 9 Best garnish Old Fashioned Cherries (2023 reviews)

Luxardo Original Maraschino Cherries line of cherry come in a pretty wide variety of styles, so you can definitely find one that suits your individual preferences and needs. Two of these cherries will outpower a dozen of those bright red "things. They have great dark cherry flavor and a delicious, rich syrup. The syrup is thick and appropriate for a cocktail mixer. There is enough of the delicious syrup in the jar to add cherry for garnish and syrup to taste. These cherries contain no artificial ingredients. They are delicious and are a treat unto themselves.

These are dark, intensely flavored, and the juice is divine. It is great for homemade chocolate covered cherries. There is no bright red dye or chemical flavor in these cherries.

Why We Like This:

Worth the money if you like delicious desserts
Ideal for the craft cocktail maker in you
New and hot release

Best For Ice cream: Amarena Fabbri garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

If you often find yourself scrambling for convenient and suitable cherry, amarena fabbri garnish old fashioned cherry is your end point. This is nothing like those bright red, nasty sweet cocktail cherries, but rather a delicious balance of sweet and tart. It is perfect to compliment a manhattan cocktail. The cherries themselves are identical, and they come with more syrup. It can be used in many ways.

These are the best cherries ever for Manhattans and topping for cheese cakes. The cherries are on the more tart side and the syrup is sweet but not sickeningly so. It is good for manhattans or ice cream. It can be used by international bartenders, baristas, and pastry chefs.

Why We Like This:

Perfect in manhattans or fruit cake too
Tasty syrup adds a sweet (but not too sweet) kick to any drink
Great flavor, beautiful container that can be reused for various things if you want
Just a bit deeper flavor than maraschino cherries

Best With liquor: Filthy food garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The filthy food garnish old fashioned cherry's high-end materials makes sure that it ages well with use. If you are looking for cocktail cherries, these are the absolute best. They last for ages so nothing goes to waste. Refrigerating the cherries just makes the sugar crystallize. It is the best tasting cherry for an old fashion. These cherries could be very good on top of a cheesecake, but the syrup they are in is thinner and the cherries themselves are not as sweet as your usual pie cherries.

These are great cherries and the value for quantity received is excellent. They are perfect for grown-up manhattan cocktails.

Why We Like This:

Perfect ingredient for the perfect cocktail
A must try for cocktail lovers and bakers
Delicious, rich sweet and sour flavor

Best With stem: Woodford Reserve garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The woodford reserve garnish old fashioned cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. These are the only cherries to use for a great manhattan. They are cherries you want to pluck from your glass when you’re done and pop into your mouth. It is used for making "old fashioned" cocktail, and topping for ice cream sundae. They have the stems for easy finding and picking out of your drink.

The syrup is excellent over ice cream. It is a full cherry, with a complete stem, not dehydrated and rehydrated. The product makes a good cocktail garnish, better taste than typical maraschino cherries. They are on the pricy side but totally worth it for those special occasions.

Why We Like This:

Great flavor while garnishing your guests cocktail
Very tasty addition to an old fashioned or any other cocktail
Makes a delicious manhattan and does not contain harmful chemicals

Best For So many different recipes: Traverse City Whiskey Co garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

If you are searching for a satisfactory cherry for your daily usage, you cannot go wrong with the traverse city whiskey co garnish old fashioned cherry. These cherries have a great flavor and are great in Old Fashions. It makes it difficult to get cherries out of a jar. They have such a rich, thick syrup that they are packed in and add great flavor to your favorite cocktails. The syrup is definitely yummy and sweet. It's Definitely superior to your normal grocery store maraschino cherry but the flavor is a bit anemic compared to luxardo or peninsula.

These cherries have the perfect flavor and texture for cocktails. They are packed in and add great flavor to your favorite cocktails. It's also good in whiskey sours and bailey's irish creme drinks.

Why We Like This:

Excellent value and natural ingredients like black carrot juice for color
Tasty and necessary for a classic old fashioned
Perfect for manhattans and old fashions
Perfect cocktail cherries when you make an old fashioned

Best For Bourbon: Barrel Roll bar essentials garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The barrel roll bar essentials garnish old fashioned cherry should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. No decent kitchen or bar is complete without these premium cherries. These dark reserve cherries are made with dark cherry juice, elderberry juice, and vanilla on top of its infusion with barrel-aged bourbon for that distinct taste you’ll love. It is ideal for various drinks like whiskey-made cocktails or the barrel roll old fashioned and manhattan mixes. These are carefully and slowly cooked by hand in small batches to extract the most out of the fruit’s natural taste without ruining its texture.

These delicious fruits are a wonderful garnish or ingredient for charcuterie boards, cheese plates, desserts, and cocktails. It’s perfect for parties, too. This large size means you have more than enough for those cherry cravings as well as your favorite recipes.

Why We Like This:

One of the new comers and featured product
Delivers what they promise

Best For Whiskey: Traverse City Whiskey Co. garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

The traverse city whiskey co. garnish old fashioned cherry should be able to handle its purpose and duties with ease. These cherries are way more delicious than the standard maraschino cherries you can get in the grocery store. They bring back all the good memories of summers in Traverse City, beaches, starry nights, and drinks with friends. They come in a branded box that protects the glass jar and makes for a lovely presentation. The syrup is a nice topper for brownies or vanilla ice cream.

These are dense and packed to the brim of the jar. The cherries themselves have a deep, rich flavor without the sugary gag of maraschinos. They are sweet and savory, without the sticky and acrid taste that waxy imitations have. Great taste and flavor and more importantly the cherries have a really good texture/form.

Why We Like This:

Rich thick syrup even goes great on ice cream
Super easy way to level-up your home cocktail game
New and hot release

Best For Old Fashioned Cocktail: Ved garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The ved garnish old fashioned cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. A cocktail cherry on top of an ice cream sundae is great, but there are few things as satisfying as a Maraschino cherry at the bottom of an old fashioned cocktail or Manhattan cocktail glass. The Ved gourmet cherries are your go-to destination for ice cream and pastry decor. Unlike the red cherries of the ice cream parlor, these gourmet cocktail cherries come in a burgundy-red hue that adds luxury to your drinks.

The Ved cocktail cherries are hand-picked of the finest marasca cherries in the rich mountains of Italy and offered in tightly sealed jars that will keep them fresh and delicious for longer. These are non-gmo, gluten-free, and vegan. It is suitable for any healthy diet.

Why We Like This:

Looking for mouth-watering old fashioned cherries for your cocktails or baked delicacies
Candied fresh, offered in safe jars
A great addition to any healthy diet

Best For those: generic garnish Old Fashioned Cherry

Buy on Amazon

We know from years of feedback from readers, customers and amazon sellers, what most people want in a convenient and appropriate cherry. The generic garnish old fashioned cherry is exactly that - it's a simple cherry that hits all the right notes. Deep purple and juicy, these cherries are perfect for those looking for an authentic option. These cocktail garnishes are the ideal gift for parties, housewarming, weddings, birthdays, or just as a surprise gift for cocktail connoisseurs. It is perfect for adding the finishing touch, the candied orange twists and stemless amarena cherries are the best way to achieve authentic cocktails that you’d find at even the most prestigious bars.

Why We Like This: